Protected: Handbook Clinical Reasoning

This content is password-protected. To view it, please enter the password below.

Review edition, November 2026. Online for a limited time. © Crijnen & Kraan 2026. All rights reserved.

This page holds the full text of the review edition of Clinical Reasoning: A Small Physiology of the Noticed Body by Alfons A. M. Crijnen and Herro F. Kraan, the companion volume to The Medical Interview. The book follows a complaint from the patient’s words back to the mechanism that produced it, and on to its cause and a plan. We place it here for a short time so that colleagues and reviewers can read it next to the Preps. We welcome your comments at info@maas-mi.eu.

Terms of use. This copy is for personal review only. Please do not copy, download, distribute or quote it. The authors reserve all rights of text and data mining under Article 4(3) of EU Directive 2019/790: no part of this text may be used to train, prompt or feed any AI system.

Before You Begin

Every patient begins with something felt. A burning behind the breastbone, a pressure on the stairs, a tiredness that will not lift: the complaint is the first fact of medicine, the thing the patient carries across the threshold and into the room. This book begins there, and reads from the complaint the patient brings back to the mechanism that produced it.

Physiology describes how the body works; pathology, how disease unfolds once it has a name. This book joins the two along the path the patient travels: from a sensation first noticed to the mechanism it reports. It is a small physiology of the body as it is felt.

It makes one promise: follow the flow from the quiet, unnoticed body to the spoken complaint, and you will begin to read, in every patient, the mechanism at work beneath the skin.

The core approach

One idea carries the whole book, and it is worth stating plainly before anything is built on it. A complaint is the mark a mechanism leaves in a region of the body. The book gives the complaint three names, each for one side of the same thing. The feel is what the patient experiences. The grammar is the fixed pattern the patient reports the feel in. The signature is the mark itself: a mechanism met in a region. As an equation, in the order the body produces it:

mechanism × region = complaint

Read the × as met in: a mechanism met in a region. What the patient hands you is the grammar, in four dimensions: the quality, the place, the timing and the companions (the symptoms that come with the complaint). The mechanism and the region stay hidden across the desk. Clinical reasoning reads the equation from right to left, from the signature back to the mechanism and region that made it. The book calls this the read-back; the follow-up confirms the result. That single move, repeated, is the whole book. Chapter 1 names the equation, the page after this one draws it, and Chapter 4 treats it in full. The three names, and the rest of the book’s fixed vocabulary, are defined once in the Glossary (Appendix 6).

The purpose of all this reasoning is simple to say. From what the patient feels and says, the interview reaches the few explanations most likely to be right and the ones most dangerous to miss. The interview also comes to understand the person well enough to act, with them, on what it finds.

Five threads

Five ideas run through everything that follows. The book is written through them, and each is taken up in full later.

  1. The grammar is the mechanism’s signature. A disturbance in a given place reports itself in a typical way, so the feel can be read from a few principles, with far less to memorise.
  2. Read by mechanism, across the organs. One disturbance turns up at many addresses: ischaemia as angina, claudication, mesenteric pain, a TIA.
  3. Health is quiet, and a complaint is that quiet breaking. Illness begins when the body’s defences are overrun (Chapter 2), and a sensation crosses into notice, and then into words.
  4. A mechanism you have read back is a hypothesis until it is tested: by the modifying factors, the rule-out and the follow-up. And the grammar can report less than is there: some patients, and some diseases, say less than the mechanism is doing (Chapters 6 and 8).
  5. The mechanism, handed back, is often the point. For many patients the explanation is what they came for (Chapter 10), and giving it back is where this book meets its companion, The Medical Interview.

The two books

This is one of a pair. The Medical Interview: A Handbook for Primary Care and Hospital Care teaches how to elicit the grammar at the bedside — the heuristics, the questions, the right words in the right order. Clinical Reasoning teaches what the grammar means — the mechanism it is a signature of, and how to read it back to a diagnosis. The interview supplies the technique; this book supplies the content. Together they are one method: you ask with the same heuristics in the one book and reason with them in the other. The interview’s items, with what to explore and how to score them, are at www.maas-mi.eu, and Appendix 1 gives the history-taking items with the question each one asks.

The running text is kept light. A source is named in the text only where a claim rests on particular evidence. Each chapter ends with its references, and Further Reading (Appendix 7) gives the wider reading, including the three works drawn on throughout. The history-taking items this book reasons from are listed in Appendix 1.

Who this book is for

The book assumes you have met the body once already — the preclinical physiology and anatomy of the systems it reads — and have begun to see patients, enough that a biliary colic or an angina is more than words on a page. It is written for the clinical years and beyond: students crossing onto the wards, trainees, and clinicians refreshing how they reason. Inside a curriculum, the method can start earlier and be spread over the years: the clean complaints and the framework first, and the harder kinds of complaint as students gain the knowledge to handle them. The teaching appendix (Appendix 5) takes that up.

Reading this book

The book follows one progression, and reading it in order lets you feel the reasoning as a single continuous line. Chapters 1 and 2 describe the noticed body and the quiet body beneath it, and Chapter 3 the grammar a complaint is reported in. Part II (Chapters 4 and 5) crosses to the mechanism and the region the complaint reports. Part III reasons on from there. Chapter 6 reads the complaint back to its mechanism, and Chapter 7 carries the reasoning on to the cause and the plan. Chapters 8 and 9 take the two edges: complaints noticed by someone other than the patient, and the sensitised reporter, where the sensation persists while the tissue is sound. They are edges of the model; in practice both are common, the sensitised reporter among the commonest presentations in primary care. Chapter 10 closes the loop at follow-up.

Early learners: read in order — the arc is the point. Clinicians and teachers: dip in by mechanism or by family, and use the one-page architecture at the front, the review of systems, complaint by complaint (Appendix 3), and the Reasoning Reference (Appendix 2) to find your way. You will meet Sarah Nolan, whose burning behind the breastbone opens the book, and Anna Petrov, whose chest pressure on the walk uphill carries the reasoning through to treatment.

A note on notation: the shorthand mechanism × region and the arrow → mark the read-back from feel to mechanism; the heuristics are H1–H4 (reaching the mechanism) and H5–H7 (reaching the cause and the plan); Red Flags are the cannot-miss mechanisms the rule-out must exclude every time. The cases give 999, the UK emergency number; use your local one (112 across Europe, 911 in North America).

From reading to practice

Reading teaches the what and the why; the reasoning becomes yours only by using it. The practice lives beyond this book: in MAAS-Prep, where you drill the reasoning in short blocks, and in MAAS Practice, where you work it through cases. Then come the steps from paper cases to simulated patients to real ones, each a step closer to the live encounter. How a curriculum orders those steps is the subject of the teaching appendix.

Each chapter follows the same plan: learning objectives, a patient, the teaching sections, a summary of what you have learned, and the Reflections. Two supports sit inside the book itself. Each chapter ends with Reflections: open scenarios with “Think about” prompts and no answer key, meant to connect what you have read with the patients you meet. And Prep signposts point into MAAS-Prep, online at www.maas-mi.eu. One principle governs those exercises: they drill the mechanism, the reasoning this book teaches. Where a moment calls for interview technique, the book says so and leaves the drilling to its companion. Practise the read-back until it is second nature, and each complaint becomes a signal to read: one of the quiet pleasures of medicine.

The Architecture on One Page

Everything stands on the quiet working of the body. Read the page from the bottom up.

mechanism × region = complaint

Read the × as met in. The grammar is what you can observe; reading from right to left, you find the mechanism and the region.

↑ clinical reasoning climbs from the complaint to the diagnosis

follow-up: does the predicted relief come, or a complication? The loop closes ↻

Diagnosis
the named condition, completed by its cause

↑

Aetiology
the cause beneath it

↑

Family
a group of related mechanisms

↑

Mechanism × Region
the disturbance, and the place it strikes; together they produce the feel

downwards ↓: mechanism and region produce the feel  ·  upwards ↑: “what makes it better or worse?” (H3) tests which mechanism it is

↑

Grammar
how the feel is reported: quality, location, timing, companions

↑

Complaint
a sensation or lost function given meaning

↑ a disturbance crosses the threshold

Quiet Body
the regulated body, below the threshold of notice

The read-back, from the feel to the mechanism: H1 Complaint → quality + location · H2 course → timing · H3 what changes it → tests the mechanism · H4 what else → companions (what comes with it) · Red Flags: the cannot-miss is ruled out before you settle.

Reasoning patterns (Chapter 6): schema-based · branching · rule-out · pattern recognition.

The second half (Chapter 7): H5–H7 carry the read-back on to the cause and the plan.

The two edges: the informant notices (Chapter 8); the reporter is sensitised (Chapter 9).

At each level: 6 region-types · 17 mechanisms · 5 families + mechanical, the seventeenth · 7 aetiologies.

Chapter 1 · The Noticed Body

Learning objectives

  • Explain why a healthy body is almost never felt, and what a symptom actually reports
  • Describe the threshold-crossing that turns an unnoticed sensation into a complaint
  • Read the review of systems as the vocabulary of the noticed body
  • Recognise seven quality-word signatures that each point at a mechanism
  • State the equation, mechanism × region = complaint, and the working rule: the feature the patient reports carries the mechanism, and the follow-up question tests it
  • Name the four heuristics, H1–H4, and the part of the grammar each brings out

Sarah Nolan, 42, is a schoolteacher. She sits down in your consulting room, apologises for being early, and says: “For about three weeks I’ve had this burning behind my breastbone. Mostly after supper. It’s not painful, exactly — more like a slow burn. I ignored it for a while, but my mother had heart trouble, so I thought I should get it checked.”

Sit with what she has just done. Three weeks ago, something in her body changed. The change had been happening quietly — probably for longer than three weeks — while she taught, marked papers, made dinner, went to bed. At some point, on one particular evening, the change crossed a line. She noticed. She gave it a word: burning. She gave it a place: behind my breastbone. She gave it a time: after supper. And, without deciding to, she gave it a meaning: her mother’s heart trouble, danger, worth checking. Between the moment she first felt it and the moment she sat down opposite you, a complaint was born.

Every patient’s journey begins with this crossing. First a sensation is noticed, then it is named, then it is given a meaning. Your work with Sarah begins there too. Before you ask what is wrong, you need to know what she has already told you: the shape of the sensation she brought across her own threshold and into the room.

This chapter is about that threshold. Why was Sarah’s body almost invisible to her until three weeks ago? What has changed? What do the words she chose tell you (burning, behind my breastbone, after supper)? How much of the diagnosis is already in those three phrases? And what does “small” mean in the subtitle, A Small Physiology of the Noticed Body?

The Quiet Body

Sarah’s body has been busy every second of her life. Her heart has beaten roughly one and a half billion times. Her diaphragm has moved for every one of her breaths. Her kidneys have filtered around a hundred and eighty litres of plasma today alone. Her gut has moved food along by peristaltic waves she has never had to think about. Her oesophageal mucosa — the very lining that now burns — has been quietly renewing itself, guarded by the sphincter at its lower end, cleared by peristalsis and swallowed saliva, and sealed by its tight lining, keeping acid on one side and tissue on the other. None of this has reached her attention.

These processes send signals all the time: a constant stream of interoceptive signals, the body’s reports on its own internal state. The brain has learned what to expect from a process that works well, and a signal that matches the expectation does not reach awareness. You do not feel your heartbeat when it beats as expected, or your stomach fill when the meal is ordinary.

Physiology names six ways the body achieves this: negative feedback, reserve, redundancy, adaptation, anticipation and perceptual filtering. Chapter 2 explains each of them. While they work, the signals match what the brain expects, and we are spared the details. What matters here is the result: most of the time we hardly notice our body at all. If we felt everything the body does, we could not function. The great achievement of health is its silence.

When the balance shifts — physiologically (a hard run, a heavy meal, standing up too fast) or pathologically (inflammation, ischaemia, obstruction) — the signal changes. It stops matching what the brain predicts. Depending on the direction and the size of the mismatch, one of two things happens: the sensation crosses into notice as something present that was not there before (a burning, a pressure, a tearing), or a function crosses into notice by being missing (the word that will not come, the step the foot did not clear). Either way, the body has stopped being quiet.

A symptom is the report of this change: the news that regulation has failed somewhere, before any diagnosis or disease has a name. Three things shape the report: what the body could no longer keep within its safe range, how fast the failure came, and in which tissue. Together they decide what the patient feels, and so the word the patient chooses. Sarah’s burning is exactly how an unprotected mucosa reports contact with acid. The word carries the mechanism inside it.

Here is the idea the whole book rests on. The sensation is the physiology itself, felt at the moment the body stops defending a process, that is, can no longer keep it within its safe range. It reaches awareness through a reporter, the nerves and the brain that weigh the signal; in most complaints the reporter works as it should, and the feel reports a tissue. How Sarah came to notice it, and what it means to her, belongs to the interview: her fear, her mother’s heart trouble, the sense that today was the day. The Medical Interview handbook gives that meaning its full place. This book reads the sensation itself. In practice: when you meet a symptom, ask first which physiological process the sensation reports; the diagnostic name comes later. Chapter 2 looks at what the physiology does before the threshold, and Chapter 3 at what it becomes when it crosses.

One limit should be marked now. In some cases the sensation no longer comes from a tissue in trouble: in sensitised chronic pain, in phantom-limb sensations, in some functional syndromes. There the physiology that is felt is the reporter’s own. Chapter 9 treats the best-characterised of these cases on their own terms, as the sensitised reporter: the nervous system that reports on the body has itself become oversensitive. The others reach the same edge by other mechanisms. Until then we use the idea in its usual form.

See MAAS-Prep 1.1 to practise identifying what has stopped being defended: given a short patient statement, name the regulatory failure the sensation is reporting.

See MAAS-Prep 1.2 to practise recognising the threshold-crossing: given a patient history, mark the moment the sensation moved from unnoticed to noticed — and identify what tipped it.

What “Small” Means

The subtitle of this book is A Small Physiology of the Noticed Body, and small is easily misread, so it is worth being clear at once. “Small” refers to the signals: the small, quiet, characteristic signals the body makes. They hum below awareness while a process runs well, and cross into notice when it is disturbed. Sarah’s burning is small in this sense: quiet, only just being heard. The word says nothing about the size of the physiology; Costanzo and Robbins remain the textbooks this book draws on, for the unstable patient in intensive care as much as for the patient in the clinic.

The book’s method follows from this. The method begins with the noticed sensation and treats it as diagnostic in its own right. A pathophysiology textbook runs from mechanism to disease to complaint; this book runs from the complaint back to the mechanism that produced it, the direction in which a clinician works. And it stays close to the noticed signal: it teaches the physiology needed to explain what the patient felt, and no more.

The same method changes how physiology and pathology relate. In the standard picture, physiology and pathology are two disciplines: physiology tells you how a healthy system works; pathology tells you how a diseased one goes wrong. They are usually taught separately, sometimes in different years of the curriculum, sometimes by different departments.

In the sensation-first picture, they are two readings of the same process. Sarah’s oesophageal mucosa works physiologically while its defences hold: the sphincter, the clearing waves, the tight junctions of its lining. It turns pathological when acid overruns those defences and irritates the unprotected epithelium, and the burning reaches notice. The tissue is the same, and so are the molecules. The disease is the physiology carried on past its threshold. That is why this book writes pathophysiology as one word: one object, read at two moments.

Reading the two as one makes your knowledge lighter to carry. What you need to learn is where the threshold lies, what tips the process from quiet to reporting.

See MAAS-Prep 1.3 to practise reading the same process in health and in disease: given a tissue and its process, describe the physiological version (below threshold) and the pathological version (above), and name what tipped the balance.

The Lexicon of the Noticed Body

Every clinician learns a review of systems — a list of symptoms grouped by organ system, memorised in medical school, walked through in the consultation. The MAAS Review of Systems has fifty-five entries. Traditionally the list is treated as a checklist: a set of items to run through so that nothing important is missed.

The review of systems can also be read another way: as the language patients use when the quiet body crosses into notice. Read like this, it is the vocabulary of the noticed body, collected from what patients say: burning, pressure, cramping, tearing, numbness, dizziness, the words they reach for when a threshold is crossed. The fifty-five entries are then what the noticed body has to say, grouped by organ system and ordered by how often patients bring them to the consultation.

Seen this way, the list has three consequences. First, the word itself carries diagnostic weight: burning is the way one particular kind of injury reports. Second, the review of systems works as a reading primer: you learn it so that you can read what the patient says. Third, the list is a sample. There are more ways the body can be noticed than there are entries; some sensations are folded together, and some, found only on examination or screening, never come in as a chief complaint. The list is a working vocabulary for practice, and makes no claim to classify every sensation.

Each entry also has a place. Burning behind the breastbone is a different report from burning on the tip of the tongue, though the word is the same, because the place tells you which tissue is involved, and the same mechanism feels different in different tissue. That tissue and place, the region, is one of the two things that make a complaint; the mechanism is the other. The book writes this as its equation: mechanism × region = complaint. What the patient reports is the result of the two together: how it feels, where it is felt, when it comes and what comes with it. The book calls this pattern the grammar, and the grammar is the mechanism’s signature. Read the grammar, and you read the equation from right to left, back to the mechanism; from the mechanism you reach the diagnosis. Sarah’s three phrases, burning, behind the breastbone, after supper, already carry the quality, the location and the timing. She has done more of your work than she realises.

The rest of the book is the reading manual for those signatures. Chapter 2 slows the body down enough to see how it stays quiet in the first place. Chapter 3 sets out the grammar: the four dimensions in which every complaint is reported (quality, location, timing, companions). Later chapters work through the mechanisms behind the reports, and the reasoning that goes back from the patient’s word to the diagnosis on the chart.

See MAAS-Prep 1.4 to practise taking a complaint apart: given a patient’s phrase, split it into quality, location and timing, and name what each points at.

Seven Words That Point at a Mechanism

Some of the reports the noticed body sends are cleaner than others. Seven quality-words, each taken with its location or its timing, usually point at one mechanism so clearly that a single follow-up question can confirm it. They are the easiest way into the book, the cases where the equation is easiest to see. Sarah’s burning is one of them. Later chapters refer back to this table as the Top-7.

What the patient saysThe follow-up that tests itWhat it points at
“Pressure on my chest”Brought on by walking, relieved by rest?Ischaemia
“Sharp, worse on a deep breath”Worse with cough or movement?Inflammation
“Cramping in waves, can’t lie still”Relieved by vomiting or passing gas?Obstruction
“Tearing, maximal from the first second”Reached its peak instantly?Vascular rupture (tear or leak)
“Burning, worse after meals”Better with an antacid?Tissue irritation
“Dizzy when I stand up”Only on sitting-to-standing?Hypoperfusion
“Pins and needles, sock pattern”Spreading distal-to-proximal?Neurogenic

Burning means an unprotected surface is in chemical contact; the follow-up (better with an antacid) confirms that the irritant is acid. If the answer is no, the mechanism is a different kind of irritation, and the reasoning shifts to a different line of questioning.

These seven pairs give the book its working rule. The feature the patient reports, whether a word, an image, a lump or a change in gait, carries the mechanism, and the follow-up question is the test that confirms it. In practice: whenever a patient reports a feature, ask which tissue and which mechanism would produce it. Then ask what would remove it, or bring it back, if that mechanism is right. The confirming question comes from the mechanism, so there is far less to memorise. Chapter 3 explains how this works; here we meet it in its simplest form.

In cases you know, pattern recognition does this work for you. In a presentation you have never met before, the rule is the tool you carry into the room.

These are the cleanest cases. Most complaints are not this clean: the same quality-word may point at more than one mechanism, or the region may change what the word means, or the important report is a companion sensation rather than the primary one. And even the cleanest of them often sits inside a complaint that still needs a dangerous cause ruled out: chest pain is read in this way and, at the same time, checked for aortic dissection, and a pleuritic pain is checked for pulmonary embolism. The rest of the book is written for these harder complaints. If you can read those seven, you can start to read the rest.

See MAAS-Prep 1.5 to practise the Top-7: given a patient’s quality-word, name the mechanism it points at and the single follow-up question that confirms it.

The Reasoning in Real Time

Sarah’s case is the fifth row, but arriving there is not one clean step. Watch the reasoning actually run.

Sarah says burning behind my breastbone, mostly after supper. The word burning catches your attention. Top-7 fifth row: tissue irritation by acid. Before settling, though, you check whether this is really burning or pressure described as burning. You ask her to say more. “Like a slow burn, not a squeeze.” Burning confirmed.

Retrosternal could be oesophagus or heart. The word alone does not decide. She has not tried an antacid, so you ask about the pattern: worse after supper, not on exertion. That tempo fits oesophageal irritation better than cardiac ischaemia, which typically comes on with exertion. But her mother had heart trouble, and although Sarah at 42 is low-risk, the risk is not zero. You order an ECG and a lipid panel — a safety-net alongside the leading hypothesis.

You start a two-week trial of a proton-pump inhibitor. If this is gastro-oesophageal reflux (GORD), the burning should ease. If it does not ease, GORD becomes less likely, and you return to the question of what makes the burning better or worse (H3, Section 6), to see which other mechanism the answer points to.

Three weeks later she returns. Burning almost gone on the PPI, back briefly when she skips a dose. ECG normal, lipids fine. Working diagnosis: GORD. The prediction held, and the return of the burning when she skipped a dose is the strongest support the trial can give. GORD stays the working diagnosis while follow-up continues: if the burning comes back when the course ends, or other features appear, the question reopens.

That is what the sensation-first method looks like in a clean case: one visit and one review. Harder cases use the same reasoning. Chest pain, for example, can come from six or more mechanisms, the chest wall the commonest in general practice (Haasenritter 2015), so several of them are tested and ruled out at the same time (Chapter 6).

The Interview Hears; This Book Reads

Four interview heuristics from The Medical Interview handbook recur throughout this book by their short names. A heuristic is a rule of thumb: a way of searching that brings the interview to the diagnosis quickly, without working through every possibility. H1 (the Complaint heuristic) asks what the sensation feels like and where; H2 (Time-Intensity) how it started and how it has evolved; H3 (Modifying Factors) what makes it better or worse; H4 (Context) what else is present, and the circumstances around it. A Red Flags sweep covers catastrophic possibilities. Together they bring out the grammar: H1 its quality and location, H2 its timing, H4 its companions, while H3 tests what the quality-word implies. Chapter 3 §7 shows why these are the right questions, and Chapter 6 shows how they carry the reasoning back from the complaint to the diagnosis.

The Medical Interview, the first book of the pair, is the instrument that hears the sensation. This book takes over where hearing ends and reading begins.

The two books meet at the moment Sarah says burning. The Medical Interview handbook teaches how to reach that word without cutting her off, how to make her comfortable enough to say it, and how to ask in a way that invites her to be specific. This book teaches what to do with the word once she has said it: how burning reports a particular kind of injury, which mechanism it implies, which follow-up will test that mechanism, and how to reason from the confirmed mechanism to the diagnosis.

For that reason this book repeats a small part of the handbook: the four heuristics that structure the interview, and the reasoning patterns that shape the diagnostic move. The sensation-first method works with the same tools. How to ask, how to pace the consultation, how to adjust to the patient, and what to say when the patient is anxious or the story is confusing: all of this lives in the handbook, with cross-references where they help. When we write “see the handbook on history-taking”, that is a deliberate division of labour.

Both books rest on one commitment: meet the patient’s experience on its own terms before you fit it to a diagnostic label. Phenomenology, the philosophy of lived experience, takes this stance, and this book calls it experience before category. In this book it means that a complaint is first a feel, something lived, and only then a grammar to read or a signature to trace back to its cause. The book keeps returning to this order. The Medical Interview handbook applies the stance in the interview; this book applies it to the body. The clinician who works this way reads the report a noticed body has just sent, and the differential follows from that reading.

See MAAS-Prep 1.6 to practise the hand-off: given a short consultation transcript, mark which heuristic (H1–H4) surfaced each part of the grammar, and name the mechanism it points at.

What You’ve Learned

Most of the time the body is quiet because its regulation works. What crosses into notice is a failure of that regulation: a signal that no longer matches what the brain expects. The word the patient chooses carries the shape of the failure, and so points at the mechanism. The review of systems is the vocabulary of the noticed body, grouped by organ system and ordered by how often patients bring each complaint. Seven of its words point at a mechanism so cleanly that one follow-up question confirms it; the rest of the book reads the harder cases with the same method. The Medical Interview handbook teaches you to hear the sensation; this book teaches what the sensation is. And reading a body this way, beginning with what the patient noticed, is also how you hand its meaning back to the person who brought it.

Reflections

Five open-ended scenarios for thinking, journaling, or peer discussion. No answer key: they are meant to connect what you have read with the patients you meet.

Reflection 1 — what has just crossed a threshold. A patient sits down and says: “I’ve been feeling really tired for a few months. I finally decided to come in.” Think about: what has crossed a threshold for this patient, and when? What has the sensation been like beforehand? Why did today become the day it was worth coming in for — and what might the answer to that tell you about the mechanism?

Reflection 2 — the word carries the mechanism. Two patients describe abdominal pain. The first says: “It cramps in waves, and I can’t sit still.” The second says: “It burns, and it’s worse an hour after eating.” Think about: what mechanism does each quality-word imply? What single follow-up question would test each? What would you expect to hear if the mechanism is right — and what would you hear if it is not?

Reflection 3 — the not-quite-noticed. A patient has been walking with a slight limp for the last six months. He has not noticed. His wife has. She has brought him in. Think about: whose noticing counts as the complaint here? What does it change about the way you take the history? What kind of signal is a slow gait change, and why is it more likely to be noticed by others than by the person walking?

Reflection 4 — the lexicon in practice. You are told a colleague is going to send you a patient with “abdominal complaints”. Before you see the patient, you have no other information. Think about: what quality-words are you listening for? What would each imply? What is the first open question you would ask that invites the patient to name their sensation in their own words rather than in yours?

Reflection 5 — physiology and pathology as one object. A trained runner has breathlessness at the end of a hard interval workout. An elderly man has breathlessness climbing the same flight of stairs he climbed last month. Think about: same sensation, same body system — what makes the first a signal below the threshold and the second a signal that has crossed it? Where does the boundary between physiology and pathology sit here, and what determines it?

From Here to Chapter 2

You have met the noticed body and the moment its sensation crosses into a complaint. To read those complaints, you first need to know what the body was doing while it was quiet: how it defends its balances, how it spends its reserves to stay quiet, and how those defences are lost when disease begins. Chapter 2 is the physiology of the quiet body, the ground the clinical material stands on.

References

  1. Barrett LF, Simmons WK. Interoceptive predictions in the brain. Nat Rev Neurosci. 2015;16(7):419–429. — the brain predicts the body’s own signals; what matches the prediction stays below awareness.
  2. Haasenritter J, Biroga T, Keunecke C, et al. Causes of chest pain in primary care: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Croat Med J. 2015;56(5):422–430. — in primary care the chest wall is the commonest cause of chest pain; cardiac causes account for a minority.
  3. Kulasegaram KM, Martimianakis MA, Mylopoulos M, Whitehead CR, Woods NN. Cognition before curriculum: rethinking the integration of basic science and clinical learning. Acad Med. 2013;88(10):1578–1585. — integration of basic science and clinical knowledge happens in the learner’s mind, and teaching helps it most by making the causal links explicit.
  4. Leder D. The Absent Body. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1990. — the body unnoticed in health, obtruding (“dys-appearing”) in illness.
  5. Schmidt HG, Rikers RMJP. How expertise develops in medicine: knowledge encapsulation and illness script formation. Med Educ. 2007;41(12):1133–1139. — as expertise grows, biomedical knowledge becomes encapsulated in clinical concepts and illness scripts, and stays available when a case does not fit.
  6. Woods NN. Science is fundamental: the role of biomedical knowledge in clinical reasoning. Med Educ. 2007;41(12):1173–1177. — students who learned the causal basic science behind a disease remembered its features better and diagnosed more accurately after a delay.

Chapter 2 · The Quiet Body

Learning objectives

  • Describe how the body’s quiet is an active achievement
  • Name the six achievements that hold the body below the threshold of notice
  • Explain the compensation gap — why signs appear before symptoms, and why patients who feel fine may not be fine
  • Distinguish the three modes by which defence is overrun and illness arrives
  • Recognise how context sets the threshold at which a signal becomes a complaint

Frank Aldrich, 68, sits down for his annual check. He is a retired shop foreman, still active, still walks the dog. He has no complaints. His blood pressure is 128/78. Heart rate is 74. Oxygen saturation is 97%. He weighs the same he did last year.

By any measurement your practice takes at the door, Frank is well.

You listen to his chest anyway. There is a slow, harsh crescendo-decrescendo murmur at the right upper sternal border, radiating to his carotids. His pulse is slow-rising, and the second heart sound is soft. The murmur has been noted before, growing louder over the last three years. You ask him to walk with you to the end of the corridor and back. He does. When he sits down again, he takes a breath and says: “I’m slower than I used to be. My wife has been telling me for months.”

Frank has brought no complaint today. The disease that has been changing his heart is old: a calcified aortic valve, and a ventricle that has thickened year by year in silent response. It has been advancing for a decade, and for all that time his body has compensated so quietly that Frank never had to notice. What is new is that his reserve is beginning to run out, and his wife has seen it before he has. When compensation fails, the sensation will cross his own threshold, and Frank will come with a complaint of his own. Today he is still quiet, and the quiet is doing enormous work.

Chapter 1 said that most of the time we hardly notice our body at all. This chapter looks at how the body achieves that. The quiet is an achievement: it costs something to maintain, and it has a limit. When the limit is reached, illness arrives in a small number of characteristic ways. Once you understand the quiet, you can see the crossing coming, and you can see why it comes when it does.

Quiet Is an Achievement

In health the body works to stay quiet. It holds values such as blood pressure, glucose and temperature within ranges narrow enough that the brain has no reason to raise the alarm. Six achievements, working together, do this: the recurring ways a well-run body keeps itself quiet.

Negative feedback (homeostasis). Sensors monitor a value (blood pH, glucose, oxygen tension, blood pressure, core temperature, plasma osmolality), and effectors correct any deviation before it becomes noticeable. Insulin and glucagon hold glucose. Baroreceptors adjust cardiac output and vascular tone to hold arterial pressure. Chemoreceptors adjust ventilation to hold arterial pH and O₂. The loops run continuously, quietly, and mostly successfully.

Reserve. Organs are overbuilt for resting demand. We have two kidneys where one would do; the liver can lose half its parenchyma before function drops; the heart can quadruple its output on demand. Small losses are absorbed in silence; a person can donate a kidney and not notice.

Redundancy. Overlapping pathways and paired organs cover for one another. Collateral circulation grows where a vessel narrows slowly. One lung compensates for the other. In the brain, neighbouring areas and pathways can take over part of the work, so that a small stroke may leave function almost intact.

Adaptation. Sustained demand remodels the tissue. The trained heart enlarges. The runner’s tendons and bones thicken. Long exposure to a hormone or a drug raises or lowers the number of its receptors. Physiologists call this kind of stability allostasis: stability achieved through change. The body’s target values, its setpoints, shift with the circumstances: day and night, cold and heat, sea level and altitude.

Anticipation. Regulation also looks ahead. Before you eat, your salivary glands and gastric mucosa begin their preparation. Before you stand, your sympathetic nervous system raises vascular tone and heart rate. Before you exercise, your heart rate and breathing rise in anticipation of the coming demand. Supply meets demand before the deviation happens.

Perceptual filtering. The brain gets used to steady, expected signals from inside the body and stops passing them on to awareness. You do not feel your heartbeat, because it matches what the brain predicts. You do not feel your gut move, because the movement is expected. This filter can also be set wrong. When it is set too sensitive, the brain gives an ordinary signal too much weight, or expects trouble so strongly that the expectation itself is felt; what should stay below notice is then felt, and felt again. That is the ground of the sensitised reporter, which Chapter 9 takes up.

Frank has five of the six at work. His baroreflex holds his blood pressure at 128/78 while the valve limits his output. His heart draws on its reserve to push blood through the narrowed valve. His thickened ventricle is adaptation. His sympathetic system prepares his circulation before he moves, so he can start walking without trouble. And his brain has learned to pass over the slight breathlessness when he begins to exert himself. These achievements work out of sight, so that Frank can walk his dog, sit down at your desk and say nothing is wrong.

See MAAS-Prep 2.1 to practise recognising the six achievements: given a body system in a specific situation, name which achievements are at work to keep it quiet.

What Adjustment Costs

The body adjusts constantly. Most adjustments are so small they never cross into notice: an extra beat when you stand, a slight change in respiratory rate when you walk uphill, a subtle vasoconstriction when the room is cold. These are silent because they are successful.

Larger adjustments do produce sensation, and the sensation fits what the body is doing. You feel breathless on a hard run because ventilation has risen; the sensation has a purpose, and the brain accepts it as fitting the context. A sensation that fits stays a sensation. The same breathlessness at rest, without an obvious cause, becomes a complaint.

Context does this work. The brain mostly accepts a signal it expected, and is far more likely to notice one it did not expect: the bigger the surprise, the more the signal stands out. So the same physiological event can pass unnoticed at one moment and stand out at the next. Section 4 returns to context and to the history that finds it out.

The larger the adjustment, the more the body spends. Reserve is finite. Every extra beat, every recruited nephron, every hypertrophied muscle fibre is capacity taken out of the bank. The body may still hold the values it defends within their range (blood pressure, oxygen saturation, glucose, cardiac output), and it does so at a rising cost.

The effort of compensating is detectable on examination before it is felt by the patient. An early shock patient has a normal blood pressure. But their peripheries are cool because vasoconstriction is holding the pressure; their heart rate is elevated because tachycardia is holding the cardiac output; their skin is pale, their urine output has fallen, their capillary refill is prolonged. Blood pressure, the value being defended, is normal; the effort of the defence can be seen. Wait long enough and the defence fails: blood pressure falls sharply, the patient becomes unwell, and the alarm is finally raised. The signs were there long before the symptom.

This is the compensation gap: the visible tip of the illness (the symptom) is a small part of what is going on; the compensating body underneath is what a careful examination reveals.

Signs come before symptoms in mild illness too. The same examination, often with the stethoscope more than the eye, hears the crackle of a mild chest infection or the rub of a small inflammation well before the patient would call it serious. Examination informs across the whole range of severity, from the mild case to the catastrophic one.

The compensation gap gives a short rule for practice: feeling fine does not mean being fine. Examine the patient who does not complain, and observe them under load (walking, standing, exertion), because that is where the compensating body shows its cost.

During Frank’s corridor walk you are not looking for the murmur — you heard that already. You are looking at reserve. His pace is slower than his baseline. On return he takes one large breath before speaking, then his sentence. As he sits down he does not lean forward or grip the arm-rests, so he is in no acute distress; still, it costs him more effort than he wants to show.

Ask him to compare with three months ago. “I used to walk faster than my wife.” In that sentence his reserve speaks: he reports the compensation gap that the numbers hide. He now sleeps on two pillows. He has never been breathless at rest. So decompensation, the moment compensation begins to fail, has started and is not yet complete.

The working picture is aortic stenosis, probably severe: the murmur and its radiation to the carotids point to the valve; the slow-rising pulse, the soft second sound and his symptoms point to severity. The stenosis is beginning to decompensate: his gait is slower, he has orthopnoea (breathlessness lying flat), and his wife noticed before he did. Working diagnosis: symptomatic aortic stenosis, NYHA class II. The symptoms are there, though Frank has not yet called them a complaint. Next: urgent echocardiogram this week and a cardiology referral for consideration of valve replacement. Safety-net: call 999 (the UK emergency number; use your local one) if he faints or has chest pain; return the same day if he wakes short of breath.

The corridor walk was the diagnostic test itself: it showed the cost. The working picture is made at the bedside; the echo confirms the valve lesion and grades how severe it is. Here lies the difference between examination as ritual (blood pressure, heart rate, temperature) and examination as procedure: what is this body defending, and at what cost?

The same adaptations that keep the body quiet can, over time, become the disease. Chronic hypertension drives ventricular hypertrophy. At first the thicker wall lets the ventricle keep its output against the higher pressure; then it stiffens the ventricle and causes diastolic failure. Chronic sympathetic activation holds cardiovascular tone under stress; sustained, it drives cardiovascular disease. What protected the body earlier becomes the ground of illness later. The technical name is allostatic load.

When you meet a patient with a chronic condition, part of what you are meeting is a body that has been compensating for years. That compensation may itself need treatment, as part of the illness.

See MAAS-Prep 2.2 to practise reading the compensation gap: given a patient who feels fine, name the sign the body is likely to be showing that the symptom is not yet reporting.

When Defence Is Overrun — Three Modes

Compensation buys time, and only so much of it. When the body can no longer hold the value it defends, illness arrives, in one of three characteristic modes. They are the usual shapes of failure and do not cover every case: a sudden overwhelming injury, or a mass that grows into a tissue, can fit more than one, and real illnesses can combine them. Usually one mode dominates, and recognising it is often the first diagnostic step.

Reserve exhausted. The commonest mode. Compensation has kept the value inside its range for as long as reserve allowed. Reserve runs out. The value finally deviates, and the deviation raises the alarm. This is what is now happening to Frank. For a decade his ventricle pushed blood through an ever narrower valve; now his reserve is falling below what he needs to walk at his old pace, and he slows down. When the complaint comes, it will be the failure of the defence. Diseases that present like this include heart failure (systolic reserve exhausted), chronic kidney disease (nephron reserve exhausted), COPD (respiratory reserve exhausted), cirrhosis (hepatic reserve exhausted). The characteristic history is a slow-progressing disease that presents suddenly: the disease has been running for years, but the sensation has crossed only recently, because reserve has only recently run out.

Adaptation outpaced. Adaptation takes time. Collaterals grow over months; hypertrophy remodels over years; receptor up-regulation happens over weeks. A slow disturbance lets the body adapt and stay quiet. A fast disturbance can outrun the adaptation: the same lesion can be silent when it comes slowly and lethal when it comes fast. Coronary atherosclerosis is the classic example. A vessel that narrows over years may develop collateral supply, and the patient may live with severe stenosis without symptoms. The same vessel, occluded acutely by a ruptured plaque, causes myocardial infarction — because the collaterals had no time to form. This is why onset speed — the H2 question — is diagnostically powerful: the tempo tells you whether the process outran the compensation or the compensation held long enough to remodel around it.

Regulator broken. Here the control system itself is damaged, and the value drifts because nothing defends it any more. The clearest case is type 1 diabetes: the beta cells that sense glucose and release insulin are destroyed, and blood glucose climbs because the regulator itself is gone. Hypothyroidism and Addison’s disease are the same shape — a failed gland, a value left undefended. The pattern repeats outside endocrinology: no compensating tachycardia when the pacemaker cells die, no muscle recruitment when the motor neuron is lost. Because a broken regulator is often a silent one, this mode frequently presents as loss of function rather than as a positive signal. Dementia does not hurt; hearing loss does not throb; slow gait change generates no pain. The patient may not notice; the family often does. Chapter 3 calls this the negative departure, a crossing by loss of function, and it returns in Chapter 8 as its own clinical territory.

Recognising which mode is at work orients the history-taking before any specific mechanism is identified. The mode answers the body’s “why now”: why it crossed its threshold at this moment. The patient has a “why now” of their own: why they came today, and why they did not come sooner. The interview explores that with the reasons for encounter.

See MAAS-Prep 2.3 to practise the three modes: given a case, decide which mode brought the illness (reserve exhausted, adaptation outpaced or regulator broken) and name the H2 or H4 signal that tells you which.

Context Sets the Threshold

Breathless on a hard run at the end of a set of intervals is a signal the runner accepts. Breathless walking to the postbox is a signal the same person brings in. The stimulus itself rarely explains the difference; the context usually does.

Three things set the threshold: the size of the signal, the patient’s own disposition, and the context. Context is the one the history is built to find out. Every quality-word the patient uses is spoken against a context. When a patient reports a sensation, H4 (context) finds out the circumstances: when did this happen, what were you doing, what would you have expected? Against that frame you decide whether the signal fits the situation or reports a problem.

Two consequences follow. First, a signal at rest is more likely to mean disease than the same signal on exertion, because rest was expected to produce nothing. A patient who is short of breath climbing stairs may still be well; a patient who is short of breath sitting in your office is not. Second, changes in the usual context — walking to the corner where the patient always walked without difficulty, becoming breathless doing the shopping the patient always did — are more diagnostic than absolute measures, because the patient has effectively provided their own baseline.

See MAAS-Prep 2.4 to practise reading context: given the same sensation in two different contexts, decide which fits the situation and which has crossed into a complaint — and explain what makes the difference.

What You’ve Learned

In health the body actively holds its values within ranges that give the brain no reason to raise the alarm. Six achievements do this work — negative feedback, reserve, redundancy, adaptation, anticipation, and perceptual filtering — and every one of them costs something to run. Because compensation has a detectable cost before it has a felt one, patients who feel fine may not be fine: examination finds the defence that the symptom has not yet reported. When defence is finally overrun, illness arrives in one of three modes — reserve exhausted, adaptation outpaced, or regulator broken — and knowing which mode is at work orients the reasoning before any specific mechanism is identified. Over years, the compensation can itself become the disease. Above all, context sets the threshold. Whether a signal fits or reports a problem depends on what the body was expected to be doing, and the history is how you find that out.

Reflections

Five open-ended scenarios for thinking, journaling, or peer discussion. No answer key: they are meant to connect what you have read with the patients you meet.

Reflection 1 — reading the quiet. A patient with well-controlled diabetes and long-standing hypertension walks into your clinic and reports feeling fine. Her BP is 130/80. Her heart rate is 78. Her glucose today is 6.1. Think about: what work is her body doing, right now, to keep those numbers in that range? Which of the six achievements are at play? What would you expect to find on examination that a normal set of vital signs would not show?

Reflection 2 — signs before symptoms. An 82-year-old man is brought in by his daughter. She is worried; he is not. He walks in slowly. His BP is 118/72. His pulse is 96 and thready. His skin is cool. His capillary refill is four seconds. He says he feels “a bit tired, that’s all.” Think about: what is his body defending, and at what cost? Which value is likely to fail next if the defence is not reinforced? What does the discrepancy between his subjective state and his signs suggest about how far along the compensation gap has already run?

Reflection 3 — which mode. Three patients present with fatigue. The first has slowly progressive fatigue over two years; a recent blood test shows creatinine of 220. The second has sudden fatigue after a chest infection, and a lactate of 4. The third has fatigue over three months plus cold intolerance, dry skin, and a hoarse voice. Think about: which of the three modes does each represent? What signal in each history told you which mode? What does that tell you about the history you would take next?

Reflection 4 — context sets the threshold. A trained cyclist reports palpitations at the top of a steep climb. A sedentary 55-year-old reports palpitations sitting in his kitchen watching TV. Think about: are these the same complaint? What context accepts the first sensation and rejects the second? What single question would you ask each patient to decide whether their sensation fits what their body is doing, or reports something you need to investigate?

Reflection 5 — the compensation that becomes the disease. A patient has had well-treated hypertension for twenty years. An echocardiogram now shows left ventricular hypertrophy and reduced diastolic function. She is beginning to be short of breath on exertion. Think about: what adaptation kept her body quiet for those twenty years? What is that adaptation now doing to her? Where is the boundary between the compensation and the disease — and does the question have a clean answer?

From Here to Chapter 3

You now know what a sensation departs from. Chapter 3 turns to the departure itself: the small vocabulary of dimensions along which any complaint is reported, and the way that vocabulary already carries so much of the diagnosis inside it. The quiet body you have met in this chapter is what makes Chapter 3’s grammar readable at all. Without an expectation there is no departure, and so no report.

References

  1. Barrett LF, Simmons WK. Interoceptive predictions in the brain. Nat Rev Neurosci. 2015;16(7):419–429. — the brain predicts the body’s own signals; what matches the prediction stays below awareness.
  2. McEwen BS, Wingfield JC. The concept of allostasis in biology and biomedicine. Horm Behav. 2003;43(1):2–15. — allostasis, stability through change, and allostatic load, the wear that repeated or prolonged adaptation leaves behind.
  3. Sterling P. Allostasis: a model of predictive regulation. Physiol Behav. 2012;106(1):5–15. — regulation is predictive: the brain anticipates the body’s needs and adjusts before they arise.

Chapter 3 · The Grammar of the Sensation

Learning objectives

  • Recognise the four dimensions along which every complaint is reported
  • Read the patient’s word for the feel as the report of two things: the kind of injury, and the kind of nerve that carries it
  • Distinguish local, referred, and migratory patterns, and explain why referred pain is felt where it is
  • Use tempo and accompanying symptoms to complete the signature of a complaint
  • Apply the same grammar to complaints reported as loss of function rather than as new sensation
  • Explain why each heuristic, H1–H4, draws out its part of the grammar, and why H3 is a test

Marion Colby, 46, arrives on Monday morning after a Sunday dinner. She is pale. She apologises for the appointment and says: “I had this attack again last night. A gripping pain under my right ribs. It built up and then it just stayed. I couldn’t get comfortable — I was pacing. It went up into my shoulder blade. I was sweating and nauseated. It lasted about two hours and then eased off. This is the third time in six months, always after a heavy meal.”

Marion has already done much of your work. In a few sentences she has told you the quality of the sensation (gripping, with a restlessness that will not let her keep still), the location (under the right ribs, into the shoulder blade), the timing (built up and then stayed, two hours, after a heavy meal, the third time in six months) and the companions (sweating, nausea). The values of the four dimensions fit together, and they point at the same thing.

The word gripping, with the restlessness, is how a hollow organ reports a blockage it strains against; the place, the timing and the companions point the same way. Before you have laid a hand on Marion, the grammar of her sensation has assembled the picture: biliary colic. Section 5 walks the reading step by step.

Chapter 1 showed that the feature a patient reports carries the mechanism. Chapter 2 showed how the body keeps quiet, and what it costs when the quiet fails. This chapter names the small set of rules by which the noticed body reports. Together they produce the signature of almost any bodily complaint. Once you have the grammar, most of the review of systems can be read as a language, with far less to memorise.

The chapter is ordered by what a sensation is made of: its four dimensions. How you ask about them in the consultation, with the interview heuristics, comes in Section 7, which shows how the heuristics draw the grammar out of the patient’s story. For now, read the dimensions as the parts of a patient’s report.

The Four Dimensions

Every complaint the noticed body makes reports along four dimensions:

Quality — the feel of it: sharp, dull, burning, pressure, gripping, cramping, tearing, electric, itch. The kind of trouble.

Location — where it is felt: at the source, referred to a shared spinal segment, or migrating as the process advances.

Timing — how fast it arrived, how it evolves, when it happens: seconds, minutes, hours, days; steady, in waves, on exertion, at rest, post-prandial, morning-worse.

Companions — what travels with it: autonomic halo (nausea, sweating, pallor, faintness), systemic halo (fever, malaise, anorexia), other symptoms in other systems.

Each dimension has only a few possible values, and physiology sets them. Quality depends on the kind of nerve that reports the sensation and the kind of injury that fires it. Location depends on the tissue and its nerve supply. Timing depends on how fast the process itself moves. Companions depend on the reflexes and the body-wide signals the process sets off. Because the values are limited, only a few combinations hang together. So the signatures of the common complaints can be learned, and an uncommon signature stands out against them.

This is the central claim of the chapter. Learn the four dimensions and their values, and most of the fifty-five pictures can be rebuilt from them.

See MAAS-Prep 3.1 to practise the four dimensions: given a short patient statement, separate what belongs to Quality, Location, Timing, and Companions — and check whether the four together form a coherent signature.

Quality — The Feel Is the Kind of Trouble

Quality often tells you the most. A word for the feel reports two things at once: what kind of injury is happening, and what kind of nerve reports it. Nerves that carry pain to the spinal cord are called afferents. There are two main kinds. Somatic afferents serve the skin, muscles and joint linings; visceral afferents serve the internal organs. The two kinds report in different ways, and this book calls the nerve the reporter. Injury and reporter together give the sensation its character: change either one, and the word changes.

The patient says……because the reporter and the injury are→ kind of trouble
Sharp, well-localised, “I can point to it”, worse on movementSomatic afferents at a lined surface — richly and precisely wiredIrritation or inflammation of a lined surface (pleura, peritoneum, periosteum, synovium)
Dull, deep, vague, midline, hard to point toVisceral afferents: few, and sharing pathways in the spinal cord (Section 3)Organ stretch, ischaemia, or capsular distension
BurningChemical or mucosal irritation (acid, inflammatory mediators)Tissue irritation on an unprotected surface
Pressure, tightness, heaviness; builds on demand, eases on restIschaemia — oxygen starvation, anaerobic metabolite build-upPerfusion failure
Gripping or cramping, restless; in waves in the gut, steady in the gallbladderSmooth muscle of a hollow organ straining against a blockObstruction (colic)
Tearing or ripping, instant, maximal at onsetSudden structural ruptureMechanical or vascular rupture
Burning, electric, or shooting in a nerve’s territory, with or without numbnessThe nerve itself is damagedNeurogenic (neuropathic pain)
ItchPruriceptive (itch-sensing) fibres, histaminergic and non-histaminergicSkin inflammation (the rash is felt), or a systemic itch without a rash, as in cholestasis

Two rules are worth noticing in this table. First, the reporter shapes the language. Somatic afferents are richly wired to specific points on the body wall; when they fire, the patient can point. Visceral afferents are few and share their pathways; when they fire, the patient waves at a general region. So a sharp pain the patient can point to comes from a somatic reporter, and a dull midline pain from a visceral one, whatever the tissue underneath.

Second, the injury shapes the language too. Each kind of injury fires the nerve in its own way, and the patient reports that firing with its own word. Acid on an unprotected mucosa opens acid-sensing channels on the pain-nerve endings (the nociceptors; the channels, TRPV1 and ASICs, respond to the fall in pH), and that firing is felt as burning. Ischaemia starves the tissue of oxygen. The products that build up without oxygen (adenosine, lactate, potassium) sensitise the nerve endings in their own way, and that firing is felt as pressure.

Each quality-word is the closest match the language of pain has for a specific event in the body. The word itself still varies between cultures and languages, while the physiology under it stays the same: a sensation one patient calls burning, another may call heat rising. Read past the word to the mechanism. How to draw out a patient’s own way of saying it belongs to the interview handbook.

Marion says gripping, and she cannot keep still. The word makes a lined surface, ischaemia or a rupture unlikely: each usually reports in another word (sharp, pressure, tearing). It fits the smooth muscle of a hollow organ straining against a blockage. The word has narrowed the mechanism before you have asked another question.

Now you can see why Chapter 1’s working rule holds. Chapter 1 drew the rule from the Top-7 table:

The feature the patient reports carries the mechanism, and the follow-up question is the test that confirms it.

This section has shown where the rule comes from: the injury and the nerve that reports it shape the word. Because the rule rests on the way the sensory system is built, it carries over to presentations outside the Top-7 as a strong guide.

See MAAS-Prep 3.2 to practise reading Quality: given a patient’s quality-word, name the reporter and the injury it implies — and say which quality-word you would expect if the reporter changed and the injury stayed the same.

Location — Not Always Where It Is

Location does two kinds of work. It tells you which tissue is involved, and it tells you which kind of reporter carries the signal. There are three patterns.

Local. The sensation is felt at the source. This is the somatic pattern: the patient can point, the pain sits over the tissue, and pressing on the tissue reproduces or worsens the pain. Skin, subcutaneous tissue, the parietal surfaces of body cavities (pleura, peritoneum), periosteum, and synovial linings all report locally. A pleuritic pain is here, and a finger will find it.

Referred. The sensation is felt at a distance from the source. This is the visceral pattern, and it has a specific anatomical logic. Visceral afferents from an organ enter the spinal cord at the same segmental level as somatic afferents from a particular strip of skin — that strip is a dermatome, and each spinal segment has one. In the dorsal horn of the spinal cord, the two sets of nerves converge onto the same second-order neurons. The skin sends signals far more often than the organs do, so the brain has learned to read signals at that level as coming from the skin, and it places the organ’s pain in the shared dermatome. Referred pain is true, in the sense that it is where the brain places the sensation; the disease lies elsewhere.

A handful of segmental maps are worth carrying, because they explain most referred patterns you will meet:

  • Diaphragm (C3–5) → shoulder tip. When the diaphragm is irritated — from below (subphrenic abscess, cholecystitis, ruptured spleen) or from above (basal pneumonia) — the patient may feel it in the shoulder rather than the abdomen or the chest.
  • Heart (T1–4) → chest, left arm, jaw, epigastrium. The heart shares its spinal segments, T1–4, with the chest wall and the inner left arm, so the brain places cardiac pain there; pain in the jaw and the epigastrium comes through neighbouring segments.
  • Foregut, midgut, hindgut, by embryology → epigastric, periumbilical, suprapubic. Early appendicitis presents periumbilical because the appendix is midgut.

Marion’s pain up into the shoulder blade is referred pain. The gallbladder is a foregut structure, and its nerves enter the spinal cord at T7–9. Its pain is felt under the right ribs and, through the same segments, under the right shoulder blade. Pain at the shoulder tip would tell you something else: that the diaphragm is irritated (C3–5), as in the list above.

Migratory. The sensation moves as the process itself advances. Appendicitis is the classic example: it starts as periumbilical visceral pain and shifts to the right iliac fossa as the parietal peritoneum becomes involved. The word for the feel may stay much the same; what changes is the place, and often how easily the patient can point to it. A pain that moves tells you the disease is spreading beyond the tissue where it began, and that is a diagnostic signal in itself.

See MAAS-Prep 3.3 to practise Location: given a referred pattern, name the shared spinal segment or embryological source that explains why the pain is felt where it is — and given a migration, name what the shift reports about the disease.

Timing and Companions

Timing — how fast the process itself moves. The tempo of a sensation is the tempo of the process. Onset speed, evolution over hours or days, the pattern within a day, the pattern across weeks — each has meaning.

TempoWhat kind of process moves that fastConcrete example
Seconds; maximal at onsetMechanical rupture, embolism, vascular eventAortic dissection; subarachnoid haemorrhage; pulmonary embolism
Minutes; builds, plateausIschaemia; obstruction of a hollow organAngina on exertion; renal or biliary colic
Hours; steady buildInflammation, infectionCholecystitis; appendicitis; pyelonephritis
Days to weeksDeveloping obstruction, progressive inflammationBowel obstruction; sub-acute endocarditis
Weeks to months; insidiousInfiltration, neoplasia, degenerationNeoplasm; chronic renal decline; dementia

Rate matters because, as Chapter 2 showed, the body compensates over time. A process that develops slowly may cross the threshold late, because the body has adapted around it; a process that develops fast crosses at once, with no time to adapt. So rate separates a coronary artery that has narrowed slowly (silent, then angina on exertion) from the same artery blocked suddenly (instant, catastrophic MI).

The relationship of the sensation to time within the day, or to specific events, is often just as diagnostic as the onset speed. Post-prandial (after-eating) worsening points at digestive load. Morning stiffness points at inflammation. Symptoms only on exertion point at demand outpacing supply. Marion’s after a heavy meal is a small tempo detail with large diagnostic weight: it says the process is triggered by an event that raises biliary demand.

Companions — what travels with the sensation. Sensations rarely arrive alone. They arrive with a halo of other symptoms — some general (fever, malaise), some autonomic (nausea, sweating, pallor, faintness), some cross-system (breathlessness, dizziness). They follow predictably from the same underlying process, so they need not be memorised one by one. In the interview, companions belong to H4, the context heuristic. That is why you ask about them whenever a patient reports one main sensation.

Autonomic halo. Strong firing of the visceral afferents sets off autonomic reflexes: nausea, sweating, pallor, sometimes faintness. Visceral pain of any origin — myocardial ischaemia, biliary colic, renal colic, ovarian torsion — carries this halo. A patient who describes a pain and looks unwell is often reporting a visceral process, or a lined surface that is severely inflamed. Marion’s sweating and nauseated marks her pain as visceral: the pain comes from an abdominal organ, and the abdominal wall is unlikely.

Systemic halo. Cytokine-driven symptoms — fever, chills, myalgia, malaise, anorexia — signal infection or systemic inflammation. Their absence is diagnostic too: a patient with abdominal pain who is entirely well between attacks is telling you something different from one who is febrile and lethargic.

Cross-system companions. A chest pain with breathlessness raises different possibilities than a chest pain without. A headache with visual disturbance is not the same headache without one. A companion makes some diagnoses more likely and others less likely.

See MAAS-Prep 3.4 to practise Timing and Companions: given how fast a sensation began and how it varies over the day, name the kind of process that fits; given a sensation, say which halo is present or absent, and what that makes more or less likely.

The Reasoning in Real Time

Marion’s gripping pain, with the restlessness, points to obstruction of a hollow organ. It makes a sharp, somatic pain unlikely, such as pleurisy or irritation of the peritoneal lining. It also makes ischaemia less likely: mesenteric ischaemia gives a dull ache after every meal, with weight loss and a fear of eating, usually in an older patient with vascular disease. Her pain under the right ribs narrows the place to the right upper quadrant: the biliary tree first, with the renal pelvis and the duodenum still on the differential. In the gallbladder the strain builds to a plateau and holds, which is why biliary “colic” is usually a steady pain, despite its name; it comes in attacks.

Then the next detail: up into the shoulder blade. The detail fits biliary colic and adds weight to it. Her sweating and nauseated supports a visceral source. Her trigger, after a heavy meal, fits fat in the duodenum releasing cholecystokinin, which makes the gallbladder contract against a blocked duct. And the third time in six months tells you that the attacks recur.

The working picture: recurrent biliary colic from gallstones (symptomatic cholelithiasis). Next: check her temperature, white cell count and liver tests (LFTs), to look for cholecystitis or a stone in the bile duct. If she has no fever and her counts and LFTs are normal, arrange an abdominal ultrasound to confirm the stones and refer her to a surgeon as an outpatient. If she has a fever or her LFTs are deranged, admit her tonight for biliary imaging.

The reasoning started from the grammar, and from no list of the causes of right-upper-quadrant pain. It followed quality, location, timing and companions, and the picture assembled. At each step a candidate became less likely. All the while, the check for fever and the LFTs kept the safety-net in place.

Positive and Negative Departures — One Grammar, Two Tracks

Everything so far has assumed that the body has generated a new signal: a burning, a pressure, a cramping. We call this a positive departure: the body produces something it was not producing before, and the new signal crosses into notice.

A whole class of complaints departs the other way: the body loses a function it used to have. A patient stops being able to hear the television at the volume that always worked. A patient starts asking the same questions twice. A patient walks less steadily, or smells less, or sees a smaller field than they used to. These are negative departures: the patient, or someone close, notices that something is missing.

The grammar still applies to the negative departure, with three swaps.

Quality becomes the pattern of the deficit. The question “what does it feel like?” becomes “what shape is the absence?”. Memory loss comes in different patterns. In one, the patient cannot form new memories: they repeat questions and cannot say what happened yesterday. In another, the patient remembers when given a cue, which points to a failure of recall, often from mood or a subcortical cause. In a third, the patient is foggy and inattentive, which points to working memory, often from delirium or depression. Hearing loss in which sounds are muffled and the patient’s own voice sounds loud is conductive; hearing loss that fails to pick out words in a noisy room is sensorineural. The shape of what is missing is diagnostic in the same way as the shape of what is felt.

The symptom-modifier becomes a functional probe. In a positive departure, the question about modifying factors asks what changes the symptom: does an antacid help the burning? In a negative departure, it becomes a test that restores function at one level only. Does a cue help the memory? If it does, recall is the problem; if it does not, the memory was never stored. Does speech become clear once it is loud enough? If it does, the loss is likely conductive; if it stays unclear even when it is loud, it is likely sensorineural. The tuning-fork tests (Rinne, Weber) confirm the level.

The informant becomes a main source of the history. The patient does not hear what they used to hear, does not remember what they used to remember, walks less well than they used to walk. Often the lost ability is the very one the patient would need to notice the loss, so the informant (a partner, a child, sometimes a colleague) carries part of the history the patient cannot. Chapter 8 takes this up in its own right.

Marion’s gripping pain is a positive-departure complaint: her body generated a new signal, the attack of colic, that crossed her threshold. Suppose instead that a disease of the same organ had stayed silent for years and showed only as a slow loss of appetite and weight, which her husband noticed before she did; a gallbladder cancer can present this way. Then we would be on the negative-departure track. There is no quality-word and no clear place, and her husband reports what she herself had not noticed. The same organ, a different track through the grammar. The patient, or the informant, sets the track by what they bring to you. A third situation sits behind both tracks: the sensation persists while the tissue is sound, because the reporting system itself has become oversensitive. Chapter 9 takes that up.

See MAAS-Prep 3.5 to practise the swap: given a patient with a loss-of-function complaint, apply the grammar. What is the pattern of the deficit, what functional probe would confirm the level, and whose report carries the history?

Why the Interview Asks the Questions It Does

The grammar you have just met explains, on its own, why the interview’s four heuristics are what they are. Chapter 1 introduced them briefly; here they gain their meaning. Each heuristic draws out part of the grammar from which the complaint was built.

HeuristicWhat the clinician asksWhat it draws out of the grammar
H1 ComplaintWhat does it feel like, and where?Quality + Location — the shape of the sensation and where it is felt
H2 Time-IntensityWhen did it start, and how has it changed?Timing — the tempo of the underlying process
H3 Modifying FactorsWhat makes it better or worse?The demand-and-relief logic that follows from each quality — the confirming test
H4 ContextWhat else is present, and what were you doing?Companions — the halo of the process; also the context that sets the threshold
Red Flags sweepWhat would be catastrophic if missed?The safety-first check — catastrophic mechanisms that H1 did not point at

H3 is worth a further word, because it is the one heuristic that does not match a single dimension. It is a test derived from Quality: burning invites an antacid trial (does neutralising the acid remove the burning?); pressure invites a rest trial (does removing demand remove the pressure?); gripping or cramping invites a test of the blockage (does the pain ease once the stone has moved or the bowel has emptied?). A modifier can also test timing or context, so H3 is tied less closely to one dimension than the other three are.

The heuristics are also a way to listen. Even before you ask anything, they tune your ear: as the patient talks, you hear the few words that carry Quality, Timing, the halo and the context, and the rest falls into the background. Marion gave you all four before you asked anything; the heuristics let you hear which of her words mattered.

So the interview grows out of the physiology it serves. The interview is how you draw the grammar out of the patient’s story. The grammar and the interview have the same shape.

Chapter 6 of this book returns to the heuristics to show how they carry the read-back, from the complaint to the mechanism.

What You’ve Learned

Every complaint the noticed body makes reports along four dimensions: Quality, Location, Timing, and Companions. Each dimension has only a few possible values, set by physiology: the reporter that fires, the tissue involved, the tempo of the process, the reflex halo it sets off. Together, the four dimensions produce the signature of almost any bodily complaint, so most of the review of systems can be read as a language, with far less to memorise. Quality narrows the mechanism; the modifying-factors test (H3) that each quality implies confirms it. The same grammar reads complaints reported as new sensation (positive departure) and as loss of function (negative departure), with three swaps: the pattern of the deficit for the quality-word, a functional probe for the symptom modifier, the informant for the patient. And the interview’s four heuristics follow from the grammar. In the consulting room they help you draw the grammar out, as much by hearing the right words as by asking the right questions.

Reflections

Five open-ended scenarios for thinking, journaling, or peer discussion. No answer key: they are meant to connect what you have read with the patients you meet.

Reflection 1 — sorting the four dimensions. A patient says: “I’ve had a sharp pain in my left flank for the last six hours. It came on suddenly. It goes down into my groin. I’ve been vomiting and can’t sit still.” Think about: what belongs to Quality, Location, Timing, and Companions? Do the four values fit together to make a coherent signature? What single mechanism does the signature point at — and which one word gave you the strongest signal?

Reflection 2 — change one word. Take Marion’s presentation and imagine that everything is identical except the quality-word: instead of gripping, she says burning. Then instead, imagine she says tearing. Think about: what mechanism does each change point at? Where in the same anatomical region would the process now sit? What single follow-up question would distinguish each possibility?

Reflection 3 — referred pain. A 30-year-old man reports pain at the tip of his right shoulder. He is otherwise well. He has had a mild fever for two days. Think about: what does the shoulder tip refer from? Which structure sits at C3–5 and could refer pain here? What is the range of diagnoses to consider, and what one further question would you ask to narrow it?

Reflection 4 — the same lesion, different tempo. A 60-year-old man reports pressure across the chest on climbing two flights of stairs, the same for six months, eased by rest. A second man, 60, calls an ambulance for severe crushing chest pressure that came on at rest twenty minutes ago and is still there. Think about: what does the difference in tempo tell you about the process in each? What is the same, and what is different? Why does the first man’s six-month history suggest adaptation has occurred, and what would you expect of his coronary anatomy compared with the second’s?

Reflection 5 — applying the grammar to loss. An 82-year-old woman is brought in by her son because she is confused. She agrees she has had “a bit of trouble remembering things.” When you ask her to recall three words after five minutes, she recalls none. When you cue her (“one was a colour”), she remembers “red.” Think about: how does the grammar apply here? What is the pattern of the deficit? What did the cueing test tell you — and where in the memory pathway is the failure? Whose report do you weigh most heavily — hers, her son’s, or the objective testing — and why?

From Here to Chapter 4

Chapter 4 works out the equation that Chapter 1 named, which ties the grammar to the disease it points at: a complaint is the signature a mechanism leaves in a region (mechanism × region = complaint), and the grammar is how that signature is read. The equation explains why fifty-five complaints are enough for a review of systems that could, in principle, run to many hundreds, and why most of them assemble themselves once the grammar is in hand. Marion’s biliary colic is what a particular mechanism, met in a particular region, is bound to feel like. The next chapter shows how mechanism and region together produce it.

References

  1. Cervero F, Laird JMA. Visceral pain. Lancet. 1999;353(9170):2145–2148. — the classical account of visceral afferent convergence and referred pain.
  2. McMahon SB, Koltzenburg M, Tracey I, Turk DC, editors. Wall and Melzack’s Textbook of Pain. 6th ed. Philadelphia: Elsevier Saunders; 2013. Chapters on visceral pain and referred pain — for the segmental convergence account.

Chapter 4 · The Complaint Equation

Learning objectives

  • State the equation that links every complaint to a mechanism met in a region
  • Recognise six region-types and describe how each constrains the sensation it can report
  • Show how the same mechanism produces different named complaints in different regions
  • Recognise the classes of complaint where the equation needs an extra step
  • Read the review of systems as a list that follows from the equation, so that it need not be memorised item by item
  • Apply the safety principle: rule out the catastrophic mechanism before you settle on the benign one

Part II — what the sensation points at. Part I stayed on the patient’s side of the desk: the quiet body, the moment it crosses into notice, and the grammar of the feel. Part II crosses to the other side: the mechanism and the region that produce that feel. This chapter shows how the two together produce it; Chapter 5 opens the mechanisms themselves.

Anna Petrov, 71, tells you that for the last three months she has felt a pressure across her chest when she walks uphill to the shops. It lasts a minute or two. It settles when she sits down at the bus stop. She has never had chest pain at rest. She feels “heavy” when it happens, and slightly sick with it. She is here today because a friend told her her chest pressure should not be ignored.

You have three chapters of grammar in hand. Anna’s quality-word is pressure. Her location is retrosternal. Her companion: she feels slightly sick. Her timing: it comes on effort, eases with rest, and has done so for three months. Pressure on effort, eased by rest, with nausea, in the territory of the coronary arteries: this signature has one leading mechanism behind it, ischaemia, and one likely diagnosis, stable angina.

Move the same pressure to her calf, and it is claudication; Section 3 follows the same mechanism through six complaints.

The Equation

The claim of this chapter fits in one sentence: a complaint is the signature a mechanism leaves in a region. The patient reports it in the grammar of Chapter 3. As a shorthand, in the order the body produces it:

mechanism × region = complaint

Two things produce a complaint, and the patient hands you neither directly. The mechanism is the disturbance itself: acid on an unprotected mucosa, blood failing to reach a muscle under load. The region is where it is happening. Both are hidden from you across the desk. What the patient gives you is the grammar of Chapter 3: quality, location, timing and companions. The grammar adds no third factor. It is the signature in a form you can read, the one face the mechanism and the region show. Acid on oesophageal mucosa usually reports as burning behind the breastbone: that is how this disturbance, in this place, most often makes itself felt. So reasoning reads the equation from right to left, from the signature back to the mechanism and the place that wrote it. That single move, repeated, is the whole of clinical reasoning in this book.

Read the × as met in: a mechanism met in a region. This clean case is the rule, and it has exceptions (Section 5): sometimes several mechanisms share one signature, sometimes the region is the whole body, sometimes the report is a loss instead of a feel. The rule is what keeps the list small. There are seventeen mechanisms (Chapter 5) and six region-types (Section 2). Combine them, keep the combinations patients actually bring in, and the feel of each follows on its own. That is why the review of systems has fifty-five entries, each set out in Appendix 3, where several hundred were possible: a small number of mechanisms, met in a small number of places, has only so much to say. Learn how the feel is produced, and you can read most of the list instead of memorising it.

See MAAS-Prep 4.1 to practise the equation: given a named complaint, name the mechanism and the region it points back to, read through its grammar, and show that the two together produce the name.

Region — The Second Factor

Region means more than a place in the body. Each type of region reports trouble in its own way, and that limits the grammar it can produce. Six types recur.

Region-typeHow it reportsTypical grammar signature
Surface / lined (skin, pleura, peritoneum, synovium, periosteum)Somatic-innervated, richly wiredSharp, pointable, worse on movement or breath
Hollow-organ lumen (gut, biliary tree, ureter, uterus)Visceral, contractileGripping or cramping, restless (in waves in the gut, steady in the gallbladder); midline or poorly localised
Capsule or stretch (liver, kidney, spleen, ovary)Capsular afferents fire on stretchDull, heavy, deep; often referred to a shared dermatome
Vascular territory (coronary, mesenteric, cerebral, peripheral)Tissue dependent on its arterial supplyPressure, tightness; exertional; eases with rest
Enclosed compartment (skull, eye, middle ear, joint capsule)A rigid, closed spacePressure; worse with bending or Valsalva
Signalling faculty (nerve pathway, sensory organ, cognitive system, endocrine axis)Tissue that carries or processes a signal, not wired to sense damagePattern of a deficit; often noticed by others first

One edge type sits next to these six. Systemic means the complaint has no local region: when the report is fever, malaise, weight change, night sweats or generalised fatigue, the address is the whole body, and the reasoning has to run through the companions instead of the location. Beside it stands the mechanical edge, which belongs to the mechanisms. Here the anatomy itself is at fault: a joint surface, a lens, a sphincter. Mechanical is the seventeenth mechanism, the only structural one, and Chapter 5 §7 sets it outside the five families. Because no physiological process is disturbed, there is no process to find: you read the complaint from the faulty anatomy of the region, and its feel comes straight from that anatomy. Here the method reaches its edge.

You know all of these regions from anatomy. Naming the types shows that region does two kinds of work at once: it narrows the plausible grammar, and it narrows the plausible mechanism. A surface region cannot produce cramping (there is no smooth muscle to contract); a vascular territory rarely produces sharp-and-pointable (there are no rich somatic afferents in a vessel wall). These six, with the systemic edge, cover the regions of the review of systems, and the mechanical edge covers its faults of structure: they have been checked against all fifty-five complaints. They describe how the common complaints report, and make no claim about the whole of anatomy.

See MAAS-Prep 4.2 to practise regions: given a body region, name its region-type and the two or three grammar-values you would expect its complaints to take — and the two or three values it would not produce.

The Equation in Action

The easiest way to see how the feel is produced is to change one of the two at a time, the mechanism or the region, and watch the grammar shift with it. Each time, the result is a group of related complaints that a student would otherwise have to memorise as unrelated.

Fix the mechanism, vary the region. Keep Anna’s mechanism — ischaemia — and move it from one arterial territory to another. Where the tissue reports with a feel, the feel stays the ache of demand (a pressure, a tightness, a cramp that rest relieves); mainly the address and the timing change:

RegionNamed complaint
Coronary territoryAngina (stable, unstable, or infarction depending on tempo)
Mesenteric territoryMesenteric ischaemia — post-prandial abdominal pain
Lower-limb vascular territoryClaudication — calf cramp or ache on walking, eased by standing still

Now move the same mechanism into tissue whose job is to do something, such as seeing, moving or speaking. There the same ischaemia is reported as a loss: a deficit in place of a pressure.

RegionNamed complaint
Cerebral territoryTIA — transient weakness or speech loss
Retinal arteryAmaurosis fugax — transient monocular vision loss
Penile vascular territoryVasculogenic erectile dysfunction — loss of function

Six named entries in the review of systems, one mechanism behind them all. What you carry is the mechanism and the map of where it can strike, in place of six unrelated pictures.

Fix the region, vary the mechanism. Now keep Anna’s region (coronary territory, felt retrosternally) and change the mechanism instead. The feel changes with it: each mechanism writes its own signature at the same address:

MechanismDiagnosis
IschaemiaAngina / MI
Vessel-wall dissectionAortic dissection
Pericardial inflammationPericarditis
Oesophageal mucosal irritationGORD
Oesophageal smooth-muscle contraction out of sequenceOesophageal spasm

Five different diagnoses, one address. Here the grammar has to tell them apart: tearing against pressure, sharp on breathing against heavy on effort, burning after meals against pain brought on by swallowing or cold drinks. Nitrates do not separate them: they ease oesophageal spasm as well as angina. The equation shows why H3 (modifying factors) is often the decisive question: when the region is fixed and the mechanism uncertain, H3 separates the candidates.

A complaint can vary in these two ways only: one mechanism moves to another region, or another mechanism strikes the same region. The feel cannot vary on its own while mechanism and region stay the same, because the two together produce it. What might look like a third variation is part of the region: the kind of tissue the mechanism strikes. Within one territory, tissue that reports with a feel and tissue that does a job report the same mechanism differently. In an ischaemic leg, the muscle reports pain and the nerves report numbness.

See MAAS-Prep 4.3 to practise the equation in action: hold one factor constant — the mechanism or the region — vary the other, and list the review-of-systems entries that result; then check them against the actual review of systems.

The Reasoning in Real Time

Read the equation back with Anna. The quality-word pressure, with nothing sharp, burning or tearing in it, already narrows the process to ischaemia. Add the retrosternal location, the mild nausea, and the timing (on effort, easing with rest), and the signature hangs together: ischaemia in coronary territory, most likely stable angina.

Retrosternal at Anna’s age puts coronary at the top of the list, but oesophageal spasm can mimic angina almost exactly at the same address, and aortic dissection is a low-probability but high-consequence alternative that must not be missed. The catastrophic alternative is checked first: sudden-and-maximal onset or a tearing character would move dissection to the top. Her three-month history, and a pressure with nothing tearing in it, make dissection unlikely for now; think of it again if the picture changes. H3 separates oesophageal spasm: cardiac ischaemia is brought on by exertion, oesophageal spasm by cold drinks and meals. Anna’s pattern is exertional. Ischaemia stays.

Working diagnosis: stable angina. Immediate work: ECG today, lipid and glucose tests, and referral within the week to a rapid-access chest pain clinic for CT coronary angiography or a functional test, as local practice sets it. Offer her a GTN spray and show her how to use it: a second dose after five minutes if the pressure has not gone, and 999 if it has not gone five minutes after that. Safety-net: call 999 if the pressure comes at rest and lasts more than 15 minutes; come back the same day if the attacks come more often or with less effort.

The reasoning needed no chest-pain differential: it started from the equation and followed it to a diagnosis, each question narrowing the field.

Named Exceptions — When the Equation Does More Work

Most entries in the review of systems work out simply: one grammar signature, one plausible process, one region, one diagnosis. Several of the commonest presentations do not. They fall into six classes, the same in every organ system: cross-cutting, branching, systemic-companion, negative-departure, mixed and mechanical edge. The classes are grouped by how the equation works on them. Each class asks for its own extra step, and knowing which one you are in tells you what the interview has to do next. Two further groups lie at or beyond the edge of the equation; they follow the six.

Cross-cutting. The same signature, at one region, can be produced by five or more plausible mechanisms converging. Chest Pain, Abdominal Pain, Headache, Dyspnoea, Vision, and Pelvic Pain are the primary members of this class. The equation holds, but H1 alone does not settle it; H2 (timing), H3 (modifiers), H4 (companions) and the Red Flags sweep work together to rule out the dangerous causes at the same time. Chapter 6 takes this up as its own reasoning pattern, rule-out.

Branching. One quality-word splits into sub-qualities that each point at a different sub-process. Dizziness (spinning, lightheaded or unsteady) is the classic example; Nausea and Vomiting, Cough, Diarrhoea, and Blood in Urine also branch this way. Follow one branch at a time: take the branch that H1 or H3 selects, and work down it.

Systemic-companion. There is no localised grammar signature at all. Fatigue, Fever, Weight Loss, Night Sweats, and Loss of Appetite are the primary members. The region is the whole body, H1 cannot tell the causes apart, and the companions (H4) carry almost all of the diagnostic weight. Here the interview starts with H4; Chapter 6 takes up this H4-first way in.

Negative-departure. The report is a lost function: Weakness, Memory, Hearing, Erectile Dysfunction. The equation runs on Chapter 3’s negative-departure track, with its three swaps: the pattern of the deficit for the quality-word, a functional probe for H3, the informant as a main source of the history. Chapter 8 is about this class.

Mixed. The same review-of-systems entry carries both departures. Numbness and Tingling has a positive form (burning, electric, paraesthesia) and a negative form (loss of sensation, a patch of skin that feels dead). The equation reads both, through the swap between the two tracks.

Mechanical edge. Back Pain, Knee Pain, Shoulder Pain, Neck Pain. When acute, these are often read from the anatomy of the region and from the grammar, as in Section 2. Red-flag mechanisms (inflammation, infection, neoplasia) can hide behind mechanical presentations and need a rule-out sweep. For most low back pain no specific structural source can be found, and in the chronic forms of all four a sensitised reporter (Chapter 9) often joins the mechanical reading or takes its place.

The first of the two further groups sits outside the equation: off-map. Depression, Anxiety, Suicidal Ideation, Psychosis, Substance Use. The body’s mechanisms in this book do not explain them; the mental-health handbook covers them. Two of them, Anxiety and Depression, have an off-map core and a bodily branch that needs a medical rule-out. The bodily branch of Anxiety (palpitations, tremor, dyspnoea, chest tightness) runs through autonomic dysregulation, a Family V mechanism (Chapter 5). The bodily branch of Depression (fatigue, sleep and appetite change, psychomotor slowing) needs the same rule-out before it is read as mood alone.

The second group sits at the equation’s far edge: the sensitised complaint. Here the sensation persists while the tissue is sound, because the reporting system has become oversensitive: chronic widespread pain, many persistent physical symptoms. Reading the tissue fails here, and the reasoning reads the complaint back to the reporter instead. Chapter 9 takes it up.

So the six classes belong to the equation. In each, a complaint is still a mechanism’s signature in a region. What changes is only which part of the signature carries the diagnostic weight: the grammar-word in a clean case, the modifier and timing in a cross-cutting case, the companions in a systemic-companion case, the informant in a negative-departure case.

See MAAS-Prep 4.4 to practise recognising the exception classes: given a review-of-systems entry, name which class it belongs to — and name which part of the signature will carry the most diagnostic weight in that class.

The Safety Principle

The cross-cutting class brings a rule into the open. Sometimes the equation allows more than one process for the same signature at the same address, and one of those processes could kill or maim if missed: aortic dissection behind angina, subarachnoid haemorrhage behind migraine, retinal artery occlusion behind blurred vision, ectopic pregnancy behind pelvic pain. Then safety comes before your leading hypothesis, the diagnosis you think most likely. Stated plainly: when a catastrophic possibility is on the table, rule it out before you settle on the benign one.

In practice: when a dangerous alternative is plausible, the test for it comes before you settle on the leading hypothesis, in this visit, before the patient leaves. Chapter 6 shows how the reasoning patterns do this, above all the rule-out pattern for the cross-cutting complaints. The rule itself belongs here, because the equation shows why the danger is built in. A cross-cutting signature always includes a catastrophic mechanism among its candidates. The risk of missing it is built in too, unless the rule-out runs every time.

The principle costs time. In a busy clinic it feels excessive to run a red-flag sweep on a patient who almost certainly has GORD or migraine. The alternative is a case, once every few years, where the patient with the benign presentation had the fatal alternative and no one asked.

See MAAS-Prep 4.5 to practise the safety principle: given a common complaint with a plausible benign process, name the catastrophic alternative and the single question or test that would separate them.

The Review of Systems, Read Back

With the equation in hand, the review of systems takes on a different shape. It becomes a vocabulary that follows from the equation: the language patients use when a small number of processes, met in a small number of regions, cross the threshold of notice.

You practise this read-back throughout the MAAS-Prep exercises and in MAAS Practice, where each case runs a complaint back to the mechanism and region that wrote it.

What You’ve Learned

Every complaint in the review of systems is the feel a mechanism makes in a region: the grammar the patient reports is produced by the mechanism it points at and the region where that mechanism is happening. Region comes in six types, set by their wiring, and each type limits both the grammar it can carry and the mechanisms likely to occur there. Change one of the two, the mechanism or the region, and the feel shifts through whole groups of related complaints that would otherwise have to be memorised as unrelated. Most complaints work out simply, but six exception classes recur (cross-cutting, branching, systemic-companion, negative-departure, mixed and mechanical edge), and each tells the interview where to put its weight. Off-map and sensitised complaints lie at or beyond the edge. The review of systems comes down to one equation, six region-types, seventeen mechanisms, and a small set of rules for reading what the equation produces.

Reflections

Five open-ended scenarios for thinking, journaling, or peer discussion. No answer key: they are meant to connect what you have read with the patients you meet.

Reflection 1 — take a complaint apart. Take one complaint from your own clinical week — any patient, any system. Think about: what is its grammar (its quality, location, timing and companions), what mechanism produced that feel, and in what region did the mechanism sit? Do the mechanism and the region, read through the grammar, lead back to the name you gave the complaint at the time? If not, which had you misread?

Reflection 2 — vary the region. Take a common mechanism — inflammation, obstruction, ischaemia, or a vascular leak — and walk it through three or four different regions. Think about: how does the named complaint change at each address? Which region gives the most familiar picture, which one surprised you, and what in the region-type explains why the same mechanism feels so different there?

Reflection 3 — which exception class. A patient reports fatigue that has slowly worsened over four months. She has no localised pain, no rash, no fever, but has lost four kilograms without trying, and is going to bed earlier because she cannot stay up. Think about: which exception class does this complaint belong to? Which part of the signature will carry the diagnostic weight? What is the first question you would ask — and would it be an H1, H2, H3, or H4 question?

Reflection 4 — same address, different process. Take a single address — the retrosternal region. Think about: which five mechanisms can produce a complaint there, and for each, what grammar signature would set it apart from the others? Which one is the catastrophic alternative that must be ruled out first, and what single question would separate it from the benign leader?

Reflection 5 — an entry that resists. Find a review-of-systems entry that does not work out simply to one mechanism in one region. Think about: which class of exception does it fall into? What does the equation still tell you about it, and where does it stop being useful — and does that boundary feel like a flaw in the method or a limit?

From Here to Chapter 5

You now have the equation and its exceptions. Chapter 5 turns to the mechanisms themselves, which the equation points back to, and to the five families that group them. Sixteen of the seventeen mechanisms sit inside five families, the mechanical one stands outside them, and the families organise the reasoning. Beneath the mechanisms lie the seven aetiologies of general pathology, the causes that drive them.

References

  1. Crijnen AAM. Mechanisms across the MAAS Complaint Library. MAAS working document. 2026. [Internal — the mechanisms sweep that grounds the seventeen-mechanism taxonomy used in this book.]

Chapter 5 · The Five Families

Learning objectives

  • Recognise the five families that group the seventeen mechanisms by shared physiological logic
  • Explain the signature of each family
  • Read physiology and pathology as two moments of the same process
  • Locate the seven aetiologies this book uses, adapted from general pathology, beneath the seventeen mechanisms
  • Use the map of mechanisms and aetiologies to help diagnose and to teach

Elena Vargas, 42, has come to your practice because her joints hurt. She points to her wrists and small hand joints, and her knees. The pain is worse in the morning and improves as the day goes on. She adds that she has felt generally unwell for weeks, has lost her appetite, has a low fever some evenings, and has noticed a faint rash across her cheeks. Her sister has lupus.

Look at Elena’s picture. Symmetric small-joint pain worse in the morning; low-grade fever; malar rash; family history of connective-tissue disease. Every element points at one thing: the immune system attacking her own tissues. That is immune hypersensitivity in the Tissue Injury family. Every element points the same way because that is what a family does: its members share one physiological logic, so they leave a recognisable signature in every complaint they cause.

This chapter names the five families that group the seventeen mechanisms Chapter 4 introduced. It also names the seven aetiologies this book uses, adapted from general pathology: the causes behind the mechanisms. Appendix 4 maps families, mechanisms and aetiologies together. The families and the aetiologies tell you what lies inside the first factor of the equation, the mechanism. Families and mechanisms are drawn from the review of systems itself: they cover the complaints patients bring, and they make no claim to classify all disease.

What the Grammar Points To

The seventeen mechanisms did not need to be seventeen isolated things. Read closely, they fall into five families that share a physiological logic, plus one edge that sits outside physiology altogether: the mechanical edge (Section 7). Each family has a signature grammar: quality-words, timings and companions that follow from how the family works. In a clean case they let you recognise the family from the report alone. Some signatures are shared: pressure, for instance, serves both perfusion failure and raised pressure in a closed space. Then the report narrows the family without settling it, and H1–H4 and the Red Flags sweep do the rest.

The organ chapters of a pathology textbook such as Robbins cut disease differently: by organ. A single mechanism like ischaemia then appears many times over, filed under wherever it strikes: the heart, the gut, the brain, the limb. This book reads instead by mechanism across organs: demand outrunning supply is one thing, whether it shows as angina, claudication, mesenteric ischaemia, or a transient ischaemic attack. Both cuts are useful. The organ cut tells you what a lesion looks like; the mechanism cut tells you what a complaint is trying to say.

One note before we go through the families. Beneath them lies a layer this book has mentioned and not yet explained: the seven aetiologies of general pathology. Each mechanism has a why, and the seven aetiologies give it. Section 8 sets them out in a table. Until then, when a worked example ends with a label such as (aetiology: chemical), the label names this layer in passing.

Family I — Tissue Injury and Response

The Tissue Injury family is the largest and probably the most familiar. It contains five mechanisms: inflammation, infection, immune hypersensitivity, chemical or mucosal irritation, and neoplastic disease. What unites them is that a tissue is being damaged — by an external agent, an internal error, or an accumulating process — and the body responds with an inflammatory cascade. Neoplastic disease is the quiet member of the family. It damages tissue too, and it often shows itself first as a mass, an obstruction, or the systemic halo of weight loss and night sweats. The other four share the inflammatory signature.

The family signature is straightforward once you look for it. The grammar shows tenderness, a sharp or burning quality, a steady or steadily rising course, and systemic companions if the process is extensive (fever, malaise, weight loss). The interview move that catches Family I is “is there any tenderness, and does anything systemic go with it?” When the answer is yes to both, you are in this family.

Elena is in this family. Symmetric small-joint pain with morning stiffness is inflammatory synovitis. The malar rash is the same immune process at a different tissue. The low fever and appetite loss are the systemic companions the family carries. The aetiology: an immunological failure — the immune system attacking the self. One family and one aetiology, showing in three regions, give one diagnosis: probable systemic lupus erythematosus.

The reasoning in real time. Elena’s picture landed fast because every element pointed the same way, but walk the steps that got you there. Her presenting feature is joint pain. Joint pain can come from Family I (inflammation, infection, immune disease, tumour), from the mechanical edge, and now and then from Family III (bleeding into the joint) or Family V (pain referred from a nerve). Joint pain alone does not narrow the family; the companions do.

Symmetric, small-joint, worse in the morning: that is the signature of inflammatory synovitis. Pain on both sides argues against a mechanical cause, which is usually one-sided and tied to load. Many small joints at once argue against crystal arthritis, which usually strikes one joint at a time. Pain worse in the morning argues against a mechanical cause again, since mechanical pain grows with use and eases with rest. Family I inflammation now leads, and a mechanical cause is unlikely.

The picture then broadens. The malar rash is the same process in a different region; the evening fever and appetite loss are the systemic halo; her sister’s lupus makes an immune cause more likely. So within Family I the mechanism narrows from inflammation to immune hypersensitivity, and specifically to autoimmunity.

The reasoning needed no list of the causes of joint pain. It followed the family signature and let the companions confirm the mechanism. Next: full blood count, renal function, urinalysis with a protein:creatinine ratio, ANA, anti-dsDNA, complement, ESR/CRP; rheumatology referral within the week. Safety-net: call 999 for sudden chest pain or breathlessness; come back the same day with a new headache with visual change, or blood in the urine. Each can signal a lupus complication that needs care at once.

Family II — Perfusion and Oxygenation

Family II contains three mechanisms: ischaemia (regional demand exceeds supply), hypoxia (systemic oxygen delivery is inadequate), and hypoperfusion (regional or postural drop in pressure or flow). What unites them is that oxygen delivery fails somewhere on its way from lung to blood to vessel to tissue.

The family signature is a small vocabulary of oxygen-starvation words: pressure, heavy, tight, breathless, lightheaded. The symptoms often come with effort: they rise when the tissue needs more oxygen than the body can supply, and settle when the need falls again. Walking uphill brings on angina, climbing stairs the breathlessness of anaemia, standing up the dizziness of a falling blood pressure. The interview move that catches Family II is “what were you doing when it happened, and did stopping help?”.

Recall Anna Petrov from Chapter 4: her pressure walking uphill, easing at the bus stop, was Family II ischaemia in coronary territory. The aetiology behind her narrowed coronary artery is atherosclerosis, a degenerative process helped along by diet and metabolism (aetiologies: degenerative and nutritional). Recall Frank Aldrich from Chapter 2: his slowing on the corridor walk was Family II too. In his case the limit lay at the pump: a narrowed aortic valve held back the flow out of his heart (aetiology: degenerative, from a calcified valve, or congenital, from a valve with two cusps).

Physiology and pathology as two readings: exertion normally raises the demand of the tissue, local vasodilation raises the supply to match, and the matching goes unnoticed. When supply fails, the same demand can no longer be met: a narrowed coronary artery, a low haemoglobin, an autonomic system that no longer adjusts blood pressure on standing. The physiology is the quiet matching; the pathology is that matching broken.

Family III — Vessel and Fluid Balance

Family III contains three mechanisms: vascular leak or rupture, oedema from Starling-force imbalance, and haemostatic disturbance. What unites them is a failure at one of three levels: the wall of a large vessel (rupture), the wall of the capillary (fluid shifts into the tissue), or the clotting cascade that seals small injuries (bleeding).

The family signature is variable but each mechanism has a strong grammar. Vascular leak announces itself as tearing or thunderclap, at its worst from the first moment: the timing of a wall that has given way at once. Oedema announces itself as swelling, dependent on gravity, growing over days. Haemostatic disturbance announces itself as easy bruising, mucocutaneous bleeding, or bleeding out of proportion to trauma. The interview move that catches Family III depends on which mechanism is at work, and onset speed sorts them best, as the case below shows.

The reasoning in real time — sorting by onset. Iris Nakamura, 68, presents because her ankles have been swelling. It began about three weeks ago; each morning the swelling is less, each evening it is worse; her rings still fit; she has no pain in the swollen tissue. There is no chest pain and no breathlessness at rest, though she notices she has slowed on the stairs. Her only regular medication is amlodipine. On examination the pitting oedema goes to mid-calf, the jugular venous pressure is elevated, and there is mild ascites.

Walk the family. The three mechanisms have three distinct grammars, and Iris’s report picks one of them cleanly. A vascular leak or rupture would have announced itself as an instant, tearing, catastrophic onset — the grammar Iris does not have. A haemostatic disturbance would have announced itself as bruising, mucocutaneous bleeding, or bleeding out of proportion — the grammar Iris does not have. What Iris has is a bilateral, gravity-dependent, painless accumulation growing over weeks. That is Starling-force imbalance: more fluid leaves the capillaries than the lymphatics can return, and the excess stayed quiet until it filled the tissue.

The picture then broadens the way Elena’s did in Family I. Bilateral pitting with a raised JVP and ascites means congestion of the whole venous system, beyond any local venous obstruction. It points back along the venous return to the right heart. The likely cause is right-sided heart failure, which may follow a left-sided problem she has not yet reported, or a disease of the lungs or the valves. The mechanism is Starling imbalance driven by venous congestion. Behind it lies a heart or a lung whose adaptation has finally failed. The aetiology is most often degenerative (long-standing hypertension, ischaemic cardiomyopathy), with a nutritional part where a low albumin adds to the swelling. Next: echocardiogram, chest imaging, BNP, urinalysis and serum albumin; and a review of her amlodipine, which can itself cause ankle swelling (the drug history is H6, which Chapter 7 takes up). Safety-net: call 999 for sudden breathlessness, chest pain or a faint, the signs that her heart is failing faster.

The teaching move: within Family III, onset speed sorts first, before any laboratory test. Instant onset points at leak or rupture and takes precedence over everything; gradual painless growth points at Starling; provoked bleeding out of proportion points at haemostasis. Only after that sorting does the rest of the reasoning — the aetiology, the treatment, the safety-net — open properly.

The same structures, read twice: Starling forces continuously exchange fluid across the capillary membrane, and the balance holds. Haemostasis continuously seals microtrauma, and the balance holds. Vessel walls remodel under pressure, and the balance holds. When one of them fails badly (a dissected aortic wall, a leaking capillary bed, a broken clotting cascade), what has been quiet becomes catastrophic. Vessel wall, capillary membrane and clotting cascade are three separate systems. They form one family because they share one job: keeping blood where it belongs, each at its own level.

Family IV — Luminal and Pressure Dynamics

Family IV contains two mechanisms: obstruction of a hollow lumen, and increased pressure inside an enclosed compartment (intraluminal, or in an anatomical space such as the skull, eye, or middle ear).

The family signature is characteristic. Obstruction gives a gripping or cramping pain with restlessness, in waves in the gut and steady in the gallbladder, and often relief when the content is expelled: vomiting in bowel obstruction, passing a stone with the urine. Raised pressure gives a feeling of pressure or fullness. It grows with anything that raises the pressure further, such as bending forward, straining (Valsalva) or coughing, and often eases with anything that lowers it, such as sitting upright with raised intracranial pressure, or drainage of an effusion. The interview move that catches Family IV is “does anything make it come and go in a rhythm, and does anything relieve it?”.

Recall Marion Colby from Chapter 3: her gripping pain under the right ribs that built up and stayed, radiating to the shoulder blade, with sweating and nausea, after fatty meals. Family IV obstruction: a stone blocking the duct. If the gallbladder wall becomes inflamed around the stone (cholecystitis), Family I joins in; what Marion reports today comes from the blockage. Aetiology: physical (the stone), often with a nutritional background, since most gallstones form from cholesterol.

One process, read twice: peristalsis moves content along a lumen against a small resistance, and the movement is quiet. CSF, aqueous humour and bile flow at pressures the body holds steady. When the flow is blocked, the same physiology works against itself: the smooth muscle fires more forcefully against the block (colic), or the pressure in the enclosed space rises because production continues but drainage does not (raised ICP, glaucoma).

Family V — Signal and Regulation

Family V contains three mechanisms: neurogenic (a nerve, at any level, is damaged or misfiring), autonomic dysregulation (the sympathetic-parasympathetic balance is off), and endocrine or metabolic derangement (a hormonal or metabolic axis is out of range).

The family signature is distinctive. Because the affected system is a control system, its report is often loss of function rather than new sensation — the pattern of the deficit rather than the quality of the pain. Neurogenic complaints follow anatomical patterns: a dermatome, a stocking-and-glove pattern, one side of the body. Autonomic complaints come as palpitations, sweating, faintness, or unexplained diarrhoea. Endocrine and metabolic complaints come as thirst, temperature intolerance, weight change, or fatigue with no localised complaint. The interview move that catches Family V is “where exactly in your body do you feel this, and is there a pattern to it?” or, for the endocrine-metabolic axis, “is anything about your energy, temperature, or weight different?”.

Family V is also the family where the negative-departure class of complaints lives most naturally. When the control system breaks, the patient may no longer notice what is lost, and the informant becomes a main source of the history. Chapter 8 takes up this territory in its own right.

Quiet control, then failed control: the nervous, autonomic and endocrine systems hold the body’s values in range. When the regulator itself is damaged (a nerve degenerates, a gland fails, a receptor is lost), the value drifts because nothing defends it. Chapter 2 called this mode the regulator broken, and Family V shows it most clearly. A related problem lies just beyond this family. Sometimes the signalling system is intact and oversensitive, or sensitised: it amplifies signals instead of failing, and the complaint no longer matches any change in the tissue. Chapter 9 takes up this sensitised reporter.

See MAAS-Prep 5.1 to practise the family signatures: given a short patient statement, identify which of the five families the complaint belongs to — and name the family signature that let you decide.

See MAAS-Prep 5.2 to practise matching signatures to families: given several short patient statements, assign each to its family and name the failure mode it shows.

The Mechanical Edge

Sixteen of the seventeen mechanisms fit inside the five physiological families. The seventeenth, mechanical or structural, sits outside them, because the fault lies in the anatomy. A joint surface worn down; a lens gone opaque; a sphincter that leaks. No process has been disturbed; the shape itself is wrong.

Mechanical complaints dominate primary-care musculoskeletal presentations (back, knee, shoulder, neck). They also account for a good part of vision (refractive error, cataract) and hearing (cerumen impaction, otosclerosis). In these complaints the reasoning runs through the region. The pain can be reproduced by movement or by pressing, and there is no systemic halo. Behind a mechanical presentation a red-flag mechanism can hide (neoplastic, infectious, inflammatory), and the rule-out sweep is there to catch it. All of this holds best for the acute complaint. For nearly all low back pain no specific source can be identified (Hartvigsen 2018), and the chronic forms of back, neck, knee and shoulder pain are where a sensitised reporter most often joins in (Chapter 9).

The reasoning at the edge: when the scan finding is not the mechanism. Barbara Rousseau, 60, presents with severe knee pain and difficulty walking. Her right knee is swollen. There is no fever, no rash, no other joint involved. Her MRI shows a meniscal tear. The radiologist reports it, and a first surgeon proposes arthroscopic repair with three months of restricted weight-bearing and rehabilitation.

A second, experienced orthopaedic surgeon reads the same MRI and disagrees. The meniscal damage on the images is mild, he says — the kind that heals with a period of relative rest. The severity of Barbara’s pain does not fit a meniscal injury of that grade. What fits is the second finding on the MRI that the report mentions in passing: subchondral bone oedema. That is what is producing the pain. He aspirates the knee first: the fluid is clear, with no crystals and no organisms on Gram stain, and he sends it for culture. Then he offers an intra-articular corticosteroid injection. Within a few days Barbara can bear weight and the pain has settled to a level she can live with. The plan is rest, gradual mobilisation, and no surgery; the rest also covers the other reading that bone oedema raises at her age, a subchondral insufficiency fracture.

Two lessons live in this case, and both belong here at the edge. First: a finding on imaging and the mechanism behind a complaint are two different things. Mechanical presentations especially attract imaging, and imaging especially finds anatomical abnormalities — joint surfaces have wear, discs have bulges, tendons have partial tears — in patients whose complaint is not caused by any of them. Among people aged 50 to 90, a meniscal tear shows on MRI in a fifth to more than half, and most of those with a tear have no knee symptoms at all (Englund 2008). The reasoning starts from the grammar of the complaint (Barbara’s severity, the swelling, her failure to walk), asks which mechanism produces this pain in this patient, and then checks whether the imaging finding fits. In Barbara’s case the mild meniscal tear did not fit the severity; the bone oedema did. The orthopaedic surgeon’s expertise lies in this reading: which finding on the film explains the complaint.

Second: mechanical sits at the edge because no process is disturbed, and yet a mechanical presentation can carry inflammation alongside it as a co-mechanism. When it does, the inflammation is often what makes the pain severe. Bone oedema often goes with inflammation in and around the joint, and pain of this kind can respond to anti-inflammatory treatment. The corticosteroid injection here does two jobs: it treats the inflammatory co-mechanism and it functions as an H3 confirming test — if the pain settles over the next few days, the inflammatory reading gains support; if it does not, the reasoning returns to the branch point. Barbara’s response supported the reading. Surgery would have treated the meniscus, which was a finding, and left the pain of the bone oedema untreated through months of a recovery she did not need.

Beneath the Mechanisms — The Seven Aetiologies

The five families describe what is happening to the tissue. General pathology asks one layer deeper: why is it happening at all? What disturbed the process? The categorisation this book uses — adapted from the classical categories of general pathology (cf. Robbins Basic Pathology Part I) — is a set of seven:

  1. Congenital / genetic — the body is built wrong from the start.
  2. Physical / mechanical — trauma, radiation, temperature.
  3. Chemical / toxic — harmful substances, including drugs.
  4. Nutritional — deficiency or excess.
  5. Infectious — a pathogen has invaded.
  6. Immunological — hypersensitivity or autoimmunity.
  7. Neoplastic / degenerative — uncontrolled growth or accumulated wear.

A full diagnosis names the aetiology too: a specific aetiology driving a specific mechanism in a specific region. The full chain, for any patient, runs: complaint → mechanism → family → aetiology.

One of the seven deserves a flag of its own. The chemical category (#3) includes the iatrogenic cause — the drugs the patient is already taking — and across the fifty-five complaints the drug is one of the commonest causes of all, and one of the easiest to miss: oedema from a calcium-channel blocker, cough from an ACE inhibitor, confusion from an anticholinergic, bleeding from an anticoagulant. A new symptom in a patient on medication should prompt one question — could this be the drug? — before the differential is allowed to widen.

And a final caveat: not every complaint resolves to one of the seven. Some stay idiopathic — no cause is found — and naming that plainly is better than forcing a label the evidence will not carry.

The map of mechanisms and aetiologies. Each mechanism usually has only a few typical causes, and each cause usually acts through only a few mechanisms. The table below is a first version of the map, and Appendix 4 gives the fuller one; within each row the aetiologies are listed by number (#1–#7), in no order of frequency or severity.

MechanismTypical aetiologies
Family I — Tissue Injury and Response
Inflammation#2 physical, #3 chemical, #5 infectious, #6 immunological
Infection#5 infectious
Immune hypersensitivity#6 immunological
Chemical / mucosal irritation#3 chemical
Neoplastic#1 genetic, #2 physical (radiation), #3 chemical, #5 infectious
Family II — Perfusion and Oxygenation
Ischaemia / hypoxia / hypoperfusion#2 physical (compression, trauma), #3 chemical (CO), #4 nutritional (anaemia), #7 degenerative (atherosclerosis)
Family III — Vessel and Fluid Balance
Vascular leak / rupture#1 genetic (connective-tissue disorders), #2 physical (trauma), #7 degenerative
Oedema (Starling)#3 chemical (calcium-channel blockers, ACE inhibitors), #4 nutritional (hypoalbuminaemia), #6 immunological (angio-oedema), #7 degenerative
Haemostatic disturbance#1 genetic (haemophilia, vWD), #3 chemical (anticoagulants), #6 immunological (ITP), #7 neoplastic (leukaemia)
Family IV — Luminal and Pressure Dynamics
Obstruction / raised pressure#1 genetic (polycystic, congenital stenosis), #2 physical (stone, foreign body), #4 nutritional (cholesterol stones), #7 neoplastic
Family V — Signal and Regulation
Neurogenic#1 genetic, #2 physical (trauma), #3 chemical (alcohol, chemotherapy), #4 nutritional (B12), #6 immunological (MS, GBS), #7 degenerative
Autonomic dysregulation#3 chemical (drugs), #7 degenerative (diabetic neuropathy)
Endocrine / metabolic#1 genetic, #4 nutritional, #6 immunological (thyroid, T1DM), #7 neoplastic (adenoma)
Edge — Mechanical / Structural
Mechanical / structural#1 congenital, #2 physical, #7 degenerative

Neoplastic appears twice. As a mechanism (Family I) it names what a growth does to the tissue around it; as aetiology #7 it names the growth as the cause of another mechanism, such as an obstruction or a bleed.

The map is useful because it takes the reasoning one step further than most clinicians take it: to the aetiology. The temptation is to stop at the mechanism, as though naming the disturbance were the whole answer. The mechanism tells you how the damage happens; the aetiology tells you what causes it, and often where treatment has to reach. Elena’s inflammation has an immunological cause, so her treatment aims at the immune system, beyond the joint. Anna’s ischaemia has degenerative and nutritional causes, so her treatment aims at the vessel and the lipid profile, beyond the heart muscle. Treatment can aim at the aetiology where it can be reached, at the mechanism where it cannot (a genetic disorder managed through its mechanism), or at the symptom for relief.

See MAAS-Prep 5.3 to practise the map of mechanisms and aetiologies: given a diagnosis, name its family (or families), its dominant mechanism(s), and the aetiology (or aetiologies) that drive them — then trace the full chain forward from aetiology to complaint.

See MAAS-Prep 5.4 to practise the mechanical edge: given a mechanical presentation with an imaging finding, decide whether the finding is the mechanism generating the complaint, a co-mechanism, or an incidental abnormality — and name the H3 confirming test that would settle it.

See MAAS-Prep 5.5 to practise sorting within Family III: given a Family III presentation, sort first by onset speed to decide between leak or rupture, Starling oedema and haemostatic disturbance, and name the companion that confirms the mechanism.

What You’ve Learned

The seventeen mechanisms fall into five families that share a physiological logic, plus one edge for faults of structure. Each family has a recognisable signature in the grammar patients use. Physiology and pathology are one continuous process, read at two moments — healthy and disturbed. Beneath the mechanisms, the seven aetiologies this book uses, adapted from general pathology, name the causes that drive the disturbances; and the map between the seven and the seventeen lets you answer both what is happening and why. Complaint, mechanism, family, aetiology: four links in one chain, each reached by asking about the link before it.

Reflections

Five open-ended scenarios for thinking, journaling, or peer discussion. No answer key: they are meant to connect what you have read with the patients you meet.

Reflection 1 — identify the family. A patient presents with severe cramping abdominal pain in waves, restlessness, and a distended abdomen. Think about: which family does this belong to? What single interview move confirmed it for you — and what would have moved you to a different family?

Reflection 2 — two families at once. A patient with severe sepsis is hypotensive, tachycardic, and confused. Think about: which families are at work in this presentation, and in what order did they arrive? How does the order in which they arrived help you decide what to treat first?

Reflection 3 — physiology becomes pathology. Take one mechanism from Family I — inflammation, say. Think about: what is its physiological role in the body when it is working correctly? When does the same cascade become the disease? Where is the threshold, and what tips it?

Reflection 4 — the aetiology behind the mechanism. You have diagnosed a patient with cirrhosis. Think about: which family and mechanism does cirrhosis sit in, and which aetiologies could have driven it? How does knowing the aetiology change your management plan?

Reflection 5 — reasoning across the map. A patient with new-onset seizures could have several causes. Take three: a stroke, a brain tumour, and a low blood glucose. Think about: for each, what family and mechanism is at work, and which of the seven aetiologies lies behind it? How would the grammar signature of the presentation differ across them?

From Here to Chapter 6

You now know the equation and the mechanisms behind it. Chapter 6 turns to the reasoning: given a complaint at the door, how do you read it back to its mechanism and reach a diagnosis? Chapter 6 calls this the read-back. The interview’s four heuristics are the tools for it. The Medical Interview handbook’s four reasoning patterns are four shapes the read-back can take, and which one you take depends on how many mechanisms the complaint leaves open, weighed by how dangerous they are.

References

  1. Crijnen AAM. Mechanisms across the MAAS Complaint Library. MAAS working document. 2026. [Internal — the seventeen-mechanism taxonomy and the family × aetiology reconciliation used in this chapter.]
  2. Englund M, Guermazi A, Gale D, et al. Incidental meniscal findings on knee MRI in middle-aged and elderly persons. N Engl J Med. 2008;359(11):1108–1115. — meniscal tears on MRI were common in middle-aged and older people, and most of those with a tear had no knee symptoms.
  3. Hartvigsen J, Hancock MJ, Kongsted A, et al. What low back pain is and why we need to pay attention. Lancet. 2018;391(10137):2356–2367. — for most low back pain no specific tissue cause can be found; it is the leading cause of disability worldwide.

Chapter 6 · Reading the Complaint Back

Learning objectives

  • Read a complaint back, from the feel to the mechanism that produced it, and name what each of the four heuristics draws out
  • State the goal: the few explanations most likely to be right and most dangerous to miss, a short list that tells you which scarce, fallible tests to order; and an understanding of the person good enough to decide, with them, what to do
  • Recognise the four reasoning patterns (Schema-based, Branching, Rule-out, Pattern recognition), and how a complaint’s choice of pattern depends on how many mechanisms could produce it, on danger, and on experience
  • Enter the sweep at H4 for a complaint with no quality to name, such as weight loss
  • Choose tests that could change the diagnosis, including the one that would prove the leading explanation wrong
  • Use follow-up as the method’s only check from outside: the outcome confirms or revises the mechanism

Part III — the reasoning. A complaint has two sides: the feel the patient reports, and the mechanism in a region that produces it. This chapter turns them into clinical work: how the interview reads the signature back to find the mechanism. Chapter 7 then follows the mechanism to its cause. Chapters 8 and 9 take the two edges: the patient who does not notice, and the sensitised reporter. Chapter 10 closes the loop with the patient.

David Chen, 55, presents to the emergency department with severe central chest pain. It began forty minutes ago, at rest. It feels like a heavy pressure with radiation to the left arm. He is sweating and slightly nauseated. He has hypertension and smokes.

You have seconds to reason. The pressure, with its autonomic halo of sweating and nausea, points to Family II, ischaemia. Its place behind the breastbone fits the coronary territory, and the sudden, sustained onset at rest fits as well. The conclusion comes fast: this is likely an acute coronary syndrome, probably an infarction.

But you cannot stop there. Chest pain is a cross-cutting complaint (Chapter 4): five or more mechanisms can produce the same feel in the same place. Ischaemia is the leading candidate, but aortic dissection, pulmonary embolism, tamponade, oesophageal rupture, and severe reflux all remain on the table until they are ruled out. So you order the ECG and the troponin to test for ischaemia, and at the same time you ask more. Was the pain at its worst from the first second? That suggests dissection. Is it worse when he breathes in? That suggests pericarditis or a problem of the pleura. Are there risk factors for PE? Is there a tearing pain through to the back? Each candidate is ruled in or out by its own question, and all are kept in mind at once.

Running several hypotheses at once, each with its own confirming and refuting test, is one of four reasoning patterns the interview can take. Which pattern a complaint calls for depends on how many mechanisms could produce its signature. Whatever the pattern, the same four heuristics carry it out. This chapter names the four patterns and shows the heuristics running them.

What is all this reasoning for? To reach the few explanations most likely to be right and most dangerous to miss, built from what the patient feels and says and from what the physician understands. Measuring what is physically happening is left to the tests. Tests are slow and imperfect: a scan may be weeks away, and every test carries a small error rate, so running many of them on one patient mostly produces false alarms, cost, and harm. A good interview makes testing work: it narrows a wide field to a short list and tells you which one or two tests will settle it. Two classic studies of medical outpatients found that the history alone pointed to the right diagnosis in about four cases out of five. Examination and tests mostly made the physician more confident of an answer the history had already reached.

This chapter teaches the thorough, step-by-step sweep as the basic pattern; branching serves the complaint that splits into several kinds, rule-out the complaint that may hide a catastrophe.

Reasoning as Read-Back

Chapter 4 worked out the equation: a complaint is the signature a mechanism leaves in a region (mechanism × region = complaint). The body writes it from left to right. The patient hands you the signature, written in its grammar; the mechanism and the region are hidden across the desk. Deliberate clinical reasoning reads the equation from right to left: from the complaint back to the mechanism and the region, and from there to the specific diagnosis. This book calls that reading the read-back; Chapter 7 follows it further, on to the cause and the plan. The expert’s instant recognition, to which Section 6 returns, grows out of this read-back with practice.

Each step of the read-back is a question. What is the grammar signature? Which mechanism does it point at? Which specific diagnosis inside that mechanism? The interview’s four heuristics (H1 complaint, H2 time-intensity, H3 modifying factors, H4 accompanying context), plus the Red Flags sweep, are the questions that take each step back.

HeuristicInterview gestureWhat it draws out
H1 ComplaintTell me what it feels likeQuality + Location: the grammar signature; sets the plausible family
H2 Time-IntensityHow did it start and how has it changed?Timing: selects the mode of failure (reserve exhausted, adaptation outpaced, regulator broken; Chapter 2) and often the specific mechanism within the family
H3 Modifying FactorsWhat makes it better or worse?The confirming test: picks the specific mechanism when the family holds more than one
H4 ContextWhat else have you noticed?Companions: picks up a second mechanism at work, or a second family involved
Red Flags sweepSystematic catastrophe checkCatches the dangerous mechanisms H1 did not pick up: the safety net under the other questions

Asking has a cost of its own. Answering a question about a symptom asks real work of the patient: to grasp what is meant, to feel inward for whether it happened, to find it in memory, and to judge how to say it. That capacity is limited and wears out as the questions accumulate. On a long checklist with no clear aim, the patient begins to settle for the quickest acceptable answer: agreeing to be agreeable, sliding into a run of yeses. Answers grow measurably worse towards the end of a long questionnaire, most of all for patients with the least schooling. Past a point, added questions mostly add false positives. Fatigue also costs what comes after: a patient worn out by questions keeps less of the explanation and the plan, and much of what is said in a consultation is forgotten soon after in any case. The four heuristics rather aim at a few questions, well chosen and informative. They ask only what the reasoning needs, and spend the patient’s attention where it changes the differential, keeping enough of it for the explanation and plan still to come.

See MAAS-Prep 6.1 to practise following the feel to its mechanism: given a complaint, take each heuristic in turn and name what it draws out, and which candidate each question narrows.

The Four Reasoning Patterns

The read-back does not always take the same shape. When one mechanism fits cleanly, the path from complaint to diagnosis is short. When several mechanisms produce the same signature, the read-back must follow several branches, and choosing the pattern is a diagnostic decision in its own right.

The Medical Interview handbook names four reasoning patterns, and this book uses the same four (set out in Appendix 2). What this book adds is the main principle that decides between them: how many mechanisms could produce the complaint. That number sets the usual pattern. Two other forces pull on the choice: danger calls for the rule-out however many mechanisms there are, and the clinician’s experience turns the sweep, over time, into instant recognition. Two of the four patterns have a variation, set out below: the rule-out runs in two ways, and the sweep has a second way in.

PatternWhen to use itHow it runs
Schema-based (the systematic sweep)The basic pattern: run the heuristics completely so nothing is missed; for complaints with a wide differential (abdominal pain)The full pass H1–H4 plus Red Flags; for a complaint with no quality to name, entered at H4
BranchingOne family, but sub-mechanisms compete; H1 splits into sub-qualities (dizziness)Take the branch H1 or H3 points to, and follow it to its end
Rule-outA likely mechanism plus a cannot-miss alternative; high-stakes complaints (chest pain, headache)Exclude the dangerous one first; in parallel when the questions overlap, first when they are separate
Pattern recognitionA classic picture recognised on sight; where practice leadsThe whole picture is seen at once; it grows out of the other three with experience

Schema-based — the systematic sweep. The basic pattern is the full sweep: run the heuristics in order (H1, H2, H3, H4, and the Red Flags sweep) so that nothing is missed. It is the pattern for the complaint with a wide differential, where no single mechanism dominates; abdominal pain is the typical case. On a complaint with only one possible mechanism the same sweep is short, and from outside it can look like an instant read. It is still the sweep, run quickly. The classical surgical sieve, VINDICATE and its kin (memory aids for the classes of cause), is the older, exhaustive form of this sweep. The sieve runs through every class of cause for every case. The schema-based sweep keeps that completeness for the complaints that need it, and enters each one at the question the complaint can answer.

The sweep entered at H4. Traditional teaching starts the sweep at H1: name the quality, then characterise it. But a whole class of complaints has no quality to name. Fever, Fatigue, Weight Loss, Night Sweats, Loss of Appetite, Sleep Disturbance — these give H1 nothing to grip. They affect the whole body and sit nowhere in particular. For them H1 is a dead end, and the sweep enters through a different door: H4, the accompanying symptoms across systems. The companions H4 gathers are the first real clue, the thread the patient truly presents with. From that group of companions the sweep runs back into the heuristics it skipped: H2 reads the tempo of the companions, H3 looks for what modifies them, and H1 returns last, now a rule-out check for a hidden localised complaint the patient never named. This H4-first entry matters. Appendix 3, which breaks down the review of systems, marks the complaints that need it. Taught the sweep only in its H1-first form, trainees are stranded on exactly these cases, and they meet them often. As far as we know, this formulation is new: the questions are the same, entered at a different point and run in a different order, for a set of complaints that can be named.

Robert Yildirim. Robert Yildirim, 68, has lost six kilograms over three months without trying; his trousers no longer fit. No pain, no cough, nothing he thinks to mention. H1 is stuck — nothing to characterise — so the sweep enters at H4. Any night sweats? Some, most weeks. Appetite? Gone, and food tastes wrong. Bowel change? Looser, not bloody. Any lumps? His wife noticed something in his neck — and on examination there is a firm two-centimetre left supraclavicular node. H4 has done what H1 could not. The complaint that had no quality now has a group of companions: constitutional symptoms with lymphadenopathy.

The sweep runs back through what H4 opened. H2 dates the node at six weeks, slow and painless, on the same three-month arc as the sweats; H3 finds nothing that changes it; H1 returns last and finds no hidden localised pain. The reasoning works with this group of companions. Painless supraclavicular lymphadenopathy with constitutional symptoms in a man of sixty-eight points to Family I neoplastic: lymphoma, or a metastatic carcinoma, since a left supraclavicular node can drain a gastric or other abdominal primary, and his lost appetite and looser stools point the same way. Behind these stand Family I infectious (tuberculosis, HIV-related) and, less often, an endocrine or autoimmune cause. Next: full blood count, LDH, CT of chest and abdomen, node biopsy, HIV and TB tests, and urgent referral on the suspected-cancer pathway. What made the reasoning possible was refusing to sit stuck at H1. The same path shapes what Yildirim is told: that something serious is possible, that it is still to be confirmed, and which few tests will settle it.

Branching. Some complaints look like one signature at H1 but split into sub-signatures on closer look. Dizziness is the classic example: spinning points at vestibular pathology (Family V), light-headed at perfusion failure (Family II), unsteady at mixed cerebellar or proprioceptive causes. The reasoning takes the branch H1 (or sometimes H3) selects and follows it down as if it were a clean single-mechanism case. Nausea, cough, diarrhoea, constipation, blood in the urine, menstrual problems and others branch the same way; it is the largest group of exceptions in the review of systems (Appendix 3 lists them).

Hannah Ricci. Hannah Ricci, 74, says she gets dizzy. H1 asks what dizzy means for her, and the word splits: does the room spin, do you feel you might faint, or are you unsteady on your feet? The room spins, she says, for less than a minute, when she turns over in bed or looks up at a high shelf. That chooses the vestibular branch, and within it benign paroxysmal positional vertigo, the brief spin set off by loose crystals in the inner ear; a Dix–Hallpike test that brings back the spin and its nystagmus confirms it, the H3 test of this branch. Had she said she nearly faints when she stands up, the branch would have been perfusion (Family II), tested by her blood pressure lying and standing. The trap sits at the branch point: a stroke in the brainstem or cerebellum can also make the room spin. Vertigo that is continuous for hours or days, a new headache or other neurological signs, or a patient who cannot walk without support sends the case down the central branch, to urgent assessment and imaging. Classify the shape first; then follow one branch at a time.

Rule-out. Some complaints have both a plausible benign mechanism and a plausible dangerous one, and the dangerous one must be excluded first, even if the benign one is more likely. The order rests on a simple asymmetry: missing the dangerous cause (a false negative) costs far more than looking for it when it is absent (a false positive). The rule-out runs in two ways, depending on whether the danger signs overlap the questions that describe the complaint. When they are separate, the rule-out runs first, as its own screen. A first seizure is the example: a structural or metabolic cause (a tumour, a bleed, a low glucose) must be excluded whatever the event looked like, before the heuristics describe the pattern. When they overlap, the rule-out runs in parallel. This happens in the cross-cutting complaints (Chest Pain, Abdominal Pain, Headache, Dyspnoea, Vision, Pelvic Pain), each with five or more plausible mechanisms at once: the same questions that describe the complaint also separate the dangerous causes from the benign. David Chen’s chest pain is a case in point: ischaemia is the leading candidate, while dissection, PE, tamponade and oesophageal rupture are all held and excluded together, each by the H3 or H4 question, or the test, that narrows it. Here the most mechanisms are in play at once, and here the four heuristics and the Red Flags sweep earn every second they take.

Pattern recognition — the destination. The fourth pattern is the state the other three grow into. When a clinician has worked through fifty presentations of biliary colic, the fifty-first is recognised on sight — a gripping pain under the right ribs that builds and stays, spreading to the right shoulder blade, after a fatty meal — the whole picture comes at once, and one test (an ultrasound for a stone) confirms it. Strictly, this is fast thinking at work (Section 3); we count it among the four because it shows the learner where the other three lead. Marion Colby’s biliary colic in Chapter 3 and Sarah Nolan’s GORD in Chapter 1 are typical of such a picture once it is known. Research calls this forming an illness script: a stored picture of a disease, built by running the sweep many times until it condenses into a single fast read. So it is the one pattern this book does not ask you to rehearse as a drill. The aim is that the fast read, when it forms, stays grounded in the mechanism: a read you could still take apart and justify by its mechanism.

See MAAS-Prep 6.2 to practise the four patterns: given a complaint, decide which of the four reasoning patterns it calls for — and explain what feature of the complaint told you which.

See MAAS-Prep 6.3 to practise the sweep: given a complaint with no localised signature (for example, weight loss), enter at H4 and walk the systematic sweep — and say where H2 and H3 come in.

Rule In, Rule Out

The patterns also differ in their logic. Schema-based and branching rule in: positive findings select the branch and build towards the diagnosis. Rule-out works the other way: it rules out, seeking the feature that would disprove the leading hypothesis. A “no” reassures; a single “yes” to a danger sign overturns the benign reading. Seen this way, a question in the history is itself a test, though we do not call it one. You ask it because its answer could change your mind; a question whose answer would change nothing costs time and tells you nothing. For David Chen, did the pain tear, and was it at its worst in the first second? is such a test: a yes would move aortic dissection above the heart attack. The questions narrow the field; the lab, the X-ray and the scan then confirm or refute.

Looking for the answer that would prove you wrong is called disconfirmation. It runs against habit: once a diagnosis seems to fit, the mind looks for what supports it and passes over what does not (confirmation bias). So the disconfirming question matters most where the benign reading is most convincing. For a headache that looks like tension-type, it is the thunderclap question — did it arrive in a second, the worst of your life? — whose yes points to a subarachnoid haemorrhage. For chest pain that seems benign in a patient with risk factors for a pulmonary embolism, it is a D-dimer: a normal result makes the embolism unlikely, a raised one sends you on to the scan. Deliberately considering the opposite reduces biased judgement more than good intentions do (Lord 1984). In medicine the evidence for such strategies is still modest (Ludolph 2018), and that literature seldom says which question or test to use. This book does: for each complaint, the cannot-miss mechanism tells you what to rule out, and the grammar tells you which question will do it.

Background: how the four patterns fit the research. Clinical-reasoning research describes three strategies: hypothetico-deductive (propose a diagnosis, then test it), scheme-inductive (reason down a branching scheme), and pattern recognition. The four patterns fit them. Schema-based and branching are forms of scheme-inductive reasoning; rule-out is hypothesis-testing driven by danger; pattern recognition is the same in both lists. In one study of the strategies clinicians use, scheme-inductive reasoning and pattern recognition were linked to markedly higher odds of the right diagnosis than hypothesis-testing (Coderre 2003), which supports teaching schemes.

Each can be run fast or slow: the dual processing Kahneman and Bowen describe. Underneath all four run two more kinds of reasoning. One is causal reasoning, from mechanism to symptom and back, the ground the whole book stands on. The other weighs how likely and how dangerous each explanation is, and it chooses both the pattern and the test. Followed strictly, the read-back reasons from the complaint to the explanation that best accounts for it: what philosophers call abduction.

See MAAS-Prep 6.4 to practise the disconfirming move: given a complaint and your leading hypothesis, name the one question and the one test whose result could prove you wrong — and say what each would show.

Time Pressure and Safety

The read-back is not run at leisure. Two constraints drive the sequence.

Time. The consultation is short: about ten minutes in much of Europe, and five minutes or less for about half the world’s people (Irving 2017). The heuristics are ordered to give the most information per minute: H1 first (highest yield, sets the family), H2 next (tempo separates catastrophe from slow build), H3 (the specific confirming test), H4 (brings the picture together and catches other families), and the Red Flags sweep for safety. The order bends when it must: a Red Flag surfacing early reorders it, and the complaints of Section 2 that give H1 nothing to grip enter at H4 instead.

How much of this the interview must carry also depends on where you stand. In a hospital clinic, where patients arrive already filtered and serious diagnoses are common, tests are near at hand and carry much of the load. In primary care it is the other way round: most complaints are self-limiting and the serious ones rare, so the interview, and sometimes simply the passage of time, does most of the work. In much of the world’s primary care, from a rural clinic to an overstretched district hospital, tests are scarce, slow or absent, and the interview is very nearly the only instrument there is. Roughly half the world’s people have little or no access to basic diagnostics, and the gap is widest exactly where disease is heaviest. An interview grounded in mechanism, which narrows a wide field to a few possibilities you can test, with the dangerous ones in view, is the one diagnostic instrument found everywhere. For much of the world it is the main tool; where tests are at hand, it decides which test is worth ordering and what its result means.

Safety. For any complaint with a plausible catastrophic mechanism, the rule-out must run, even when a fast pattern-recognition read would have settled on a benign mechanism. This is why rule-out is a reasoning pattern in its own right: safety is built into the read-back itself. Stopping too early at the first explanation that fits is what misses the dissection behind the angina, the subarachnoid haemorrhage behind the migraine, the central retinal artery occlusion behind the blurred vision, the ectopic pregnancy behind the menstrual cramp. A catastrophe hidden in a common complaint is rare in any one case and certain across a career. Robbins describes intestinal infarction, most often in older adults with cardiac or vascular disease. It mimics acute pancreatitis, appendicitis, perforated ulcer and cholecystitis so closely that the diagnosis is often delayed or missed, with a mortality above fifty per cent once sepsis develops.

This has a direct consequence for general practice. In the low-prevalence world of primary care, a test earns its place only when it answers a question the interview has already raised. And where a test is not yet warranted while a dangerous mechanism cannot be fully excluded, the rule-out is done by safety-netting: telling the patient plainly which signs would change the picture and when to return, and planning the review. In primary care, the interview and the follow-up are the rule-out.

See MAAS-Prep 6.5 to practise pattern selection under time pressure: given a busy schedule and a complaint, name the pattern, its shortest-possible run, and the safety-net questions you cannot skip regardless of time.

Follow-up Checks the Prediction

A diagnosis is a hypothesis about which mechanism is at work, and every hypothesis carries predictions: the right mechanism predicts the relief that should follow treatment, and the complication that follows if it is left untreated. Follow-up is where those predictions are checked.

GORD reasoning predicts that acid suppression will ease the burning; angina reasoning, that a nitrate will ease the pressure. When the predicted relief does not appear, the reasoning must re-open: the mechanism may have been wrong (back to H3, where you chose between mechanisms), or the treatment may not have reached it: too small a dose, not taken, or too short an interval before you looked. The first task at follow-up is to tell those two apart. The predicted complication works the same way. If the mechanism is a bowel obstruction, leaving it untreated would let it perforate; treat it, and the perforation should never come.

David Chen’s closure comes in hours — the troponin rises, the angiogram shows the occluded vessel, and the reasoning that took seconds at the door is confirmed; in general practice the same closure may take weeks of planned review. Chapter 10 takes up follow-up as its own subject.

See MAAS-Prep 6.6 to practise closing the loop: given a diagnosis, name the relief and the complication it predicts — and describe what you would revise if the prediction did not hold.

Where the Method Stops

The read-back produces diagnoses, and it has limits. Four are worth naming.

Illness scripts and encapsulation. The step-by-step read-back this chapter teaches is a scaffold the expert eventually leaves behind. With experience the steps merge into the single read of Section 2’s pattern recognition, and the equation is no longer walked. Experts pack many steps into one stored picture of a disease; Schmidt calls this knowledge encapsulation (Schmidt 2007). The method describes how reasoning is learned, and makes no claim about how the expert’s finished reasoning runs.

Undetermined presentations. Some presentations resist the tissue reading: chronic pain with central sensitisation, functional syndromes, medically unexplained symptoms. Here the tissue is sound, and the reporter, the nervous system that reports, has itself changed. Its best-characterised form is the sensitised reporter (central sensitisation; Woolf 2011). This happens often. Medically unexplained and functional presentations, now often grouped under the less pejorative heading of persistent physical symptoms, are a large fraction of primary-care contacts, so a clinician does well to suspect a sensitised reporter early, before being taken by surprise. The warning signs: a grammar whose four dimensions will not fit together; companions and timing that fit no single family; a story that shifts between visits; and treatments, each chosen by the read-back, that keep failing to bring the predicted relief. When those accumulate, stop pressing the tissue reading. The reasoning moves to the reporter: recognise the sensitised reporter, reframe the complaint for the patient, and redirect the plan, the three steps Chapter 9 sets out. The interview’s process skills (Structuring, Interpersonal and Communication: Scales 4, 5 and 6) and shared decision-making (Presenting Solutions, Scale 3) carry much of that work. Naming the limit is worth more than a mechanism forced onto a tissue that is not producing one.

See MAAS-Prep 6.7 to practise recognising when the read-back fails: given a story that shifts, will not fit together and does not respond to treatment, name the sensitised reporter and describe how the reasoning should change.

Off-map complaints. The bodily equation does not explain mental-health complaints; the MAAS mental-health handbook gives them their own method. Anxiety is a hybrid, with a psychological core and a somatic branch (Family V autonomic) that does reward a rule-out of medical causes; for anxiety the read-back partly applies. Substance use is a behaviour; its metabolic and neurological consequences are mechanism complaints, and the equation reads them.

Under-report. Some patients notice a symptom and say less than they feel. Older people with heart disease and people with diabetes are the known groups; a culture or a stoic habit of understatement, or a long illness the patient has got used to, can soften the grammar brought to H1 in the same way. The mechanism is doing more than the words describe. The technique for drawing it out (open questions, knowing what such patients tend to leave unsaid, teach-back) belongs to the interview handbook (Scale 2, and its chapter on contextual factors). The point for this book’s method is a correction: when the patient belongs to a group known to under-report, weigh a small reported symptom as somewhat larger than the words make it sound. A “bit of pressure” in an older patient with diabetes carries the diagnostic weight of frank pressure. Autonomic neuropathy and a high threshold for reporting can mute the very symptom that should alarm. Silent and atypical myocardial ischaemia is well described in exactly these groups (silent myocardial ischaemia; see References).

This chapter has taught the half of the interview that finds the mechanism. The other half, understanding the person (the worry behind the complaint, what this patient means by getting better), is carried by the interview’s process skills (Scales 4, 5 and 6) and put into practice at Presenting Solutions (Scale 3). The two halves meet there. Sound reasoning makes the shared decision honest. It tells you and the patient what has been established, what has been excluded and what is still open, and so what is reasonable to do now, what can safely wait, and with what confidence.

What You’ve Learned

Deliberate clinical reasoning reads the complaint back: from the complaint at the door, through the grammar signature, through the mechanism, to the specific diagnosis. Its aim is to reach the few explanations most likely to be right and most dangerous to miss, a short list that tells you which scarce, fallible tests to order, and to understand the person well enough to decide, with them, what to do. The four heuristics each draw out part of the grammar, with H3 testing what the quality-word implies; they stay few and aimed, so that the patient’s answers stay reliable. Four patterns organise the reasoning: schema-based, branching, rule-out and pattern recognition. Which one a complaint needs depends mainly on how many mechanisms could produce it; danger and experience also pull on the choice. The tests you then order should be the ones that could change the diagnosis, including the one that would prove your leading hypothesis wrong. The reasoning closes at follow-up, where the outcome confirms or revises the mechanism: the right mechanism predicts the relief that should follow and the complication that threatens, and the outcome tests that prediction.

Reflections

Five open-ended scenarios for thinking, journaling, or peer discussion. No answer key: they are meant to connect what you have read with the patients you meet.

Reflection 1 — what each heuristic draws out. Take a recent consultation. Go through each of the four heuristics you asked and name what each question drew out. Think about: was one heuristic underused? Which part of the signature did it leave unasked, and what might you have missed?

Reflection 2 — pattern selection. A patient presents with sudden severe headache. Think about: which of the four patterns should the reasoning take? Compare with a patient who presents with three months of intermittent mild headaches. What has changed, and why does the pattern change?

Reflection 3 — the schema-based sweep, entered at H4. A patient presents with unexplained weight loss. There is no other complaint. Think about: which companions do you ask about, in what order, and how do the answers narrow the differential? Where does H2 fit in? When, if at all, does H3 come into play?

Reflection 4 — predict before you prescribe. You diagnose a patient with a specific mechanism and are about to prescribe. Before you do, write down what relief you expect, how much, and by when. Think about: what in the mechanism tells you the kind and the timing of the relief? If the patient returns at that time no better, which part of your written prediction would you check first: the mechanism, the dose, whether the treatment was taken, or the interval?

Reflection 5 — safety versus efficiency. A patient presents with headache and it is nearly closing time. The dangerous alternative (SAH) is unlikely here. Think about: what is the shortest safe interview? Which questions cannot be skipped, and why? What is the cost of skipping them if it turns out to be SAH?

From Here to Chapter 7

You have met the read-back and its four patterns: how the interview finds the mechanism behind a complaint. But the mechanism is only half the read-back. Ischaemia is a mechanism; the atherosclerotic plaque, the embolus, the vasospasm behind it are its causes, and the same mechanism can be driven by several of the seven aetiologies named in Chapter 5. Chapter 7 runs the second half: from the mechanism the read-back reaches, on to the specific cause that has to be treated and to the person in whom it arose. There the extended heuristics (H5–H7) take over, and relief gives way to cure.

References

  1. Bowen JL. Educational strategies to promote clinical diagnostic reasoning. N Engl J Med. 2006;355(21):2217–2225. — problem representation, semantic qualifiers and illness scripts as teachable steps of diagnostic reasoning.
  2. Coderre S, Mandin H, Harasym PH, Fick GH. Diagnostic reasoning strategies and diagnostic success. Med Educ. 2003;37(8):695–703. — the three diagnostic strategies (hypothetico-deductive, scheme-inductive, pattern recognition) and their comparative success.
  3. Fleming KA, Horton S, Wilson ML, et al. The Lancet Commission on diagnostics: transforming access to diagnostics. Lancet. 2021;398(10315):1997–2050. — roughly 47% of the world’s population has little or no access to basic diagnostics.
  4. Galesic M, Bosnjak M. Effects of questionnaire length on participation and indicators of response quality in a web survey. Public Opin Q. 2009;73(2):349–360. — questions placed later in a long questionnaire received faster, shorter and more uniform answers.
  5. Hampton JR, Harrison MJG, Mitchell JRA, Prichard JS, Seymour C. Relative contributions of history-taking, physical examination, and laboratory investigation to diagnosis and management of medical outpatients. BMJ. 1975;2(5969):486–489. — history alone yielded the diagnosis in ~82% of cases.
  6. Irving G, Neves AL, Dambha-Miller H, et al. International variations in primary care physician consultation time: a systematic review of 67 countries. BMJ Open. 2017;7(10):e017902. — consultations last five minutes or less for about half the world’s population.
  7. Kahneman D. Thinking, Fast and Slow. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux; 2011. — for the dual-process account of fast and slow reasoning.
  8. Kessels RPC. Patients’ memory for medical information. J R Soc Med. 2003;96(5):219–222. — 40–80% of medical information is forgotten immediately, and the more is given, the less is retained.
  9. Krosnick JA. Response strategies for coping with the cognitive demands of attitude measures in surveys. Appl Cogn Psychol. 1991;5(3):213–236. — when answering takes effort, respondents settle for a satisfactory answer (satisficing), the more so as ability and motivation fall.
  10. Lord CG, Lepper MR, Preston E. Considering the opposite: a corrective strategy for social judgment. J Pers Soc Psychol. 1984;47(6):1231–1243. — considering the opposite corrected bias more than an instruction to be fair and unbiased (laboratory studies).
  11. Ludolph R, Schulz PJ. Debiasing health-related judgments and decision making: a systematic review. Med Decis Making. 2018;38(1):3–13. — debiasing strategies for health judgements had mixed results, and the evidence for them is limited.
  12. Morgan DJ, Pineles L, Owczarzak J, et al. Accuracy of practitioner estimates of probability of diagnosis before and after testing. JAMA Intern Med. 2021;181(6):747–755. — practitioners systematically overestimate how likely a disease is; a sound sense of that likelihood before testing matters as much as the test itself.
  13. Narayan S, Krosnick JA. Education moderates some response effects in attitude measurement. Public Opin Q. 1996;60(1):58–88. — response effects such as agreeing regardless of content were strongest among respondents with the least schooling.
  14. O’Sullivan JW, Stevens S, Hobbs FDR, et al. Overtesting and undertesting in primary care: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ Open. 2018;8(2):e018557. — overuse of diagnostic tests is common and a source of false-positive harm and cost.
  15. Peterson MC, Holbrook JH, Von Hales D, Smith NL, Staker LV. Contributions of the history, physical examination, and laboratory investigation in making medical diagnoses. West J Med. 1992;156(2):163–165. — history responsible for 76% of diagnoses.
  16. Schmidt HG, Rikers RMJP. How expertise develops in medicine: knowledge encapsulation and illness script formation. Med Educ. 2007;41(12):1133–1139. — as expertise grows, biomedical knowledge becomes encapsulated in clinical concepts and illness scripts, and stays available when a case does not fit.
  17. Shams P, Gul Z, Makaryus AN. Silent myocardial ischemia. In: StatPearls. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing; 2024. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK536915/ — older patients with diabetes, and those with earlier myocardial infarction, are prone to ischaemia without chest pain.
  18. Woolf CJ. Central sensitization: implications for the diagnosis and treatment of pain. Pain. 2011;152(3 Suppl):S2–S15. — for the sensitised reporter.

Chapter 7 · From Mechanism to Cause, and Cause to Cure

Learning objectives

  • Carry the reasoning on from the mechanism to the aetiology: the second half of the read-back, which H5–H7 bring out
  • Say what each extended heuristic adds: H5 the person and the life-course, H6 the underlying disease and prior treatments, H7 the aetiology
  • Distinguish treatment aimed at the mechanism (relief) from treatment aimed at the aetiology (cure), and see why treating the cause of atherosclerotic disease needs both medicines and changes in daily life
  • Use the same interview structure across successive visits — and read a failed treatment as an H3 test that carries information
  • Recognise where the second half stops, as in the idiopathic case, and where it turns from the tissue to the reporter, as with the sensitised reporter (Chapter 9); and where the mental-health handbook takes over

Anna Petrov is back a week later. On her first visit she came with chest pain on exertion; in Chapter 4 the reasoning read her complaint back to its mechanism, coronary ischaemia, and you ordered the first tests and referred her to the rapid-access chest pain clinic. Her results are in: the ECG shows sinus rhythm with subtle anterolateral T-wave flattening; at the clinic, CT coronary angiography showed a 70% narrowing of the left anterior descending artery; her total cholesterol is 6.8 with an LDL of 4.2; fasting glucose and renal function are normal. The mechanism is confirmed: coronary ischaemia causing stable angina, with atherosclerotic coronary disease underneath. The equation is complete, and you have a diagnosis.

What is not yet complete is the treatment plan. That takes the second half of the interview.

You start with H5 — the person and the “why now”. Anna lives alone; her husband Peter died two years ago. She walks to the shops daily — ten minutes each way, one hill on the return. She cooks most meals herself, though she has slipped towards ready-meals since Peter died. One glass of wine some evenings. She has gained about six kilograms in the last eighteen months, mostly since she stopped walking with him. You ask what she used to do. “We walked forty minutes every day for twenty years.” Now: just the shops — a widow whose walking companion is gone.

You ask a longer question — the kind you would not ask on a first visit but that matters here. What was her life like before she met Peter, growing up. Anna pauses. She was the eldest of three; her father drank, sometimes badly, and the household ran on her mother’s anxiety. She started smoking at fifteen — everyone did, and it settled her. She left home at eighteen for work; met Peter at twenty. “He was quiet. Peter was quiet. That was what I needed.” She stopped smoking in her thirties after their son was born, started again briefly during a bad period at work in her fifties, stopped for good when her mother died of a heart attack at seventy-four. She has never talked much about her childhood; her son does not know. She is not asking you to fix any of it. But when you ask her what “better” would mean, she says: “Being able to walk properly again. And not being frightened every time my chest goes.”

You ask about her tablets. Amlodipine 5 mg for hypertension, eight years, no other regulars. Her blood pressure today is 145/85 — poorly controlled. She takes paracetamol for the arthritis in her knees, and ibuprofen “for the bad days” — two, three days a week. That would explain some of her BP.

You ask about her family. Her mother’s MI at 74; her father’s stroke at 78; her younger brother’s bypass at 68. Strong family history. Combined with her smoking history — twenty pack-years, quit fifteen years ago — and the elevated LDL, her lifetime cardiovascular risk was always going to be high.

You now have the second half of the picture. This chapter is about what H1–H4 could not bring out: the aetiology, the underlying disease, the person who has the disease, and the plan you build from these three.

The Read-Back Has a Second Half

Where H1–H4 stopped, and why the chain continues. Chapter 6 set out the first half of the read-back: H1–H4 take you from the complaint to the mechanism, as they took Anna to her ischaemia in Chapter 4. The read-back goes further than the mechanism, along the full chain Chapter 5 gave: complaint → mechanism → family → aetiology. A mechanism is enough to relieve the symptom, and not yet enough to treat the cause. Angina is what is happening; atherosclerotic coronary disease is why; and a plan aimed at the cause needs to know that why.

The extended heuristics of the interview handbook, H5, H6 and H7, run the second half. They have always been part of the interview. This chapter shows what each one brings out, in the order the encounter usually takes, from the person towards the cause: H5 the person who has the disease, H6 the underlying disease and what has been tried before, H7 the aetiology. Anna’s visit followed this order, from her “why now” to her family history. The order is a convenience. Follow the case: when the aetiology is the pressing question, start with H7.

HeuristicInterview gestureWhat it brings out
H5 Psychosocial ImpactWhat is going on in your life, and why now?The person — function, meaning, life-course context, secondary gain
H6 StagingWhat have you had before, and what medicines are you on?The underlying disease and other illnesses, prior treatments (what has been tried), current medications (which can themselves be the cause)
H7 Risk and VulnerabilityWhat runs in your family, and what do you use?Risk factors and vulnerabilities that match the classical aetiologies of Chapter 5

The three heuristics overlap; they look at one life from different sides. A family history is at once a risk (H7) and a past illness in the household (H6); a current medication is both what a patient takes (H6) and, sometimes, the cause itself (H7); and the “why now” of H5 often surfaces the aetiology directly.

See MAAS-Prep 7.1 to practise the second half: given a case whose mechanism has been found, name what H5, H6 and H7 each still need to add before a plan can be built.

H5 — The Person, the Life-Course, and the ACE Frame

Why “why now” sometimes has to go further back. H5 asks about the person: what is going on in their life, what matters to them, what “better” would look like, what the disease costs them in function and meaning. Its immediate use is the “why now” question — the change or trigger that turned a longstanding condition into today’s consultation. For Anna the answer is recent and clear: she stopped walking because Peter died, she has gained weight since, and her diet has slipped towards ready-meals. Bereavement is her “why now.”

H5 goes further when the shape of a case invites it. The behaviours behind Anna’s disease (smoking from fifteen, a return to smoking during a hard period in her fifties, comfort-eating after her husband died) sit against a family background of a father who drank and a mother who was frightened. That background is life-course context, and the clinician keeps it as context. Asking the longer question, you hear, without labelling anything, that Anna’s adult ways of coping took shape in a childhood that gave her little support, and that her twenty years with Peter helped make up for that. When he died she lost more than him. She lost the daily pattern of walking, cooking and sleeping that had kept her body quiet.

Here the framework of adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) becomes useful, even in a clinical book on physical illness. The CDC–Kaiser ACE study (Felitti and colleagues, 1998) and two decades of studies since show that the more adverse experiences a child has (parental substance use, mental illness, domestic violence, neglect, abuse), the higher the adult risk of cardiovascular disease, chronic lung disease, autoimmune disease, obesity, depression and suicide. Adversity works through two routes. One is behaviour: smoking, alcohol, little exercise, poor diet. The other is the body’s stress response: long-term activation of the HPA axis, and inflammation. For ischaemic heart disease the risk rises step by step. Nine of ten kinds of adversity each raise it by 30 to 70 per cent, and seven or more raise it more than threefold (odds ratio 3.6; Dong 2004). In that study, psychological factors such as depressed mood and anger carried more of the extra risk than the traditional risk factors did. The history cannot settle whether Anna would meet the strict ACE criteria: abuse and neglect often go unmentioned, so a low count may miss part of what happened. The frame is applied to a recognisable life-course shape, without a score, and it helps you understand her adult habits without turning them into a disorder.

Anna is a woman with atherosclerotic coronary disease whose life history includes some adversity. Knowing that history changes what the plan can offer. She is unlikely to “walk more” on advice alone; grief support is worth offering lightly; and the treatment she can keep to is one that fits her life.

See MAAS-Prep 7.2 to practise the life-course question: given a case, say what the longer H5 question could bring out about the person, and name one thing the answer would change about the plan.

H6 — Staging, Prior Treatments, and the Drug That Is the Cause

Past illness, past treatment, current medications — all diagnostic. H6 covers what a patient has had before, what has been done for it, and what they are taking now. It shows what the plan must respect: a patient with chronic kidney disease cannot have an NSAID renewed; a patient on warfarin needs any antiplatelet plan reconsidered. It also gives two more specific things.

First, prior treatments carry information. A treatment that was tried and did not work says something about the mechanism: it was an H3 test, and its answer was “no”. A migraine that did not respond to a triptan is a different clinical problem from one that did. Section 7 takes this further.

Second, a current medication can itself be the cause. The ulcer whose burning would not settle on any acid-suppression turned out to be driven by the daily anti-inflammatory the patient took for arthritis. The tremor that looked essential turned out to be a beta-agonist inhaler. The cognitive slowing that looked like early dementia turned out to be the anticholinergic added six months earlier. H6 catches these because it asks systematically what a patient takes and when each drug was started. The drug then belongs among the candidates: the chemical aetiology of Chapter 5.

Anna’s H6 brings a small but important find. Her BP is 145/85 on amlodipine 5 mg — poorly controlled. Before you reach for a second antihypertensive, ask what else she takes. Ibuprofen two or three days a week for her knees. NSAIDs raise blood pressure by a few mmHg on average, mainly in people who already have hypertension (Johnson 1994). Her uncontrolled BP may be partly caused by the drug (iatrogenic). Switching her from ibuprofen to a topical NSAID, with paracetamol only as needed, and repeating the BP in eight weeks, is a plan built from H6 as well as from the guideline. Paracetamol stays occasional because, taken regularly, it raises blood pressure as well: four times a day, it added about 5 mmHg to the systolic pressure of people with hypertension (MacIntyre 2022).

See MAAS-Prep 7.3 to practise reading H6: given a case, identify a current medication that could itself be the cause; identify a prior treatment whose failure is diagnostic data; and describe how each changes the plan.

H7 — The Aetiology Heuristic

From risk and vulnerability to the classical seven aetiologies. H7 asks about the patient’s risks and vulnerabilities: what runs in the family, what they smoke, drink, work with; the exposures a life carries. These answers match the seven aetiologies of Chapter 5 almost directly (Appendix 4 maps them to their mechanisms). Family history and smoking behind a coronary syndrome point to the degenerative aetiology of atherosclerosis; a family history of connective-tissue disease behind joint symptoms points to an immunological aetiology; a solvent-exposed work history behind a headache points to a chemical one. H7 is the heuristic that names the cause behind the mechanism.

For Anna, H7 brings out the causes behind her disease. A mother who died of MI at 74; a father who had a stroke at 78; a younger brother who needed a bypass. Twenty pack-years of past smoking. An LDL of 4.2. Behind her ischaemia lies atherosclerotic coronary disease of the classical mixed kind: part inherited, part behavioural, part accumulated wear. In Chapter 5’s terms the aetiology is degenerative and nutritional, with an inherited share. Chapter 5 named these aetiologies; H7 finds them in this patient.

As in the first half, the questions stay few: let the mechanism you have found choose them. When the mechanism is ischaemia, H7 asks about atherosclerotic risk; when the mechanism is inflammatory synovitis, about autoimmune family history; when the pain is neuropathic, about diabetes and B12 and alcohol.

The Two Targets of Treatment: Relief and Cure

Treat the mechanism, and you relieve the symptom; treat the aetiology, and you address the cause. Aim treatment at the mechanism and you get relief: an antacid neutralises the acid that is burning the oesophageal mucosa; a nitrate widens the veins and eases the heart’s workload, so the narrowed coronary supply is enough again; a bronchodilator opens the constricted airway. The symptom eases; the underlying cause has not been addressed. Aim treatment at the aetiology and you get cure, or at least a slower or milder course of the disease. Stop the anti-inflammatory that is causing the ulcer, and the mucosa heals. Treat the H. pylori that maintains it. Stop smoking; lower the LDL; lower the BP; anticoagulate in atrial fibrillation, to prevent the clot that causes a stroke.

The better treatment usually addresses the cause as well, and the cause is what H5–H7 bring out. The line between the two targets is not always sharp: a statin treats the underlying disease and changes its course at the same time, and “cure” is often a change of course. Treating the mechanism still matters; angina without a nitrate is a bad idea. The aim is to reach past the symptom to the cause.

Once you know the mechanism, you can offer relief or cure. A third offer is the commonest: understanding. Many patients came for neither relief nor cure; for them the mechanism, explained in plain words, is enough, and the explanation is the right and complete endpoint. Chapter 10 takes this up.

Anna’s atherosclerotic disease makes the point clearly: treating its cause has two arms that work together. A pharmacological arm: a statin, low-dose aspirin, and her blood pressure treated once the ibuprofen, which raises it, is stopped. And a behavioural arm: regular walking, a Mediterranean-pattern diet, and the smoking cessation she achieved fifteen years ago. The behavioural arm is medicine with its own evidence. In large studies of heart disease and its prevention, regular physical activity, a Mediterranean-pattern diet and stopping smoking each carry substantial benefit (Yusuf 2004; Estruch 2018; Lear 2017). The exact size of each effect, and how it compares with a given drug, varies by outcome and is still debated. Across the evidence, a plan that addresses both arms does more than one that treats only the pharmacological.

The two arms are not equally easy to deliver. The pharmacological arm fits a fifteen-minute consultation; the behavioural arm needs more time, and a conversation continued across visits.

See MAAS-Prep 7.4 to practise the split: given a diagnosis, name what treats the mechanism and what treats the aetiology — and, for the aetiology, name both the pharmacological and the behavioural options and their approximate evidence.

The Plan Is Built From the Person

H5 and H6 turn a plan that is right in principle into one the patient can follow. H5 tells you what the patient can keep to and what “better” means to them; H6 tells you what will interact with what, and what has already been tried. The same diagnosis produces different plans for different lives.

Anna’s plan takes shape accordingly. Mechanism relief now: a nitrate spray for any angina attack. Aetiology, pharmacological: a statin (evidence-strong for her situation); low-dose aspirin; replace the ibuprofen, which also blunts the protective effect of aspirin on the platelets (Catella-Lawson 2001), with a topical NSAID and paracetamol as needed, and repeat the BP in eight weeks — if still high, add ramipril then. Aetiology, behavioural: this is where the person decides what is possible. She cannot just “walk more” because Peter was the walk; a plan that ignores this will not be followed. What the reasoning supplies is the shape of the plan — regular walking matters as much as most of her tablets, grief is part of why it stopped, and the plan must fit a widow who lives alone. How that conversation is actually held — the phrasing, the pacing, the shared decision — is the interview handbook’s subject (Presenting Solutions, Scale 3). Then a follow-up in eight weeks: repeat BP and lipids, and check whether she walks more, has less angina and needs the nitrate less, as the plan predicted.

It is a plan Anna can realistically begin to follow.

Continuity: The Interview Across Visits, H3 Across Time

The structure links the visits; a failed treatment is an H3 test. Anna’s reasoning has now spanned two visits. The first found the mechanism (Chapter 4); the second finds the aetiology, the underlying disease and the person, and settles the plan (this chapter). Some complaints become clear only over time, and the structure of the interview links one visit to the next.

Two things pass from one visit to the next. The first is the diagnostic thread: the mechanism found on visit 1 is the hypothesis being tested on visit 2 by the results, and refined on visit 3 by response to treatment. The clinician who has run the heuristics once picks the interview up at the next visit where it stopped. The second is the person: Anna returns as a whole person, a widow with last week’s results, carrying the chest pain, the LDL and the family history as parts of a life. The chart holds the diagnostic thread; the continuity of the relationship holds the person. Both are the interview’s work, and both make the second-half heuristics possible. H5 in particular grows fuller across visits, as trust grows.

The heuristic that most clearly carries across time is H3. On the first visit, H3 was the confirming test for the mechanism: does an antacid ease the burning, does rest ease the pressure, does a cue bring back the memory. On the second visit, H3 keeps its role but its object changes. It now tests the treatment: did the two-week acid-suppressant trial ease the burning; did the nitrate work when she used it; is her BP responding to the plan you set. The question keeps its shape: the mechanism you suspect predicts what should happen, and you check whether it does.

It follows that a treatment that has failed is an H3 test whose answer was “no”, as diagnostic as any other. How much it tells you depends on how specifically the treatment targeted the mechanism: a mechanism-specific agent that fails points sharply, while a broad one, such as a general painkiller that would ease many causes, tests the mechanism only weakly. An angina that did not respond to a beta-blocker at an adequate dose is telling you something: perhaps the mechanism was not classical demand-ischaemia (variant angina? microvascular disease?), perhaps a second mechanism co-exists, perhaps the drug did not reach the target. A back pain that did not respond to physiotherapy is different from one never sent. A blood pressure that did not fall on amlodipine 5 mg is telling you that either the dose is too low, or a drug (the ibuprofen) is working against it, or a second mechanism is at work.

If the structure is kept steady from visit to visit (the mechanism named, the plan written down, the predictions made explicit), a colleague picking up the case knows what has been tested, what is still open, and what the next H3 needs to ask. Keeping track of the diagnosis and keeping track of the person become one habit.

See MAAS-Prep 7.5 to practise the continuity: given a case seen across three visits, identify at each visit the H3 question being asked, its target (mechanism or treatment), the prediction, and what a “no” would revise.

Where the Second Half Stops — Cautions

The idiopathic case, the sensitised reporter, and the risk of reading a psychosocial cause into every case. Three limits are worth naming.

The idiopathic case. Sometimes the aetiology cannot be found. Primary essential hypertension, idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis, many primary headache disorders: the mechanism can be described and treated; the cause cannot yet be identified. The extended heuristics may narrow the list of possible causes without settling on one. An unknown cause is still a result: it changes what treatment aims at (the mechanism, and the known risk factors) and what the follow-up watches for (any signal that shifts the picture towards a nameable aetiology).

The sensitised reporter. Chapter 6 named the case in which the tissue reading no longer holds: persistent physical symptoms, chronic pain with central sensitisation, medically unexplained symptoms. The tissue is sound, and the reporter, the nervous system that carries the signal, has itself become oversensitive. When the story will not hang together as the signature of a tissue, when treatments have all been given and none has held, and when the companions shift between visits, pressing harder on the tissue cannot help. The second half then runs on the reporter: what predisposed it, what set it off and what keeps it sensitised, which Chapter 9 takes up. The interview’s process skills (Scales 4, 5 and 6) and shared decision-making carry the plan. Where mood or trauma is central, the mental-health handbook joins in.

The caution against reading a psychosocial cause into every hard case. The life-course question is useful, and it does not solve a puzzle whose answer we do not know. When a plan is not working, and the mechanism is right, the treatment is right and the patient is taking it, do not reach first for adversity in the history. Sometimes atherosclerosis is what atherosclerosis is, and a family story does not have to explain whatever is left unexplained. Ask, listen, and use what you find.

See MAAS-Prep 7.6 to practise the boundary: given a case where the second half is not narrowing the plan, decide whether you are meeting the idiopathic case, the sensitised reporter, or a case where the mechanism or the treatment simply needs more time — and describe what the next visit should do differently.

What You’ve Learned

The read-back has a second half. H5–H7, the extended heuristics of the interview handbook, bring out what H1–H4 cannot: the person who has the disease (H5, including, where useful, the life-course context the ACE frame describes), the underlying disease and earlier treatments (H6), and the aetiology behind the mechanism (H7). Treatment of the mechanism brings relief; treatment of the aetiology brings cure. Some aetiologies need both medicines and changes in daily life, atherosclerotic disease most clearly, and for these the evidence supports a plan that does both. The plan itself is built from the person: H6 for what will interact and what has been tried, H5 for what the patient can keep to. Real practice spreads this reasoning over several visits, and the MAAS structure links them: the mechanism from the first visit is the hypothesis tested at the second, and H3, which confirmed the mechanism, becomes the question that tests the treatment. A failed treatment is an H3 test whose answer was “no”, as diagnostic as any confirming test that came before.

Reflections

Five open-ended scenarios for thinking, journaling, or peer discussion. No answer key: they are meant to connect what you have read with the patients you meet.

Reflection 1 — same mechanism, different cause. Two patients present with the same grammar and the same mechanism: burning epigastric pain, chemical irritation of the gastric and duodenal lining. In one, H7 brings out heavy NSAID use for arthritis. In the other, H7 brings out H. pylori exposure with no analgesic history. Same mechanism, same relief on antacid — but different cure. Think about: what does the plan look like for each, and what does follow-up test?

Reflection 2 — the medication that is the cause. A patient with new tremor is referred to you as possible essential tremor. Before you accept the label, go through H6. Think about: what current medications could be the cause? What prior treatments — if the tremor has been present a while — would be diagnostic if they did not work?

Reflection 3 — the H5 question, done well. A 55-year-old man with recurrent tension headaches, on his fifth trial of a preventive that has not helped. You have not yet asked the longer H5 question. Draft the question in your own words. Think about: what would you do with the answer if it turns out he was the child of an alcoholic and his adult coping is fragile? What would you not do?

Reflection 4 — two arms of an aetiology-level plan, and how to explain them. Take a chronic condition you saw last week where the aetiology was identifiable. Write down the pharmacological arm and the behavioural arm side by side. Think about: which one did you emphasise in the consultation? Which one has the stronger evidence for that condition? What would a plan look like that gave both their due weight — and how would you explain both arms to that patient in a way that lets them carry the plan out of the room?

Reflection 5 — the failed treatment as H3 test. A patient returns saying the treatment did not help. Rather than reaching for the next-line agent, treat it as an H3 test whose answer was “no”. Think about: what did the prescription assume about the mechanism? What does the “no” now revise? What is the next H3 that follows from that revision?

From Here to Chapter 8

You have met the second half of the read-back and seen how it turns a diagnosis of mechanism into a plan that fits the patient. Chapter 8 turns to a distinct clinical territory: the complaints where the patient is not the one who has noticed. Memory loss, hearing loss, gait change, personality change: others notice them first, sometimes because the lost ability is the very one that would notice. The read-back still runs, with the three swaps of Chapter 3 in the grammar and with the informant as a main source of the history. These are the hardest cases for a method that starts from what the patient feels.

References

  1. Catella-Lawson F, Reilly MP, Kapoor SC, et al. Cyclooxygenase inhibitors and the antiplatelet effects of aspirin. N Engl J Med. 2001;345(25):1809–1817. — ibuprofen taken before aspirin blocked aspirin’s antiplatelet effect; paracetamol, rofecoxib and diclofenac did not.
  2. Dong M, Giles WH, Felitti VJ, et al. Insights into causal pathways for ischemic heart disease: Adverse Childhood Experiences Study. Circulation. 2004;110(13):1761–1766. — the IHD-specific figures (nine of ten categories 1.3–1.7-fold; seven or more ACEs OR 3.6), mediated more by psychological factors than by traditional risk factors.
  3. Estruch R, Ros E, Salas-Salvadó J, et al. Primary prevention of cardiovascular disease with a Mediterranean diet supplemented with extra-virgin olive oil or nuts. N Engl J Med. 2018;378(25):e34. — republished 2018 after the 2013 PREDIMED article (N Engl J Med. 2013;368:1279–90) was retracted for a randomisation irregularity; the primary-prevention effect held.
  4. Felitti VJ, Anda RF, Nordenberg D, et al. Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults: the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study. Am J Prev Med. 1998;14(4):245–258. — four or more adverse childhood experiences raised the risk of several leading causes of adult death, ischaemic heart disease among them.
  5. Johnson AG, Nguyen TV, Day RO. Do nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs affect blood pressure? A meta-analysis. Ann Intern Med. 1994;121(4):289–300. — NSAIDs raised mean blood pressure by about 5 mmHg, most in people already treated for hypertension.
  6. Lear SA, Hu W, Rangarajan S, et al. The effect of physical activity on mortality and cardiovascular disease in 130,000 people from 17 high-, middle-, and low-income countries (the PURE study). Lancet. 2017;390(10113):2643–2654. — more physical activity, walking and housework included, went with lower mortality and fewer cardiovascular events in rich and poor countries alike.
  7. MacIntyre IM, Turtle EJ, Farrah TE, et al. Regular acetaminophen use and blood pressure in people with hypertension: the PATH-BP trial. Circulation. 2022;145(6):416–423. — regular paracetamol, 1 g four times daily, raised daytime systolic pressure by 4.7 mmHg against placebo.
  8. Yusuf S, Hawken S, Ôunpuu S, et al. Effect of potentially modifiable risk factors associated with myocardial infarction in 52 countries (the INTERHEART study). Lancet. 2004;364(9438):937–952. — nine modifiable risk factors accounted for about 90% of the risk of a first myocardial infarction, in every region studied.

Chapter 8 · When the Patient Is Not the One Who Notices

Learning objectives

  • Identify the class of complaints where someone other than the patient notices first
  • Use the collateral history, what relatives or carers have seen, as a main source of the history
  • Use functional probes, small bedside tests, to find the level of a loss of function, as an antacid does for a burning pain
  • Read the gap between what the patient and the informant report as a clue to the diagnosis
  • Recognise anosognosia: the trap of an illness that damages the patient’s own noticing

Margaret Beaumont, 78, sits opposite you with her daughter Rachel. Rachel does most of the talking. “She’s asking the same questions again and again. Last week she left the stove on twice. Yesterday she got lost coming back from the shop she has been going to for thirty years.” Margaret listens patiently and, when you ask her, says: “I’m fine. I forget the odd thing, but everyone does.” She agrees to a short cognitive test. On the three-word recall she scores zero at five minutes; when you cue her (“one was a fruit”), she recalls nothing further. She smiles and says: “See? I’m fine.”

Margaret’s body has crossed several thresholds: short-term memory, finding her way, and doing everyday tasks in the right order. Margaret has not noticed. Her daughter has. The memory that would normally notice the change, by keeping track of how well it works, is the very thing that is failing. That failure to notice is itself a diagnostic feature of the illness.

The read-back you have practised assumes that the patient brings the complaint: the body with the mechanism is also the one that reports it. Here that assumption fails. Margaret has the mechanism, and Rachel reports it. This is one of the method’s edges, and the reasoning changes in three definite ways. The informant becomes the one who notices. The gap between the two accounts becomes a clue. And a functional probe, a small bedside test, takes the place of the question about what makes the symptom better or worse. This chapter works out these changes; the craft of taking a collateral history belongs to the interview handbook.

When the Read-Back Starts from Someone Else’s Report

The class of complaints. Some complaints are almost always brought by the patient: pain, breathlessness, palpitations, dizziness. The patient is the natural noticer, and the read-back begins with their report. Other complaints are frequently brought by someone else, or brought by the patient only because someone else insisted: memory loss, hearing loss, gait change, loss of smell, personality change, and sometimes changes in vision. In each the patient has not noticed, for one of two reasons. Sometimes the ability that would do the noticing is itself failing: memory, insight, or the ability to check one’s own performance. This is anosognosia, and Section 5 returns to it. More often the change came on so gradually that the patient adapted to it by degrees: hearing that faded over years, a gait that slowed step by step, a sense of smell gone before it was missed. Either way, the noticing falls to someone else.

In the review of systems (Appendix 3) they are the entries Memory, Hearing, Vision and Weakness, each read there as a lost function. These are the negative departures of Chapter 3. What marks them is the way the change is noticed. Something has been lost, and another person often notices the loss before the patient does. Two things follow. The informant becomes a main source of the history, and the gap between what the patient reports and what the informant reports becomes diagnostic.

Chapter 3 set out the three swaps the grammar needs for this class. This chapter shows how the reasoning runs when the noticer is someone else.

See MAAS-Prep 8.1 to practise recognising the class: given a short vignette, decide whether the one who notices is the patient, the informant, or both — and name the feature of the complaint that told you which.

The Collateral History as a Main Source

Here the read-back starts from the collateral history. In most consultations the interview is one-to-one: the patient sits down, and the read-back begins with their story. In this class it begins with someone else’s story, and you apply H1–H4 to what the informant has observed.

HeuristicQuestion to the informant
H1 ComplaintWhat did you notice first? What did it look like or sound like?
H2 Time-IntensityWhen did you first notice? Has it been steady, worse, better? Any sudden change?
H3 Modifying FactorsDoes anything bring it out, or help? Are there things they used to do that they cannot do now?
H4 ContextAnything else you have noticed — behaviour, mood, sleep, weight, medications, other symptoms?

The two accounts are most useful heard separately: an informant’s presence can shape the patient’s answers, and the patient’s can shape the informant’s. How to arrange that gently, with a private word with each, is the interview handbook’s craft (the process skills, Scales 4, 5 and 6; see the Glossary).

The informant can be wrong. What they report is one source of information, and you judge how reliable it is: they may be worried, they may have their own agenda, they may misread what they see.

See MAAS-Prep 8.2 to practise the collateral interview: given a presentation, list the H1–H4 questions you would ask the informant — and say what the patient’s and informant’s accounts, read together, would let you conclude.

Functional Probes

What the antacid does for a burning pain. In a positive departure, H3 often asks what changes the symptom: does an antacid help the burning, does rest ease the pressure? In a negative departure, H3 becomes a functional probe: a small bedside test that shows at which level of a pathway (memory, hearing, the motor system) the function fails. Some probes restore function: if a cue or a louder voice brings back what was lost, the failure sits at that level. Others provoke the deficit: if a patient stands steady with the eyes open and sways once they close (Romberg), the failure sits in position sense. Either way the result points to a level, as “better with antacid” points to acid. Three worked examples follow.

Memory — a cue. If the patient cannot recall three words after five minutes, a cue (“one was a fruit”) tests whether the memory was stored (encoded) and then could not be found, or was never stored at all. Recall with a cue means the item was stored and the failure is in recall: typical of mood, a subcortical cause, or a medication. Failure to recall even with a cue means the item was never stored: typical of hippocampal failure and of Alzheimer’s dementia. Margaret failed both plain and cued recall, so her failure is in storing.

Hearing — a louder voice. If a patient reports difficulty hearing, a louder voice at close range tests whether the sound fails to reach the inner ear, or whether the inner ear or the nerve cannot handle it. Louder sound helps both kinds of loss; what separates them is whether speech becomes clear. If louder speech is clear again, the loss is likely conductive: something is in the way of the sound reaching the cochlea (wax, otitis media, otosclerosis). If speech grows louder and stays unclear, the loss is likely sensorineural: the cochlea or the auditory nerve is damaged, and volume alone does not make speech clear. Tuning-fork tests and the audiogram settle it.

Gait — specific manoeuvres. A gait complaint probed with specific manoeuvres localises the failure: Romberg separates proprioceptive from cerebellar causes, tandem walking brings out cerebellar and vestibular ones, and other manoeuvres test other levels of the motor system. Each manoeuvre is an H3 test: it brings out the deficit that one level would produce.

See MAAS-Prep 8.3 to practise functional probes: given a negative-departure complaint, name the probe that would restore the function, or bring out the deficit, at each level where the failure could lie, and interpret the result.

The Self-vs-Informant Gap Is Itself Diagnostic

Reading the gap. When the patient’s account and the informant’s account differ, the difference between them carries information. Four configurations recur. Each pairs who is worried (patient, informant, or both) with what the testing shows.

Loud complaint, preserved performance. The patient is worried; the informant sees little; the testing is normal. Insight is intact, and the complaint is loud. The differential shifts towards mood (depressive rumination), anxiety, functional cognitive disorder, or health anxiety. The complaint is real; the mechanism is something other than neurodegeneration.

Minimising patient, objective deficit. The informant is worried; the patient is not; the testing confirms the deficit. Insight is impaired. The mechanism is often neurodegenerative (Alzheimer’s, frontal disease), or intoxication, or a frontal lesion. Margaret is in this configuration.

Both worried, testing confirms. Patient and informant both report the change, and the testing confirms it. Insight is preserved. You can trust the reports and read back from them as they stand. The outlook is often better than in the second configuration. In mild cognitive impairment, a patient who has lost awareness of their own deficits is more likely to progress to Alzheimer’s disease (Tabert 2002; Gerretsen 2017), and awareness of memory loss usually fails only in the last two to three years before dementia (Wilson 2015).

Patient reports change, informant did not notice. Two possibilities. The change may be early or subjective — document a baseline for follow-up and reconsider in six months. Or the patient may be reporting heightened self-monitoring (anxious attention to their own memory, hypervigilance, reassurance-seeking) with no true deficit. The rest of the interview usually makes clear which it is.

The gap is an unusual kind of clinical finding: it reads both accounts together, as one measurement. It is one reason why a good history carries much of the diagnosis in this class. The investigations that follow mostly rule out causes that are reversible or structural.

See MAAS-Prep 8.4 to practise reading the gap: given the four configurations, work through a case that fits each — and describe how the diagnostic direction changes across them.

Anosognosia — The Self-Reinforcing Trap

When the damaged ability is the one that would notice. Some conditions damage the very ability that would notice the damage. Alzheimer’s dementia slowly erodes the patient’s awareness of their own memory. A right parietal stroke can leave a paralysed arm, or the loss of half the visual field, with the patient unaware of it. Frontal disease damages the ability to monitor one’s own actions, so that judgement about one’s own performance becomes unreliable. This is anosognosia: absence of insight into a deficit, caused by the deficit itself.

The clinical trap is this: we expect the patient to tell us what is wrong, and here the expectation fails without warning. Signs that point to anosognosia:

  • The informant is worried; the patient is calm about the same issue.
  • Objective testing shows performance far below the patient’s stated function.
  • The patient dismisses new safety concerns: falls, driving errors, mistakes with medication.
  • The patient may agree that others have noticed changes while not accepting the changes themselves (“my daughter says…”).

When anosognosia is suspected, the informant becomes the main source of the history, and the patient’s own report is one more piece of information, weighed for how reliable it is. The interview does not challenge the patient. It gathers the observations that let the diagnosis be made, and that let the family plan for a future the patient may not yet perceive.

Bridge to the Mental-Health Handbook

When insight itself becomes the object. Usually insight is a tool: you rely on it to interview the patient. Once insight itself is what you assess, the reasoning has crossed into the territory of the mental-health (MH) handbook: anosognosia in dementia, loss of insight in psychosis, denial in substance use, difficulty naming feelings (alexithymia) in mood disorders, the difficulty of self-report in personality disorders. The MH handbook treats each of these in its own right, with its own literature.

For this book the point is small. When the self-awareness that turns a signal into a complaint fails, the reading turns to the informant, and the diagnosis to a framework outside this book; that handover marks where the method ends.

See MAAS-Prep 8.5 to practise the bridge: given a case where insight itself is at stake, recognise the handover moment and name what the MH handbook’s framework adds to the body-based reasoning.

What You’ve Learned

A distinct class of complaints presents when the patient is not the one who has noticed: because the ability that would notice is itself failing, or because the change was gradual enough to adapt to. This is one of the sensation-first method’s edges: the body with the mechanism is not the one that reports it, and the informant becomes the one who notices. The interview’s four heuristics carry over directly to the informant’s observations. Functional probes take the place of symptomatic modifiers as the H3 confirming test. And the gap between the patient’s report and the informant’s report is itself diagnostic, in four recurring configurations. When anosognosia is likely, the usual expectation that the patient will tell you what is wrong fails without warning, and the interview is rebuilt around the informant. The chapter closes with the handover to the mental-health handbook, where insight itself is what you assess.

Reflections

Five open-ended scenarios for thinking, journaling, or peer discussion. No answer key: they are meant to connect what you have read with the patients you meet.

Reflection 1 — whose story counts? A 68-year-old man is brought in by his wife because she has noticed he is walking “funny.” He denies any change; his gait is subtly wide-based and slow. Think about: whose report do you weigh most heavily, and why? What is the first question you would ask him, and the first you would ask her?

Reflection 2 — functional-probe design. A 55-year-old woman reports difficulty hearing conversations at family dinners; her audiogram is pending. Think about: design a functional probe you could do at the bedside in ninety seconds to distinguish conductive from sensorineural loss, and say what each result would mean.

Reflection 3 — reading the gap. A 42-year-old man complains loudly of memory problems that his wife dismisses. On testing, he recalls three of three words at five minutes without cueing. Think about: which of the four configurations does this fit? What is the likely mechanism, and what should the next question address?

Reflection 4 — anosognosia in the making. Margaret returns for follow-up six months after her first visit. Her daughter reports that she has fallen twice, has stopped cooking, and no longer answers the phone accurately. Margaret still says she is fine. Think about: how has the anosognosia developed? What safety-planning conversation must now happen even without Margaret’s active participation? How do you honour her personhood while acting on what her daughter has observed?

Reflection 5 — the handover. A patient with a slowly progressive functional decline is being seen jointly by neurology and psychiatry. The neurology team frames the case as a cognitive syndrome; the psychiatry team frames it as a depressive one. Think about: where in the sensation-first method does each framing sit? What data would help you decide whether the handover to psychiatry is the right move, or whether the case is still on the somatic side?

From Here to Chapter 9

Chapter 9 turns to a different edge of the method: complaints where the sensation persists while the tissue is sound, because the reporting system itself has become oversensitive. The reading lands on a sensitised reporter. The read-back still runs there, from inside the same approach, after reading sensation back to tissue has reached its limit.

References

  1. Gerretsen P, Chung JK, Shah P, et al. Anosognosia is an independent predictor of conversion from mild cognitive impairment to Alzheimer’s disease and is associated with reduced brain metabolism. J Clin Psychiatry. 2017;78(9):e1187–e1196. — in mild cognitive impairment, poor awareness of one’s own deficits predicted Alzheimer’s disease independently of other factors, and went with reduced brain metabolism.
  2. Tabert MH, Albert SM, Borukhova-Milov L, et al. Functional deficits in patients with mild cognitive impairment: prediction of AD. Neurology. 2002;58(5):758–764. — in mild cognitive impairment, deficits noticed by the informant but not by the patient predicted conversion to Alzheimer’s disease.
  3. The MAAS Mental Health handbook (a separate book, in preparation) — insight and its loss (anosognosia, psychosis, denial, alexithymia) as subjects in their own right.
  4. Wilson RS, Boyle PA, Yu L, et al. Temporal course and pathologic basis of unawareness of memory loss in dementia. Neurology. 2015;85(11):984–991. — awareness of memory loss declined in the last two to three years before dementia, in step with the underlying pathology.

Chapter 9 · When the Reporter Is Sensitised

Learning objectives

  • Recognise a sensitised reporter: the point where a complaint no longer comes from a tissue, and the reading from sensation to tissue stops working
  • Read the positive signature of a sensitised reporter, so that the diagnosis rests on what is present
  • Hold central sensitisation as a mechanism in the reporting system itself: nociplastic pain, the third mechanism of pain
  • Find the predisposing, precipitating and perpetuating factors that sensitise the reporter
  • Keep to the same approach when the tissue reading no longer holds: recognise, reframe, redirect
  • Outline a first plan in the guideline shape: education, movement, psychological therapy, selective medication

Nadia Hassan, 39, has had pain for most of two years. It is in her neck, both shoulders, her low back, and lately her forearms; some days her skin hurts where her sleeve rests. It moves and it fluctuates — bad weeks and better ones, worse when she sleeps badly or when work is hard. She is tired in a way that sleep does not fix, and she loses words mid-sentence. Three clinicians have investigated her: bloods, inflammatory markers, an MRI of the spine, nerve conduction — all normal or trivially abnormal. She has tried an anti-inflammatory, then a stronger one, then amitriptyline, then a short course of tramadol; each helped a little, then less, then not at all. She says, carefully, that she can tell you think it is in her head. She is not sure any more that it is not.

Walk Nadia’s complaint the way the earlier chapters taught, and it will not go. The grammar will not cohere: the quality shifts, the location spreads without respecting a nerve or a territory, the timing fits no family’s tempo, the companions cross every system at once. H3 finds that load and the tissue treatments change it little, while sleep and stress change it a great deal. The treatments, each aimed at a plausible tissue mechanism, have failed in a particular way: a little, then nothing. Every investigation that would show a tissue at fault has come back clean. You have read the complaint back, and the read-back has found no cause in the body.

This is the edge of the method. Chapter 1 named the idea the whole book rests on: the sensation is the physiology itself, felt at the moment the body can no longer keep a process within its safe range. In its usual form it is a report from a tissue. For Nadia that usual form no longer holds: the physiology she feels is her reporter’s own. Her pain is real, and the reporter itself has changed. This book calls it the sensitised reporter: a nervous system that has itself become oversensitive, so that the sensation persists while the tissue is sound. Here the model that links a sensation to a tissue stops working. The wider approach still works: start with what the patient notices, and reason back to what produces it. What produces it need not be a tissue. The reading simply lands in a different place, on the reporter.

Chapter 6 flagged this case as the one that resists the read-back; Chapter 7 marked it again as the point where the second half of the read-back turns from the tissue to the reporter. This chapter takes the sensitised reporter up directly, because it is common. It runs through a large share of the fifty-five complaints (pain that spreads, fatigue, disturbed sleep, the gut that will not settle), and it is one of the commonest presentations in primary care.

When the Grammar Will Not Cohere

The signs that the reading has left the tissue. Most of the time, careful questioning and examination settle the picture. A handful of signs, taken together, say that they will not: the reporter has become sensitised. Chapter 6 named the first three signs; the clean investigations complete the set:

  • a grammar that will not cohere across its four dimensions: the quality changes, the location spreads without respecting a territory, and the timing has no tempo that fits a family;
  • companions that shift between visits, and that cross several systems at once;
  • a run of treatments, each reasonable, that have all been given and none has held;
  • investigations that come back normal, or trivially abnormal in ways that do not explain the pain.

No single sign decides it. Together, the signs tell you to stop forcing the tissue reading; they are not yet a diagnosis. The diagnosis rests on the positive signature of the next section, once treatable disease has been reasonably excluded. Make this move early. Pressing the same equation with more tests and more drugs does harm: it tells the patient that something is being missed, and too many tests and treatments help keep this kind of pain going (Section 4).

What must be excluded first. Reasonably excluded means a careful history and examination and a few simple blood tests: a full blood count, ESR, CRP, creatine kinase and thyroid function. They look for the conditions that can present as widespread pain: an underactive thyroid, an early inflammatory arthritis, polymyalgia rheumatica, a myopathy, and drugs such as statins (Fitzcharles 2013). Further tests follow only what the history and examination find. Here is the trap. A woman of seventy has ached across her shoulders and hips for six weeks and is stiff for an hour every morning: widespread pain, at first sight. Her ESR is raised, and a low dose of prednisolone settles it within days: polymyalgia rheumatica. Her age, the new onset, the morning stiffness of shoulders and hips and the raised ESR kept the tissue reading open.

See MAAS-Prep 9.1 to practise recognising the sensitised reporter: given a story that has been worked as a tissue complaint without resolving, name which of the four signs are present — and decide whether the reading should leave the tissue.

The Sensitised Signature

A positive pattern. When the reading leaves the tissue, it lands somewhere: a sensitised reporter has its own grammar, and reading it is the move the book has taught throughout, a signature pointing at a mechanism. The shape is recognisable. The pain is widespread or multifocal rather than confined to one territory, and often non-dermatomal. There is allodynia, where an ordinary touch is painful, and hyperalgesia, where a painful stimulus is felt as more painful than it should be. A companion cluster travels with it — unrefreshing sleep, fatigue, cognitive fog, low or anxious mood, and a heightened sensitivity to light, sound, and smell. It fluctuates, tracking stress and sleep more than any mechanical load. Read this way, the pattern is a positive diagnosis in its own right.

There are explicit ways to recognise this. The International Association for the Study of Pain (IASP) gave clinical criteria for nociplastic pain in the musculoskeletal system (Kosek 2021). They grade it as possible when the pain is chronic (more than three months) and regional or widespread, is not fully explained by tissue or nerve damage, and comes with hypersensitivity in the painful region on examination. A history of pain hypersensitivity, together with companions such as sensitivity to light and sound, poor sleep, fatigue and trouble thinking, raises the grade to probable. At the specialist end, quantitative sensory testing can show the two physiological fingerprints directly — heightened temporal summation (the signal builds abnormally on repetition) and impaired conditioned pain modulation (the body’s own “pain inhibits pain” damping has weakened).

The same signature recurs under several names. Fibromyalgia, irritable bowel syndrome, chronic fatigue, temporomandibular pain, chronic pelvic pain, and tension-type headache overlap far more than chance allows, and they have been grouped — under the proposed shared mechanism of central sensitisation — as the central sensitivity syndromes (Yunus 2008). Whether a single mechanism truly underlies them all is not settled, and this book does not claim to know. For the reasoning it is enough that they travel together and reward the same reading. Nadia’s picture — widespread fluctuating pain, allodynia over the shoulders, the fatigue-sleep-fog cluster — is this signature, read positively. In the review of systems (Appendix 3) such a patient turns up under several entries at once: General Pain, Fatigue & Malaise, Sleep Disturbance, Headache, Abdominal Pain, Pelvic Pain, and the back, neck and joint pains. The spread across entries is part of the signature.

See MAAS-Prep 9.2 to practise the signature: given a chronic widespread presentation, pick out the features that make it a positive sensitised signature, and name the companion cluster you would ask about.

The Mechanism — A Sensitised Reporter

Nociplastic pain. The mechanism has a name. Clinicians learn two mechanisms of pain: nociceptive, from a tissue being damaged, and neuropathic, from a nerve being damaged. In 2017 the IASP named a third — nociplastic pain: pain that arises from the nervous system’s own altered processing, with no clear evidence of tissue damage or of a nerve lesion to account for it (IASP terminology; Fitzcharles 2021). The IASP names it as a mechanism, and this book uses it that way: in the book’s terms, nociplastic pain is the mechanism in the reporter. It stands at the edge, beside the seventeen mechanisms of Chapter 5, which all act in a tissue; that is why the map in Appendix 4 has no row for it. The earlier chapters read a complaint back to a mechanism in a tissue; here the same reading lands on the reporting system itself, which now amplifies.

The amplification has a physiology, described as central sensitisation: the central nervous system becomes more responsive to input, so that normal or even sub-threshold signals are read as pain (Woolf 2011). It works along two lines. From below, the ascending pathway amplifies — the spinal dorsal horn winds up, and the temporal summation of a repeated signal grows abnormally. From above, the descending control that should damp pain weakens — the “pain inhibits pain” modulation fails, which is the impaired conditioned pain modulation that testing can show. Research adds to the picture. Brain imaging studies, mostly in fibromyalgia, show stronger coupling between the insula and the default-mode network, and PET imaging gives early evidence that glial cells are activated (Fitzcharles 2021). These are research findings; none is yet a test for the clinic.

Chapter 2 gave the ground for this. The quiet body works by prediction: a signal that matches what the brain expects does not reach awareness. Chapter 2 also noted that this filter can be set too sensitive. In a sensitised reporter it is: the brain gives the body’s signals too much weight, so that what should stay below the threshold of notice crosses it, again and again; and it can expect pain so strongly that the expectation is felt with little signal behind it (Van den Bergh 2017). Hold on to this, and give it to the patient: the change is real and physiological, in a real system. The pain is real, and the reporter is amplifying it.

See MAAS-Prep 9.3 to practise the mechanism: in plain words, explain to a patient what central sensitisation is and why the pain is real — using the idea of the amplifying reporter and the account of prediction from Chapter 2.

Why the Reporter Sensitises

Predisposing, precipitating, perpetuating. The causes fit a three-part frame clinicians use for any chronic condition. The seven aetiologies of Chapter 5 name the kind of cause; this frame names when each acts. Here the factors belong to the reporter. Some patients are predisposed. The risk factors include a family history of pain, genes that set pain sensitivity (variants in genes such as COMT and SCN9A), earlier chronic pain, female sex and long-term poor sleep. A childhood of adversity also raises the lifetime risk of these conditions, through the stress pathways Chapter 7 described. Something then precipitates the pain: an injury, an infection, an operation, a period of severe stress, after which the pain does not settle as it should. And a set of factors perpetuates it: poor sleep, inactivity, fear of movement, low or anxious mood, and catastrophising (expecting the worst from the pain). For the clinician one factor matters most: iatrogenesis, the cycle of more investigation and more treatment that teaches the patient their body is dangerous and keeps the reporter alarmed.

The frame matters because it tells you where a plan can reach. The predisposition is mostly fixed; the precipitant is usually past; the perpetuating factors are where treatment lives. For Nadia, the perpetuating factors are visible: her sleep is broken, she has stopped moving because movement hurts, two years of normal tests have left her frightened, and the escalating medications have taught her that nothing works.

See MAAS-Prep 9.4 to practise the aetiology: given a sensitised presentation, sort the factors into predisposing, precipitating, and perpetuating — and name which ones a plan can actually reach.

The Reasoning — Recognise, Reframe, Redirect

Staying inside the approach when the model has failed. The steps keep their shape, and they now point at the reporter. Each heuristic still runs, and each tells you that the reading has left the tissue. H1 finds a quality that will not settle and a location that spreads. H2 finds a long, fluctuating course with no tempo. H3 is telling: the pain tracks sleep and stress more than load, and the treatments aimed at tissue mechanisms have failed. That pattern of failure is a clue in itself, and it needs the other signs beside it. Where a treatment is a test of a mechanism (Chapter 7), a whole run of tissue-aimed treatments that all fail is a run of tests that all come back “no”, and together they point away from the tissue and towards the reporter. H4 adds the clearest positive clue: the cross-system companion cluster that a tissue complaint would not carry.

So the reasoning has three moves. Recognise the sensitised reporter, by the signs of Section 1. Reframe: name the mechanism as central sensitisation, a sensitised reporter, and say so to the patient in those terms. Redirect: stop hunting a peripheral tissue, and turn the plan towards the reporter and the person: the perpetuating factors, the sleep, the movement, the fear, the understanding. Redirecting keeps one eye on the tissue: nociplastic pain often sits alongside a nociceptive or neuropathic component, and an ongoing nociceptive source (an arthritic joint, a chronic inflammation) can be the very thing that triggered the sensitisation and keeps it fed. A treatable source of pain in the body is worth finding and treating, for its own sake and because calming it can lower the drive in the nervous system.

Walk it with Nadia. Recognise the sensitised reporter: two years of widespread, fluctuating pain with tender skin, a clean set of investigations, and a run of tissue-aimed treatments that each helped briefly and then failed; the grammar has left the tissue. Reframe: you tell her, in plain words, that the pain is real, and that what has changed is the reporting system itself, a nervous system that now amplifies; her joints and nerves are sound. Redirect: the plan turns towards the reporter and towards Nadia — her broken sleep, her stopped movement, her fear, and her understanding — while any treatable peripheral source that turns up is still addressed.

See MAAS-Prep 9.5 to practise the three moves: given a case with a sensitised reporter, walk recognise, reframe, redirect, and write the one sentence in which you would name the mechanism to the patient.

What the Clinician Can Offer

The evidence and the guidelines. The plan for a sensitised reporter is well charted, and it differs from what a tissue complaint would call for. Two guidelines agree on its shape. NICE (2021) covers all chronic primary pain; EULAR (2017) covers fibromyalgia. Both put education and non-drug measures first, and give medication a limited, selective role.

Explain the mechanism. The first intervention is the explanation itself: teaching the patient what central sensitisation is, that the pain is real, and that the reporter now amplifies. This teaching is called pain neuroscience education. Alone, it does little for the pain itself; alongside physiotherapy and exercise it eases pain and disability in the short term, and it lowers the fear of movement (Wood & Hendrick 2019; Watson 2019). Chapter 10 makes the point that the explanation is often what the patient came for; here it holds in its strongest form: for many of these patients, the explanation is what makes the rest of the plan possible.

Movement. Exercise is the most strongly supported measure: graded aerobic and strengthening activity, built up gently from wherever the patient can start. It is the only treatment EULAR rates as a strong recommendation (Macfarlane 2017), and NICE offers a supervised group exercise programme (NICE 2021).

Psychological therapy. Cognitive-behavioural therapy or acceptance and commitment therapy helps with the perpetuating factors: the fear of movement, the sleep, the mood, the catastrophising.

Medication, selectively. Where a drug is used, the evidence favours certain antidepressants, such as low-dose amitriptyline or duloxetine, with realistic expectations of a modest effect; EULAR rates them, and pregabalin, as weak recommendations (Macfarlane 2017). What NICE advises against is as important: it advises not to start paracetamol, non-steroidal anti-inflammatories, opioids or gabapentinoids for chronic primary pain, which includes fibromyalgia, because they carry little benefit and real harm (NICE 2021). The two guidelines differ on pregabalin, a gabapentinoid: EULAR allows it, and NICE advises against starting it.

Stop the chase. Part of the plan is to stop doing things. Repeating investigations that keep coming back normal, and escalating tissue-aimed treatments that keep failing, are themselves perpetuating factors. Naming the mechanism is what makes it safe to stop. Stopping is safe only when a treatable disease has been reasonably excluded and the picture is kept under review: a sensitised reporter can sit alongside a condition that does need investigating, or a new condition can appear later.

Nadia’s plan. It takes the guideline shape. It opens with the explanation: the reframe above, given as the treatment it is. It builds graded movement from whatever she can manage now, protects her sleep, and offers duloxetine (or a proper trial of low-dose amitriptyline, if the earlier one was too short or too high a dose) with modest expectations. It ends the escalating analgesics that have not held, and replaces the cycle of repeat investigation with a plan she can hold — while the serious causes stay excluded and under review. What is likely to change most for Nadia is the first move: being told, accurately and without blame, what has been happening to her.

See MAAS-Prep 9.6 to practise the plan: for a sensitised presentation, draft a first plan from the guideline shape (education, movement, psychological therapy, selective medication), and name the investigations and drugs you would deliberately stop.

Where This Chapter Stops

What this chapter does not cover. This chapter does not give the whole of the management, which is often multidisciplinary and long — pain services, physiotherapy, and, where mood, trauma, or the loss of a workable life are central, the mental-health handbook, which takes these up as subjects in their own right. A sensitised reporter and a low mood commonly travel together, each feeding the other, and the two books meet there.

Not the only mechanism at the edge. Central sensitisation is the best-characterised mechanism once the sensation no longer reports a tissue, and it is the one this chapter works. Other mechanisms reach the same edge. One is the functional disorders, in which the nervous system’s own processing is disturbed: functional neurological symptoms, functional dizziness, functional gut and chest complaints. Another is the brain’s reorganisation after a nerve or a limb is lost. A third is symptoms that have been learned and conditioned. The approach holds across all of them: read the complaint back to the reporter. The specific mechanism differs, and so does the handover; several of them belong to the mental-health handbook.

Two cautions close the chapter. The terminology is still settling. Nociplastic pain is a mechanism, and the field is still working out how it sits beside the older diagnostic labels; use it as this book uses every mechanism, as the thing the signature points at. And the discipline that matters most: the pain is real, and the mechanism is a real change in a real system. The reframe never says the pain is imagined or that the patient is at fault. It finally names, accurately, what has been happening.

What You’ve Learned

Some complaints no longer come from any tissue: the grammar will not cohere, the companions cross every system, the treatments all fail, and the investigations are clean. Here the model that links a sensation to a tissue reaches its edge, because the tissue reading no longer holds. The approach still holds: you read the complaint back to what produces it, and the reading lands on the reporter. A sensitised reporter has a positive signature (widespread fluctuating pain, allodynia and hyperalgesia, and a companion cluster of fatigue, poor sleep, fog and sensitivity to light, sound and smell), recognised by the IASP criteria. The mechanism is central sensitisation, the amplification the IASP calls nociplastic pain, with its own aetiology of predisposing, precipitating, and perpetuating factors. The reasoning is recognise, reframe, redirect; and what the clinician can offer — education, movement, psychological therapy, selective medication, and the deliberate stopping of the chase — is charted by the evidence and the guidelines. In the review of systems the signature shows as one patient under many entries.

Reflections

Five open-ended scenarios for thinking, journaling, or peer discussion. No answer key: they are meant to connect what you have read with the patients you meet.

Reflection 1 — the moment the reading leaves the tissue. Take a patient whose complaint you worked hard as a tissue problem without resolving it. Think about: which of the signs of a sensitised reporter were present, and in hindsight when did they first appear? What would have changed if you had recognised them earlier?

Reflection 2 — the failed treatment as a finding. A patient has tried, over a year, three different tissue-aimed treatments, each of which helped briefly and then not at all. Think about: what does that run of failures tell you, read as a run of H3 tests? When does “try the next agent” stop being reasoning?

Reflection 3 — naming it to the patient. Write, in your own words, the two or three sentences in which you would tell a patient that their pain comes from a sensitised reporter. Think about: how do you keep it honest, so that the patient does not feel dismissed? What would you not say?

Reflection 4 — the perpetuating factors you can reach. Choose a sensitised patient from your own practice. Think about: which perpetuating factors are present, which can a plan reach, and which of your own actions — investigations, prescriptions, referrals — might be perpetuating the pain?

Reflection 5 — where the two books meet. A patient has widespread sensitised pain and a deepening low mood, each clearly feeding the other. Think about: where does this book’s reasoning end and the mental-health handbook’s begin? What would you hold together rather than hand off?

From Here to Chapter 10

Chapter 10 closes the book. It takes the whole method to its natural end: the follow-up loop that tests whether the reasoning was right, the handover of the reasoning to the patient, and the link back to the interview handbook. For a patient with a sensitised reporter, the follow-up asks its own question: have the reframe and the redirected plan begun to quiet the reporter?

References

  1. Fitzcharles MA, Cohen SP, Clauw DJ, Littlejohn G, Usui C, Häuser W. Nociplastic pain: towards an understanding of prevalent pain conditions. Lancet. 2021;397(10289):2098–2110. — nociplastic pain, arising from altered nociception without clear tissue damage or nerve lesion, as a third mechanism beside nociceptive and neuropathic pain.
  2. Fitzcharles MA, Ste-Marie PA, Goldenberg DL, et al. 2012 Canadian Guidelines for the diagnosis and management of fibromyalgia syndrome: executive summary. Pain Res Manag. 2013;18(3):119–126. — fibromyalgia is a clinical diagnosis, made in primary care without tender-point counts or a battery of tests.
  3. Kosek E, Clauw D, Nijs J, et al. Chronic nociplastic pain affecting the musculoskeletal system: clinical criteria and grading system. Pain. 2021;162(11):2629–2634. — clinical criteria for grading nociplastic pain as possible or probable.
  4. Macfarlane GJ, Kronisch C, Dean LE, et al. EULAR revised recommendations for the management of fibromyalgia. Ann Rheum Dis. 2017;76(2):318–328. — non-drug treatment first; exercise was the only treatment with a strong recommendation.
  5. National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Chronic pain (primary and secondary) in over 16s: assessment of all chronic pain and management of chronic primary pain. NICE guideline NG193; 2021. — for chronic primary pain, recommends exercise, psychological therapy and some antidepressants, and advises against starting opioids, NSAIDs or paracetamol.
  6. Thapa R, Ang D. Nociplastic pain: a practical guide to chronic pain management in the primary care setting. Cleve Clin J Med. 2025;92(4):236–247. — a practical guide to recognising and managing nociplastic pain in primary care.
  7. The MAAS Mental Health handbook (a separate book, in preparation) — mood, trauma, and the loss of a workable life, as subjects in their own right.
  8. Van den Bergh O, Witthöft M, Petersen S, Brown RJ. Symptoms and the body: taking the inferential leap. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2017;74(Pt A):185–203. — a symptom is the brain’s inference from bodily signals and expectation, and can diverge from the state of the body.
  9. Watson JA, Ryan CG, Cooper L, et al. Pain neuroscience education for adults with chronic musculoskeletal pain: a mixed-methods systematic review and meta-analysis. J Pain. 2019;20(10):1140.e1–1140.e22. — pain neuroscience education gave a small but clinically relevant short-term reduction in pain and fear of movement.
  10. Wood L, Hendrick PA. A systematic review and meta-analysis of pain neuroscience education for chronic low back pain: short- and long-term outcomes of pain and disability. Eur J Pain. 2019;23(2):234–249. — pain neuroscience education combined with exercise reduced pain and disability in chronic low back pain in the short term.
  11. Woolf CJ. Central sensitization: implications for the diagnosis and treatment of pain. Pain. 2011;152(3 Suppl):S2–S15. — central sensitisation: amplified signalling in the central nervous system that makes ordinary input painful; for the sensitised reporter.
  12. Yunus MB. Central sensitivity syndromes: a new paradigm and group nosology for fibromyalgia and overlapping conditions, and the related issue of disease versus illness. Semin Arthritis Rheum. 2008;37(6):339–352. — fibromyalgia and overlapping conditions, such as irritable bowel syndrome and tension headache, grouped as central sensitivity syndromes with a shared mechanism.

Chapter 10 · The Loop Closes

Learning objectives

  • Use follow-up to test the diagnosis and close the read-back
  • Recognise the specific predictions a diagnosis carries — about relief and about complication
  • Explain how Presenting Solutions (The Medical Interview handbook, Scale 3) takes the patient through the mechanism, from what is wrong to what comes next
  • Describe the goal of practice: fast recognition that rests on the mechanism (illness scripts)
  • Explain which part of an encounter each book supplies

Sarah Nolan comes back to your practice, three weeks after the first visit. She sits down and says: “It worked. I took the tablets for two weeks like you said. The burning stopped almost completely. It came back a bit when I ate late on Friday and skipped the tablet, but it settles right down again when I take it.”

You read that as a clinical success. It is. It is also something more. Sarah’s report is the closing move of the reasoning you did three weeks ago. You reasoned from her burning to a mechanism — chemical irritation of the oesophageal mucosa by acid. The mechanism predicted a specific relief: cut the acid, and the sensation should stop. Sarah has now tested that prediction herself, and it held. That result tests your reasoning in a way the confidence you felt at the diagnosis could not, and its strongest part is that the burning came back when she skipped a dose. Chapter 7 called this the H3 test of treatment: the question that first confirmed the mechanism, what makes it better, now tests the treatment, and through it the reasoning.

Follow-up closes the read-back with a test in the patient’s own life: the loop that opened with Sarah’s first sentence is now complete. The last chapter is about that closing step: how to run it, why it matters, and how the two books of the MAAS Medical Interview together make one method for the medical encounter.

The Right Mechanism Predicts the Right Relief

Every diagnosis carries a prediction. A diagnosis is a hypothesis about which mechanism is at work. Every mechanism, if it is really at work, predicts specific things that will happen next: which intervention will help, what will follow if the intervention is withheld, how the disease will evolve over time. These predictions are what you can test, and follow-up is where the results come back.

The right mechanism predicts the right relief. The first test at follow-up is simple: does the treatment aimed at this process actually help?

MechanismWhat the right mechanism predicts
Chemical irritation of oesophageal mucosa (GORD)Antacid or acid-suppression relieves the burning
Coronary ischaemia (angina)Nitrate or rest relieves the pressure
Bronchial obstruction (asthma)Bronchodilator relieves the breathlessness
Bacterial infection (UTI)Targeted antibiotic relieves the dysuria within days
Inflammatory synovitisNSAID or specific immunosuppression eases the joint pain
Neuropathic painNSAIDs fail; a neuropathic agent (amitriptyline, gabapentin) helps some patients, often partly

What relief means. Relief comes in kinds, and the mechanism tells you which to expect. For the patient, relief is the sensation easing; for the body, it is the mechanism treated. Sometimes the two come together, and sometimes one comes without the other. Where the mechanism is reversible, as with acid meeting an unprotected lining, they coincide, and relief can be cure: suppress the acid and the sensation stops, as it did for Sarah. Where the mechanism is chronic or structural, the most you can offer is adjustment: the body and the patient compensate, and the symptom is held in check. Where the mechanism cannot be reversed, as in a battered heart already in failure, relief narrows to care: easing what remains, slowing what can be slowed. For a sensitised reporter the predicted relief is gradual: better sleep and function, fewer flares, fewer tests and visits; the follow-up looks for that, and a quick end to the pain would be a surprise. The follow-up test still holds, because the mechanism predicts the kind and degree of relief that is possible. It also asks for humility about what we can do for a patient: predict, and then measure, the relief the mechanism allows.

Two things follow from the table. When the predicted relief appears, in the kind and degree the mechanism allows, it supports the mechanism, and how strongly depends on how specific the treatment is. Relief on a targeted antibiotic says a good deal; relief on an acid-suppressant or a nitrate says less on its own, because pain from other causes often eases on them too (Numans 2004; Henrikson 2003). Chapter 7 gave the same rule for a treatment that fails. When the predicted relief does not come at all, either the mechanism was wrong or the treatment did not reach it. Had Sarah’s burning been cardiac ischaemia, the acid-suppressant would not have eased it. That failure would send you back to the point where H3 chose between mechanisms, to think again.

Relief needs reading with care, too. Many complaints settle on their own (natural history); some relief comes from being treated at all (the placebo response); and patients tend to come when a symptom is at its worst, so the next measure is often milder whatever was done (regression to the mean). The strongest checks are the ones only the right mechanism predicts: the symptom returning when the treatment stops, as Sarah’s did when she skipped a dose; relief that follows the dose and the time course of the drug; and relief from a treatment aimed narrowly at the mechanism. Read this way, the method corrects itself: a wrong diagnosis usually shows itself at the follow-up visit.

See MAAS-Prep 10.1 to practise the prediction: given a diagnosis, state precisely what relief you expect at follow-up — and describe what you would revise if the predicted relief did not appear.

The Right Mechanism Predicts the Right Complication

What happens if the mechanism is left to run. The second prediction a diagnosis carries is about what will happen if the mechanism is left unaddressed. Obstruction, unrelieved, predicts perforation. Inflammation, unresolved, predicts abscess. Ischaemia, unrelieved, predicts infarction. Untreated infection predicts sepsis. Autoimmune inflammation predicts tissue destruction. Each mechanism has its own natural history when it is not addressed.

This second prediction matters for two reasons. It drives the safety plan the patient leaves with: if X happens, come back. The X is the earliest complication the mechanism predicts: the signal that the disease has advanced. For Sarah’s GORD: if you vomit blood, call 999; if you have difficulty swallowing, or lose weight without trying, come back. For Anna’s stable angina: if the pressure comes at rest and lasts more than fifteen minutes, or does not ease with the nitrate spray, call 999; if the attacks come more often or with less effort, come back the same day. For Elena’s early lupus: if you have sudden chest pain or breathlessness, call 999; if you develop a new headache with visual change, or blood in the urine, come back the same day.

When the predicted complication appears, either the mechanism is right and the disease has advanced faster than expected, or the mechanism was wrong and a different one is now more likely. When it stays away, it tells you little, because it would also stay away if the mechanism had been misread. The relief remains the check.

See MAAS-Prep 10.2 to practise the complication prediction: given a diagnosis, name the earliest specific complication you would watch for — and write the safety-net advice you would give the patient at the end of the visit.

Presenting Solutions — Closing the Loop with the Patient

Scale 3 as applied physiology. The reasoning does not stay inside the clinician’s head; it has to be handed to the patient in a form they can hold and act on. The interview handbook’s Scale 3, Presenting Solutions, sets out that handover. Four of its items carry the explanation: Explains diagnosis (3.1), Explains causes (3.2), Explains prognosis (3.3) and Explains fit to problem (3.6). This book adds one thing under the causes: what the body has been doing to compensate.

Each of these items applies the reasoning about the mechanism. Once you have reached the mechanism, take the patient through it: name the sensation and link it to the mechanism, explain how the treatment acts on it, and say what will happen next.

For Sarah, presenting solutions might sound like this: “The burning behind your breastbone is acid from your stomach getting into the oesophagus. Your oesophagus does not have the protection your stomach has, so the acid irritates it — that is what the burning is. The tablet cuts the amount of acid your stomach makes, so once it works, the burning stops. If we control the acid, the burning stays away; if we do not, over months to years the oesophagus can become inflamed enough to bleed or to scar, which is why we keep it well treated. If you ever vomit blood, call 999; if swallowing gets difficult or you lose weight without trying, come back and see me.”

All of it is your reasoning about the mechanism, said out loud.

Notice what item 3.6 quietly assumes: that there is a treatment to connect to. Often there is none, and that takes nothing away from the explanation. Many of the patients who come to you want, above all, to be told what is going on. Sarah wanted to know whether the burning was her heart. The patient with a tension headache wants to hear that it is not a tumour. For these patients the explanation itself is the consultation: what is wrong, why it feels like this, what the body has been doing, and what comes next. Telling the patient plainly what the mechanism is and why it is not dangerous is the finished work, and only the mechanism can do it. A diagnosis gives the condition a name. The mechanism answers the question the patient actually asked: a heart muscle briefly needing more blood than it gets, or acid meeting a lining that has lost its defence. When patients in primary care are asked what they want from the consultation, nearly all want good communication, most want a partnership in the decisions, and only about a quarter want a prescription (Little et al. 2001).

One more Scale 3 item is worth naming here, because it works as a small follow-up inside the visit: Checks understanding (3.12), the teach-back. After the explanation, ask the patient to say back what they have understood, so you find out which parts came across. When the patient can explain the mechanism back correctly, your explanation has worked; when they cannot, explain again before you rest the plan on it. It matters because much of what is said in a consultation is soon forgotten, and a patient worn out by questions keeps even less (Chapter 6, Section 1): one more reason to keep the questions earlier in the visit few and aimed.

See MAAS-Prep 10.3 to practise presenting solutions: given a diagnosis you have reasoned to, walk through Scale 3 items 3.1, 3.2, 3.3 and 3.6 in your own words, and check whether each rests on the reasoning about the mechanism you have done.

See MAAS-Prep 10.4 to practise the explanation the patient came for: take a benign complaint — a burning behind the breastbone, a tension headache — and in three plain sentences say what the mechanism is, why it produces this exact feel, and why it is not dangerous. Then compare your explanation with the worked version.

The Target End-State

Where fast recognition is grounded. With practice, the read-back condenses. The expert who sees a patient with retrosternal burning after meals does not walk through Chapter 3’s four dimensions in real time; the whole pattern comes to mind at once. Chapter 6 named this stored picture the illness script (Schmidt 2007). It is the goal of clinical training. The book teaches the read-back step by step so that, when the stored picture forms, it rests on the mechanism. An illness script built on the mechanism can be taken apart when it fails; one built only on surface patterns leaves nothing to go back to.

So the equation matters even after you stop walking it consciously: it is the ground that intuition stands on. When Anna Petrov walks in with pressure on the chest on walking uphill, the experienced clinician recognises angina in a second — and the aim is that the equation stays at work under the recognition: pressure on exertion, eased by rest, points to ischaemia in the coronary territory. When the presentation is atypical (epigastric pressure that turns out to be cardiac, or chest pain that seems cardiac and turns out to be oesophageal), fast recognition fails, often without your noticing, because a wrong recognition feels as sure as a right one. The rule-out and the follow-up are what tell you to go back to the equation, step by step.

See MAAS-Prep 10.5 to reflect on the end-state: take a diagnosis you now recognise instantly, and ask whether you can still take it apart into grammar, mechanism, and region — and where fast recognition should give way to the read-back again.

Two Books, One Method

Where the two books meet. The book has referred to The Medical Interview handbook throughout.

Chapter 1 set out what the handbook teaches: how to hear the sensation.

Clinical Reasoning, this book, teaches what the sensation is, once it has been heard: how the body stays quiet, why a particular quality-word points at a particular mechanism, how the mechanism sits inside a family, how the equation runs from left to right, from mechanism to complaint, and how to read it from right to left, back to the diagnosis; what to do when the patient is not the one who notices and when the reporter is sensitised; and what to say to the patient when the reasoning is done.

Each book can be read on its own, and together they cover the whole encounter: the handbook teaches how to listen, this book what to listen for and what to tell the patient. Both rest on the same conviction: the medical encounter begins with what the patient has noticed, and the clinician’s work is to read that report accurately, back to the mechanism that generated it. The handbook applies this idea to the interview; this book applies it to the body. With both, you can read what the patient tells you as a report that a noticed body has just sent, through the person of the patient.

Sarah Nolan is the last patient in the book. She was the first patient in Chapter 1. When she sat down three weeks ago and told you about “this burning behind my breastbone. Mostly after supper”, you heard the complaint and read it back. When she sat down today and said “it worked”, the two books together let you close the loop and hand her back a treatment likely to keep working. That is the encounter this pair of books exists to enable.

What You’ve Learned

A diagnosis is a hypothesis about which mechanism is at work, and every hypothesis carries predictions: the right mechanism predicts the right relief and the right complication. Follow-up is where those predictions are tested and where the reasoning is either confirmed or sent back to the point where H3 chose between mechanisms. Presenting Solutions (the interview handbook, Scale 3) takes the patient through the mechanism: naming the sensation, tying it to the mechanism, connecting the treatment, predicting the outcome. With practice the read-back condenses into an illness script that comes to mind at once, and because the script rests on the mechanism, you can go back to the equation when recognition fails. The two books of the MAAS Medical Interview together make one integrated method for the medical encounter: the interview handbook to hear the sensation, this book to read it, and both to close the loop with the patient.

Reflections

Five open-ended scenarios for thinking, journaling, or peer discussion. No answer key: they are meant to connect what you have read with the patients you meet.

Reflection 1 — Nadia at three months. Nadia returns three months after the reframe. The pain is still there, a little less; she sleeps better, walks most days, and has not asked for a new scan. Think about: what relief did the mechanism in the reporter predict, and has it come? What would tell you the plan is working, and what would make you reopen the tissue reading?

Reflection 2 — the specific complication. Take a recent diagnosis you have made. Think about: name the specific earliest complication you would watch for if the mechanism is real and untreated. Have you shared that specific signal with the patient? If not, why not?

Reflection 3 — presenting solutions in the wild. Choose a diagnosis from your recent practice. Think about: write down, in the words the patient would likely use, how Scale 3 items 3.1, 3.2, 3.3 and 3.6 would apply. Which did you leave out? Was the mechanism actually explained, or only named?

Reflection 4 — encapsulation and its failures. Recall a case where your first-pass illness script was wrong. Think about: what made you stop and work through the equation? Was the switch easy or confusing? What does this tell you about what your quick recognition rests on: the mechanism, or surface features?

Reflection 5 — what you would keep, what you would leave. Of the four things this book has taught (the quiet body, the grammar, the mechanisms, the reasoning), think about: which one has changed most about how you approach a consultation? Which has proven least useful, and why? If you had one page to give a colleague, what would you write?

References

  1. Henrikson CA, Howell EE, Bush DE, et al. Chest pain relief by nitroglycerin does not predict active coronary artery disease. Ann Intern Med. 2003;139(12):979–986. — relief by nitroglycerin was as frequent in non-cardiac as in cardiac chest pain.
  2. Little P, Everitt H, Williamson I, et al. Preferences of patients for patient centred approach to consultation in primary care: observational study. BMJ. 2001;322(7284):468–472. — most patients in general practice wanted a patient-centred consultation: communication, partnership and health promotion.
  3. Numans ME, Lau J, de Wit NJ, Bonis PA. Short-term treatment with proton-pump inhibitors as a test for gastroesophageal reflux disease: a meta-analysis of diagnostic test characteristics. Ann Intern Med. 2004;140(7):518–527. — a short trial of a proton-pump inhibitor had a sensitivity of 78% and a specificity of 54% for reflux disease: a weak diagnostic test.
  4. Schmidt HG, Rikers RMJP. How expertise develops in medicine: knowledge encapsulation and illness script formation. Med Educ. 2007;41(12):1133–1139. — as expertise grows, biomedical knowledge becomes encapsulated in clinical concepts and illness scripts, and stays available when a case does not fit.

Afterword

A book that started with Sarah’s burning ends with Sarah’s relief. In between, the aim has been to show where the fifty-five complaints of the review of systems come from: each is what happens when the quiet body crosses a threshold and its report is read. Physiology and pathology are one object, read at two moments. The read-back is how you read it. The follow-up is the empirical check that the reading was right.

Small, in this book, has meant the small quiet signals the body sends when its defences are being outrun. It has also meant a book that stays close to what those signals require. Whether it has succeeded is for its readers — and for the physiologists and pathologists who will read it more carefully than we can — to say. Our aim has been to make the consultations you have with your patients a little clearer, and to let your patients share a little more in your reasoning.

Appendix 1: The History-Taking Items, by Heuristic

The history-taking items (Scale 2) of the MAAS-MI instrument, grouped by heuristic, each with the one question it asks, and the five Presenting Solutions items (Scale 3) that Chapter 10 uses, each with its example, so you can use the method with this book alone. The full items are in the companion handbook and at www.maas-mi.eu, with what to explore, what to avoid and how to score.

H1 — Complaint

2.1Asks about nature — “Can you describe what it feels like?”
2.2Asks about intensity — “How does it affect your daily life?”
2.3Asks about localisation — “Where exactly do you feel it?”
2.4Asks about radiation or shifts — “Does it spread or travel anywhere else?”

H2 — Time-Intensity

2.5Asks about history over time — “When did it start, and how has it changed since then?”
2.6Asks about course during the day — “Is it worse at particular times of day?”

H3 — Modifying Factors

2.7Asks what provoked — “What do you think might have set this off?”
2.8Asks what aggravates — “What makes it worse?”
2.9Asks what maintains — “What do you think is keeping this going?”
2.10Asks what relieves — “What helps, if anything?”

H4 — Context

2.11Asks about accompanying symptoms — “Have you noticed any other symptoms?”
2.12Asks about contextual factors — “Is there anything in your life situation that might be connected to this?”
2.13Asks about social determinants — “Is money tight right now?”

H5 — Psychosocial Impact

2.14Asks about psychological aspects — “How are you coping with this? Has it affected your mood or stress levels?”
2.15Asks about personal functioning — “How does this affect your daily activities — things like getting dressed, cooking, or getting around?”
2.16Asks about work/school functioning — “How does this affect your work or school?”
2.17Asks about social/leisure functioning — “Has this affected your social life or things you enjoy doing?”
2.18Asks about secondary gains — “Sometimes being ill changes things in life — some things get harder, but some things might get easier or different. Has anything like that happened for you?”

H6 — Staging

2.19Asks about past medical history — “What medical conditions do you have, or have you had in the past?”
2.20Asks about treatment history — “Have you been hospitalised or had any surgeries? What treatments have you tried for this problem?”
2.21Asks about current care providers — “Are you currently seeing any other doctors or specialists for this or other problems?”
2.22Asks about medications — “What medications do you take? Have any been started or changed recently? How do you actually take them?”

H7 — Risk and Vulnerability

2.23Asks about substance use — “Do you smoke or have you ever smoked? How much alcohol do you drink? Any recreational drug use?”
2.24Asks about biographical vulnerabilities — “Looking back over your life, have there been difficult periods or experiences that might still affect your health?”
2.25Asks about family history — “Are there any diseases that run in your family? Did any close relatives have serious illnesses?”

Review of Systems

2.26Conducts review of systems — “Let me ask about some other symptoms — any headaches, chest pain, shortness of breath, abdominal pain, or changes in your bowel or bladder?”

Scale 3 — Presenting Solutions (the items Chapter 10 uses)

3.1Explains diagnosis — “Based on what you’ve told me and what I found, this looks like a tension headache — that’s a common type of headache caused by muscle tightness.”
3.2Explains causes — “The headaches are likely from the tension in your neck and shoulder muscles. Sitting at a computer all day without breaks keeps those muscles tight.”
3.3Explains prognosis — “Without treatment, tension headaches often come and go for weeks. With regular stretching and posture changes, most people notice improvement within two to three weeks.”
3.6Explains fit to problem — “The stretching exercises target exactly those neck muscles that are causing your headaches. By loosening them, we address the source of the pain.”
3.12Checks understanding — “I want to make sure I explained this clearly. Can you tell me in your own words what you’re going to do?”

Appendix 2: The Reasoning Reference

This appendix sets the whole method out on a few pages: the heuristics, the four reasoning patterns, the safety rule-out, and the checks that keep the read-back sound. It is a reference, for use once the book has been read, when you want the method at a glance.

The method is one read-back in two halves. The patient gives you the grammar: its quality, its place, its timing, its companions. The first half reads that grammar back to the mechanism and the region that produced it, and the diagnosis follows (H1–H4). The second half goes on from the mechanism to its cause and to the plan the person needs (H5–H7). Follow-up closes the loop.

complaint → grammar → mechanism × region → diagnosis → cause → plan — closed by follow-up

The first half — reaching the mechanism (H1–H4 + Red Flags)

MoveQuestionWhat it draws out
H1 ComplaintWhat does it feel like, and where?Quality + Location: the signature; points to the likely family.
H2 Time-IntensityHow did it start, and how has it changed?Timing: how the defence failed (reserve exhausted, adaptation outpaced, regulator broken; Chapter 2), and often the mechanism within the family.
H3 Modifying FactorsWhat makes it better or worse?The confirming test: the specific mechanism, when the family allows more than one.
H4 ContextWhat else is present, and what were you doing?Companions: other mechanisms at work, reach into other families, and the context that set the threshold.
Red FlagsWhat would be catastrophic if missed?The dangerous mechanisms H1 did not pick up: the minimum the rule-out must cover.

These four primary heuristics read the complaint back to its mechanism. They are the first half of the read-back, the half this book is mostly about, and Chapters 3 and 6 set them out in full.

The second half — reaching the cause and the plan (H5–H7)

MoveQuestionWhat it draws out
H5 Psychosocial ImpactWhat is going on in your life, and why now?The burden and the stakes: what the mechanism costs this person; often a perpetuating cause, and the plan’s real target.
H6 StagingWhat have you had before, and what medicines are you on?The course and the context: other illnesses, how far the disease has reached, and the drug as a possible cause.
H7 Risk and VulnerabilityWhat runs in your family, and what do you use?The aetiology behind the mechanism: the predisposing and precipitating causes (the perpetuating cause usually comes under H5).

H1–H4 answer what is wrong; H5–H7 answer why it happened to this person and what to do about it. This is the second half of the read-back, from the mechanism on to its cause and the plan, and Chapter 7 runs it in full.

The four reasoning patterns

PatternWhen to use itHow it runs
Schema-based
(the systematic sweep)
The basic pattern: run the heuristics completely so nothing is missed; for complaints with a wide differential (abdominal pain, fatigue).
  • The full pass H1–H4 plus Red Flags;
  • for a complaint with no quality to name, enter at H4: companions first, then H2, then H3, with H1 as a check.
BranchingOne family, but sub-mechanisms compete; H1 splits into sub-qualities (dizziness).Take the branch H1 or H3 points to, and follow it to its end.
Rule-outA likely mechanism plus a cannot-miss alternative; high-stakes complaints (chest pain, headache).Exclude the dangerous one first; in parallel when the questions overlap, first when they are separate.
Pattern recognitionA classic picture recognised on sight; where practice leads.The whole picture is seen at once; it grows out of the other three with experience.

These four are the interview handbook’s reasoning patterns. This book uses the same four and adds the main principle that decides between them: how many mechanisms could produce the complaint. Two patterns have a variant. Rule-out runs in parallel when the questions overlap, and danger-first when they are separate. Schema-based starts at H4 when the complaint has no quality to name. The four patterns are the four shapes of the read-back. Fast recognition and slow hypothesis testing can occur within any of them (Chapter 6).

The safety-first catalogue

Some complaints can come from many organs, and for these a dangerous mechanism is always among the candidates, so the rule-out runs every time. The eight below are the rule-out complaints that matter most. In each, a common, harmless lead can hide a cannot-miss alternative. They are worked here to practise the pattern, and they are only part of it. Every one of the fifty-five complaints in the MAAS-MI Review of Systems carries its own red flags (marked † on the MAAS-MI website); that is the complete safety net. Appendix 3 names the cannot-miss alternative for each complaint. This table teaches the move.

ComplaintCommon leadCannot-missWhat tells them apart
Chest Painchest wall / GORD / stable anginaaortic dissection, PE, tamponade, MITearing-to-back, maximal at onset; risk factors + tempo.
Headachemigraine / tensionsubarachnoid haemorrhage, meningitis, raised ICPThunderclap onset; fever + neck stiffness; worse lying down.
Visionrefractive / benigncentral retinal artery occlusion (CRAO), giant-cell arteritis, retinal detachment, acute glaucomaPainless sudden loss; jaw claudication + ESR; halos + red eye.
Abdominal Paincolic / gastritisAAA, perforation, mesenteric ischaemia, ectopicTearing / rigidity / pain out of proportion to the findings; pregnancy test.
Back Painmechanicalcauda equina, malignancy, infection, AAASaddle anaesthesia / bladder; night pain + weight loss; pulsatile mass.
Dyspnoeainfection / COPDPE, ACS, pneumothoraxSudden onset; pleuritic + risk; absent breath sounds on one side.
Pelvic Paindysmenorrhoeaectopic pregnancy, ovarian torsion, PIDPregnancy test first; sudden severe unilateral.
Joint Pain (hot)flare / mechanicalseptic arthritisSingle hot joint + fever → aspirate.

When the grammar does not resolve

The scheme is clean by design, and its cleanness is a hazard. A signature that points cleanly at one mechanism invites premature closure: settling before the alternatives are excluded. Seventeen tidy mechanisms can also make you expect textbook cases, and real patients often differ. Three checks keep the read-back sound (Chapter 6).

A mechanism found still has to be confirmed. A plausible mechanism explains the grammar, and others may explain it equally well. The explanation is a hypothesis, and a hypothesis is tested: by H3, by the rule-out, by the investigation. Where the grammar allows more than one reading, keep the readings side by side until one is separated out.

The grammar can under-report. Presentations are atypical more often than a scheme suggests: the silent infarct, the afebrile infection, the patient who minimises. A weak or missing signature can still hide a mechanism. Give the small signs more weight, and keep the cannot-miss alternative among the candidates until it is actively excluded.

Uncertainty is a finding in its own right. When the grammar will not resolve, name the uncertainty, cover the dangerous branch, and let time decide; follow-up is there for that.

The two edges

Two situations sit at the method’s edge, where the plain read-back does not apply. Each has its own chapter; the reference names them so neither is forgotten at the desk.

The patient is not the one who noticed. When the change was gradual, or the ability that would notice is itself failing, someone else notices first. Hear the informant as a main source, test function with a probe, and read the gap between the two accounts (Chapter 8).

The reporter is sensitised. A vivid, spreading, shifting signature that fits no tissue points to a sensitised reporter: a nervous system that has itself become oversensitive, so that the sensation persists while the tissue is sound (nociplastic pain, central sensitisation). The tissue reading gives no answer here; the approach still holds, and the reading moves to the reporter: recognise the sensitised reporter, reframe the complaint for the patient, and redirect the plan towards the reporter and the person (Chapter 9).

Follow-up checks the prediction

The right mechanism predicts the right relief and the right complication. When the predicted relief does not come at all, the mechanism was probably wrong: go back to H3 and test the next candidate. The read-back is complete when the outcome confirms or revises the mechanism (Chapter 10).

Appendix 3: The Review of Systems, Complaint by Complaint

This appendix turns the book’s central claim into a reference: every complaint is a mechanism met in a region. Each of the fifty-five review-of-systems complaints is set out through the equation. A row gives the grammar the patient reports, the mechanism it points to and its family, the region-type, the reasoning pattern the interview should take, and the cannot-miss alternative the rule-out must catch. The fifty-five rows come from a small number of mechanisms met in a small number of regions, so the rows can be rebuilt from a few principles. Read a row across, and you are reading the equation for that complaint.

How to read a row. Grammar: what the patient reports. Mechanism · family: the mechanism the grammar points to, and its family (I–V, Chapter 5); Edge is the mechanical edge, the seventeenth mechanism (Chapter 5 §7); OFF is off-map, the mental-health handbook’s territory, and OFF+ an off-map complaint with a bodily branch to rule out. Region: the region-type (Chapter 4); a signalling faculty is a nervous or sensory system whose task is to report. Pattern: the reasoning pattern, coded as in the key below. Cannot-miss: the dangerous alternative the rule-out must exclude.

* Pattern codes. Dir direct read (a short schema-based sweep) · Mech direct read of a mechanical complaint (the mechanical edge) · Br branching · RO rule-out, danger first · ROp rule-out, in parallel · H4 schema-based, entered at H4 · Sch schema-based, full sweep · ND negative departure (a lost function) · OFF off-map (the mental-health handbook). Dir, Mech, H4 and Sch are forms of the Schema-based pattern (Appendix 2), and ROp is a form of Rule-out. Pattern recognition grows out of the other three with experience, so it has no code. ND and OFF fall outside the four patterns: ND marks a complaint read as a lost function, OFF a complaint that belongs to the mental-health handbook. An arrow (→) marks a progression, a slash (/) an either/or. Families I–V and the mechanical edge as in Chapter 5.

1 · Universal conditions

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
Fever & ChillsSystemic, no local signature.infection / inflammation · IsystemicH4sepsis, meningitis
Fatigue & MalaiseSystemic, gradual.anaemia / endocrine / malignancy / mood · I, II, VsystemicH4malignancy, cardiac failure
Weight LossSystemic, over weeks.malignancy / endocrine / malabsorption · I, VsystemicH4malignancy
General PainStarting point only.redirects to a specific pain complaint——see the specific complaint
Nausea & VomitingBranches on vomitus + tempo.obstruction / central / metabolic · IV, Vhollow lumen / systemicBrobstruction, raised ICP
Night SweatsSystemic, nocturnal.infection / lymphoma / endocrine · I, VsystemicH4TB, lymphoma
Loss of AppetiteSystemic.several causes (as fatigue) · I, II, VsystemicH4malignancy
Sleep DisturbanceSystemic / behavioural.mood / several causes · close to OFFsystemicH4depression, apnoea

2 · Cardiovascular

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
Chest PainPressure / tearing / sharp-pleuritic.chest wall / ischaemia / dissection / inflammation · Edge, II, III, Ivascular territoryROpdissection, PE, tamponade, MI
PalpitationsAwareness of heartbeat.arrhythmia / autonomic · Vsignalling facultyBrarrhythmia with syncope
OedemaSwelling, gravity-dependent, over days.oedema, Starling imbalance · IIIenclosed / systemicDir→H3DVT (unilateral), heart/renal failure

3 · Respiratory

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
Dyspnoea & SOBBreathless, on demand.hypoxia / perfusion / obstruction · II, IVsystemic / vascularROpPE, ACS, pneumothorax
CoughBranches on duration + sputum.infection / inflammation / irritation · Ihollow lumenBrmalignancy, TB
HaemoptysisBlood in sputum.inflammation / leak · I, IIIhollow lumenROmalignancy, PE, TB

4 · Gastrointestinal

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
Abdominal PainGripping or cramping (in waves in the gut, steady in the gallbladder) / burning / pressure / rigid.obstruction / irritation / ischaemia · IV, I, IIhollow lumen / capsuleROpAAA, perforation, ischaemia, ectopic
DiarrhoeaBranches (infective / inflammatory / osmotic).infection / inflammation · Ihollow lumenBrbloody (IBD/ischaemic), dehydration
ConstipationReduced/absent passage.obstruction / dysmotility · IV, Vhollow lumenBrobstructing malignancy
Rectal BleedingBranches on colour + mix.inflammation / leak / neoplastic · I, IIIhollow lumenBrcolorectal malignancy

5 · Genitourinary

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
Urinary Frequency & UrgencyIrritative / obstructive pattern.infection / obstruction · I, IVhollow lumenBrretention, pyelonephritis
Blood in UrineBranches; painful vs painless.infection / stone / neoplastic / glomerular · I, IV, IIIhollow lumenBrpainless visible haematuria: malignancy until excluded
DysuriaBurning on micturition.infection / irritation · Ihollow lumenDirpyelonephritis, STI
IncontinenceLost control (negative departure).neurogenic / sphincter · V, Edgesignalling facultyNDcauda equina (+ back pain)

6 · Neurological

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
HeadachePressure / thunderclap / band.vascular leak / ischaemia / raised-pressure / inflammation · III, II, IV, Ienclosed compartment / vascularROpSAH, meningitis, raised ICP, GCA
Dizziness & VertigoBranches: spinning / light / unsteady.vestibular / perfusion / cerebellar · V, IIsignalling facultyBrcentral (posterior stroke)
Numbness & TinglingPositive + negative forms.neurogenic · Vsignalling facultyBr/NDcord compression, stroke
WeaknessLost power (negative departure).neurogenic · Vsignalling facultyNDstroke, cord, cauda equina
SeizuresParoxysmal, stereotyped.neurogenic · Vsignalling facultyROfirst seizure (structural/metabolic), status

7 · Musculoskeletal

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
Back PainReproducible on movement, no halo.structural · Edgeenclosed / surfaceMechcauda equina, malignancy, infection, AAA
Knee PainMechanical, load-related.structural · EdgesurfaceMechseptic joint
Shoulder PainMechanical, movement-related.structural · EdgesurfaceMechreferred cardiac / diaphragmatic
Neck PainMechanical, movement-related.structural · EdgesurfaceMechmyelopathy, meningitis
Joint PainCross-cutting: inflammatory vs mechanical.inflammation / infection / immune vs structural · I, EdgesurfaceBr→ROseptic arthritis

8 · Mental health

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
DepressionOff-map core, with a bodily branch.rule out a medical cause of the fatigue, sleep and appetite change · OFF+— / systemicOFForganic cause, suicide risk
AnxietyOff-map core, with a bodily branch.rule out a medical cause of the autonomic symptoms (Family V) · OFF+— / signallingOFFarrhythmia, thyroid, phaeo
Suicidal IdeationOff-map.mental-health handbook · OFF—OFFimmediate safety
Substance UseBehaviour; withdrawal is autonomic.OFF; withdrawal · V—OFFwithdrawal (DTs), overdose
MemoryLost function (negative departure).storage vs recall · Vsignalling facultyNDrapid/focal (structural), delirium
PsychosisOff-map.mental-health handbook · OFF—OFForganic psychosis, delirium

9 · Integumentary (skin, hair, nails)

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
RashSeen + often felt (positive departure).inflammation / infection / immune · IsurfaceBrpurpura (meningococcal), SJS/TEN
ItchingItch; local vs systemic.inflammation / cholestatic · I, Vsurface / systemicBrsystemic (cholestasis, lymphoma)
LesionsSeen, evolving.inflammation / neoplastic · IsurfaceDirmelanoma / malignancy features

10 · Ear, nose & throat (and eye)

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
VisionCross-cutting + negative departure.vascular / raised-pressure / neuro / inflammation / mechanical (detachment) · II, IV, V, I, Edgesignalling facultyROp/NDCRAO, GCA, retinal detachment, acute glaucoma
HearingLost function; conductive vs sensorineural.transmission vs processing · Edge, Vsignalling facultyNDsudden sensorineural loss
Sore ThroatLocal, worse on swallowing.infection / inflammation · Isurface / lumenDirepiglottitis, quinsy
Ear PainPressure / fullness / sharp.infection / raised-pressure · I, IVenclosed compartmentDirmastoiditis

11 · Endocrine

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
Thirst & UrinationSystemic, no local signature.endocrine / metabolic (diabetes) · VsystemicH4/SchDKA / HHS
Temperature IntoleranceSystemic.endocrine (thyroid) · VsystemicH4thyroid storm / myxoedema
Hair LossLocal vs diffuse.endocrine / inflammation · V, Isurface / systemicBrsystemic cause

12 · Haematological

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
Bruising & BleedingOut of proportion to trauma.haemostatic disturbance · IIIsurface / systemicBrleukaemia, DIC, non-accidental injury
Lymph NodesSwelling, tender vs hard-fixed.infection / neoplastic · IsurfaceBrlymphoma (hard, fixed, systemic)

13 · Reproductive

ComplaintGrammarMechanism · familyRegionPattern*Cannot-miss
MenstruationBranches by cause (PALM-COEIN, the classification of abnormal uterine bleeding).structural / inflammation / haemostatic / endocrine · Edge, I, III, Vhollow lumenBrectopic, malignancy
DischargeLocal, character-specific.infection · Ihollow lumenDirSTI, malignancy
Erectile DysfunctionLost function (negative departure).vascular / neuro / endocrine · II, Vvascular territoryNDearly sign of cardiovascular disease
BreastLump / change / pain.inflammation / neoplastic · IsurfaceBrmalignancy (lump, skin/nipple change)
Pelvic PainCross-cutting; colic / pressure / sharp.obstruction / inflammation / leak · IV, I, II, IIIhollow lumen / capsuleROpectopic, ovarian torsion, PID

Note. This appendix is a teaching aid, and it does not list every possible diagnosis. Each row states the commonest reading and its cannot-miss alternative; real complaints can carry more than one mechanism, and the rule-out sweep runs regardless of the leading pattern. The full mechanism–aetiology detail is in Appendix 4; the reasoning patterns in Appendix 2.

The sensitised reporter. Many of the complaints above, pain, fatigue, disturbed sleep and the bowel among them, have a chronic form in which the reporter itself has become sensitised: the complaint stays vivid while the tissue is sound. Read acute, each complaint sits in its family as shown. Read chronic and non-resolving, it may be the sensitised reporter of Chapter 9, where the tissue reading gives no answer and the reading moves from the region to the reporter. This case runs across the whole table, so it has no row of its own.

Appendix 4: The Mechanism–Aetiology Map

The mechanism a complaint points at sits inside a family, and beneath the mechanism is its cause. This appendix brings the three together in one place: the seventeen mechanisms; the five families, which group sixteen of them by a shared physiological logic, with the mechanical edge for the seventeenth; and the seven aetiologies, adapted from general pathology, that drive them.

complaint → mechanism → family → aetiology

The five families + the edge (seventeen mechanisms)

FamilyMechanismsSignature grammarInterview moveUsual mode of failure (Chapter 2)
I Tissue Injury & Responseinflammation · infection · immune hypersensitivity · chemical / mucosal irritation · neoplasticTenderness; sharp or burning; stable / crescendo tempo; systemic halo if extensive.“Is there tenderness, and does anything systemic go with it?”Reserve exhausted, then adaptation outpaced.
II Perfusion & Oxygenationischaemia · hypoxia · hypoperfusionPressure / heavy / tight / breathless / lightheaded; on demand, eased by rest.“What were you doing when it happened, and did stopping help?”Adaptation outpaced when the block is fast (infarction); reserve exhausted when it is slow (Frank’s valve).
III Vessel & Fluid Balancevascular leak / rupture · oedema (Starling) · haemostatic disturbanceTearing / thunderclap (leak); gravity-dependent swelling (oedema); easy bruising / bleeding (haemostasis).“Did it come on instantly, gradually, or out of proportion to a knock?”Adaptation outpaced (leak); regulator broken (haemostasis).
IV Luminal & Pressure Dynamicsobstruction · raised compartment pressureGripping or cramping, restless (in waves in the gut, steady in the gallbladder), relief once the contents pass; pressure worse on bending / Valsalva.“Does it come and go in a rhythm, and does anything relieve it?”Reserve exhausted; rupture is the complication (Chapter 10).
V Signal & Regulationneurogenic · autonomic dysregulation · endocrine / metabolicLoss of function, in a pattern that follows the anatomy or affects the whole body.“Where exactly — is there a pattern?” or “Energy, temperature, weight?”Regulator broken: the control system itself fails.
Edge Mechanicalstructural / mechanical fault (the seventeenth)Reproducible on movement or palpation; no systemic halo.“Does moving or pressing it reproduce it?”No process disturbed: the fault lies in the anatomy.

Family V is where the negative-departure complaints live most naturally. When a control system breaks, the lost ability is often the very one the patient would need to notice the loss, so the informant becomes a main source of the history (Chapter 8).

The seven aetiologies (the causes)

The categories of general pathology this book uses: the cause behind each mechanism, adapted from the classical list (cf. Robbins).

  1. Congenital / genetic — the body is built wrong from the start.
  2. Physical / mechanical — trauma, radiation, temperature.
  3. Chemical / toxic — harmful substances, including drugs.
  4. Nutritional — deficiency or excess.
  5. Infectious — a pathogen has invaded.
  6. Immunological — hypersensitivity or autoimmunity.
  7. Neoplastic / degenerative — uncontrolled growth or accumulated wear.

The map — seventeen mechanisms, seven aetiologies

One mechanism can have several causes, and one cause can drive several mechanisms. Even so, most mechanisms have only a few typical causes. The table is a teaching aid; the full detail is in the general-pathology texts (cf. Robbins).

FamilyMechanismTypical aetiologies
IInflammationinfectious · physical · chemical · immunological
Infectioninfectious
Immune hypersensitivityimmunological
Chemical / mucosal irritationchemical
Neoplasticcongenital / genetic · chemical · physical · infectious
IIIschaemiadegenerative (atherosclerosis) · nutritional (diet, lipids) · physical (compression, trauma) · immunological (vasculitis)
Hypoxiachemical (CO) · nutritional (anaemia) · physical / environmental · infectious · degenerative
Hypoperfusionphysical (haemorrhage) · degenerative (cardiogenic) · infectious (septic)
IIIVascular leak / rupturedegenerative · physical · congenital
Oedema (Starling)degenerative · nutritional · immunological · chemical (drugs)
Haemostatic disturbancecongenital · chemical (drugs) · immunological · neoplastic
IVObstructionphysical / mechanical · neoplastic · congenital · nutritional (cholesterol stones)
Raised compartment pressurephysical · neoplastic · congenital
VNeurogenicdegenerative · physical · immunological · congenital · chemical (alcohol, chemotherapy) · nutritional (B12)
Autonomic dysregulationdegenerative · chemical
Endocrine / metaboliccongenital · immunological · neoplastic · nutritional · chemical (drugs)
EdgeMechanical / structuralcongenital · physical · degenerative

Reading the map. A diagnosis is what emerges when a specific aetiology drives a specific mechanism in a specific region — a degenerative aetiology driving ischaemia (Family II) in coronary territory yields angina. The map lets a clinician answer both what is happening (mechanism) and why (aetiology).

What the map does not hold. One case has no row here: the sensitised reporter. The sensation persists while the tissue is sound, so there is no disturbed tissue to find. The mechanism lies in the reporting system itself: central sensitisation (Chapter 9).

Appendix 5: A Note for Teachers

Practising the Read-Back

This book sets out the content of clinical reasoning: how a mechanism met in a region produces a complaint, and how the read-back runs from the complaint back to the mechanism, and on to the diagnosis. Knowing the content does not yet make a student able to use it. Students learn the read-back by doing it, many times, with feedback; reading about it once is too little. This note is for teachers who want to build that practice around the book.

Everything here serves one aim, and it is worth naming, because practice is not always planned around it. The aim is a clinician who hears a real patient’s complaint, reads it back to the mechanism and acts on it, fluently, and also when the case will not resolve. The formats below are ways of reaching that aim. The note is deliberately short. The teaching and assessment of the interview itself are the subject of the companion handbook (its Chapter 9). A full reasoning curriculum is set out in a separate programme, MAAS Learn to Reason, named at the end.

The arc of the training

Reasoning is trained along a rising ladder of realism: on paper, then from audio and transcripts, then with simulated patients, and finally with real ones in the clinic. Each rung is closer to the live encounter. The last rung is real clinical work, and that is where the skill is finally made. Two structured formats do most of the deliberate work before the clinic, and they do different jobs.

Prep (MAAS-Prep) trains one step at a time (part-task practice), and it travels with the books. Its short exercises sit beside paragraphs of the handbooks; in each, the student practises a single reasoning step and compares the answer with an expert’s model answer. The Preps for reasoning are short, about five per chapter, and each belongs to one stage of the read-back. Practice (MAAS Practice) is a full consultation with a simulated patient (whole-task practice). The student chooses the steps and their order as the consultation goes on, and the case is debriefed afterwards. Prep trains each step until the student can use it. Practice puts the steps together in a realistic, uncertain case, and adds what only a full consultation has: the interview itself, setting priorities as you go, and staying with a case that does not resolve. Put simply: Prep follows the book; Practice follows a curriculum.

The division of labour

IssuePrep (part-task drill)Practice (whole-task simulation)
Hypothesis generationDrilled in isolation, from the grammar.Required live, under time pressure.
Choosing what to ask nextA “which question next?” drill.Tested in the flow of the consultation.
Information gathering (the interview)The human exchange cannot be drilled alone.Owned here — asking, following, reading the patient.
Self-explanation of mechanismFree text, compared with an exemplar.Becomes “presenting the solution” to the patient.
Rule-out / cannot-missTrains the habit of ruling out danger on complaints that can come from many systems.The cannot-miss hides inside a benign-looking case.
Premature closure / uncertaintySupported by error-analysis and rule-out drills.Owned here — real-time ambiguity, the patient who will not resolve.
Learning from errorsErrors replayed as targeted drills.Errors surface naturally, then are debriefed.
Repetition and realismSimple and repeatable, with feedback at once.Fewer and more lifelike, with a structured debrief.

A useful shorthand: Prep is the scales, Practice is the performance. Both use the same four reasoning patterns (Appendix 2). Prep drills each pattern on its own; Practice presents cases that demand a pattern live; the debrief names which pattern was needed, and where it broke. Appendix 2 is the reference for both, and the material for both comes from the fifty-five complaints of Appendix 3.

Using the book in a module

Read at study pace, a chapter takes 25 to 50 minutes, and with its Preps and a Reflection three to four hours. The core for any module is Chapters 1, 3, 4 and 6, and Chapter 10 §1–3. Chapters 2, 5 and 7 build the depth, and Chapters 8 and 9 take the two edges. Chapters 4 and 5 carry the most new ideas and Chapter 6 is the longest, so give them extra time. A longitudinal module of about twelve sessions covers the whole book.

Some Reflections ask for a patient of your own. A student can take a patient seen on a rotation or a Practice case, and a first-year student a case from the Review of Systems. The Reflections carry no answer key, so in a course they work best in a small group with a tutor, who gives the feedback the page cannot.

Learning by doing, and the debrief

Reasoning is learned first in the doing. The thinking, the formulating and the choosing of the next question are themselves the practice, in Prep as much as in Practice: the student reasons while working the exercise. The structured debrief after a simulation takes this work further. The student goes through the reasoning again, more clearly and on firmer ground, and names each step. A simulated patient without a debrief teaches little, and may teach the wrong thing. Four questions, drawn from what expert teachers do at the bedside, work well as a checklist for the debrief:

  1. Did the student organise and prioritise the information, and ask the question that discriminates?
  2. Did they connect the findings to the underlying mechanism, and explain the feel as well as name the disease?
  3. Did they think aloud — make the reasoning visible so it can be examined?
  4. Did they keep the cannot-miss in view until it was actively excluded, or did they close early?

One caution the book itself creates

A clean scheme — seventeen mechanisms, one signature each — is easy to learn and easy to over-trust. Simulation makes this worse. If simulated patients always end in a tidy answer, students expect real patients to do the same; they then close too early and hold rigidly to the textbook when a case is atypical. The remedy lies in the case mix. Practice cases must deliberately include the atypical, the ambiguous, and the case with no clear diagnosis, so that students first meet uncertainty in rehearsal. This is the Practice counterpart of the discipline in Appendix 2, When the grammar does not resolve: a mechanism you have read back still needs confirming, the grammar can show less than is there, and uncertainty is itself a finding.

Simple before ambiguous — the spiral, and where it starts

Match the practice to the student’s stage, and consider starting it early. Because the core step needs little clinical experience, the method can start in the first year. It gives students a small, stable scheme (an advance organiser) on which the physiology and clinical facts from other courses can be hung, recognised and kept. The fifty-five complaints of the Review of Systems are natural material to interview and reason with. Research supports this early start (Kulasegaram et al. 2013; Woods 2007): a scheme learned early helps later content fit together and come back to mind, and novices who understand the mechanism keep a stable picture of the disease and stay accurate in diagnosis over time. In these early years both formats work best on simple, typical cases with one mechanism; the aim is the scheme and the core thinking skills, and diagnostic accuracy comes later. In the first years the student reads only the core of the book: Chapter 1, Chapter 2 §1–3, Chapter 3 §1–5 and §7, and Chapter 4 §1–3, with the first-half table of Appendix 2 (H1–H4). The rest of the book, and the Reflections that ask for a patient of one’s own, belong to the clinical years. As knowledge and clinical exposure grow, make the cases more lifelike and harder: Practice moves to atypical cases, cases with several mechanisms, and cannot-miss cases, and the Preps follow the later stages of the read-back. The reasoning is revisited at rising complexity across the whole programme.

A caveat. The direct evidence for teaching reasoning this early is still thin: the review cited below found pooled gains in the clinical years but not the pre-clinical ones. That review is sympathetic to an early foundation. It had few studies of the early years to weigh, three in the first year and none of them a trial, and these were short, one-off courses; the curriculum proposed here runs through all the years of training, alongside the medical subjects. The case for an early start therefore rests for now on the cognitive argument above, until a curriculum of this kind is tested.

The case ladder

Cases ordered from easy to hard. Each rung is practised to fluency before the next, and earlier rungs keep coming back; an example complaint is given for each:

  1. One mechanism, clean — grammar → mechanism → confirming probe; the basic read-back (dysuria, cellulitis).
  2. + Context — the same single mechanism, now with H4 (context) and the threshold at which the complaint is noticed (exertional chest pain).
  3. More mechanisms at one address, no danger yet — separate the candidates by H2 / H3 / H4 (diarrhoea, sore throat).
  4. Danger — the rule-out: first when the dangerous features are separate, in parallel when they overlap (chest pain, headache).
  5. Branching — H1 splits into sub-qualities; follow the chosen branch to its end (dizziness, cough).
  6. The sweep entered at H4 — complaints felt in the whole body, with no quality to name (fatigue, fever, weight loss).
  7. The second half of the read-back — cause and plan (H5–H7): relief versus cure, the drug-as-cause, the plan built from the person (oedema, polypharmacy).
  8. Longitudinal — follow-up as the H3 test; the failed treatment as an H3 “no”; reasoning across visits (the cough that will not settle, reviewed).
  9. The informant / negative departure — functional probes, the self-versus-informant gap (weakness, memory problems; Chapter 8).
  10. The sensitised reporter, and the case that does not resolve — recognising when the reading leaves the tissue, reading the complaint back to the reporter (recognise, reframe, redirect), and leaning on the process skills of the interview, Scales 4, 5 and 6 (chronic widespread pain; Chapter 9). Over-weighted on purpose: the book is cleanest on the cases that need least help, so the practice must dwell on the ones that need most.

Conditions for fluency

The goal is reasoning from the head, improvised fluently and grounded in mechanism, like a musician improvising over a bass line known by heart (the old practice of partimento). Six conditions develop it:

  1. A small core, learned until it runs by itself: the equation, H1–H4, the Top-7 (Chapter 1) and the families. This frees attention for the patient.
  2. Graded, spaced, deliberate practice up the case ladder above.
  3. Retrieval over re-reading — practice that makes the student produce the read-back from memory.
  4. Improvisation on a fixed scaffold — the scaffold stays the same, and the way the student fills it in may vary; reward flexible use, and discourage recital by rote.
  5. Experts show their reasoning and give feedback along the way — clinicians thinking aloud, worked read-backs, and correction of the student’s own attempts.
  6. Early and continuous doing, with escalating realism — from year one on the clean complaints, climbing paper → audio → simulated patient → real patient.

How this fits a curriculum

The book supplies the why and the what; the curriculum is a separate programme. An example curriculum, MAAS Learn to Reason, brings the parts together: this book, the Prep drills, the Practice simulations, the fifty-five complaints of the Review of Systems as a case library, and both interview handbooks (general and mental health) for the how of asking. Any curriculum can use the book as it is, and this note shows how.

On timing and formats: Wark S, Drovandi A, McGee RG, Alele FO, Mwangi F, Malau-Aduli B, for the ACHIEVE network. How and when should clinical reasoning be taught in undergraduate medicine: a systematic review and meta-analyses. Perspect Med Educ. 2025;14(1):1021–1042. doi:10.5334/pme.1986 — of fifty studies, 46 (92%) reported a measurable improvement from explicit teaching of clinical reasoning; small-group activities, skills-based workshops and serious games fared best; the pooled benefit was significant in the clinical years but not the pre-clinical ones, where early activities may lay a foundation. On early entry: Kulasegaram KM, Martimianakis MA, Mylopoulos M, Whitehead CR, Woods NN. Cognition before curriculum: rethinking the integration of basic science and clinical learning. Acad Med. 2013;88(10):1578–1585; and Woods NN. Science is fundamental: the role of biomedical knowledge in clinical reasoning. Med Educ. 2007;41(12):1173–1177. The teaching and assessment of the interview itself are in the companion interview handbook (Chapter 9).

Appendix 6: A Small Glossary

The book reasons with a small, fixed vocabulary. Each term is defined once here, so that it means the same thing in every chapter.

The words

Aetiology — The cause beneath a mechanism. The book uses seven, adapted from the classical categories of general pathology: (1) congenital or genetic, (2) physical, (3) chemical, (4) nutritional, (5) infectious, (6) immunological, (7) neoplastic or degenerative (Chapter 5; Appendix 4).

Compensation gap — The stretch of time in which the body compensates for a disease so well that the patient feels fine, while the effort of compensating can already be seen on examination: signs come before symptoms (Chapter 2).

Complaint — A sensation, or a lost function, that has crossed the threshold of notice and been given meaning.

Encapsulation — With experience, many steps of reasoning merge into one stored picture of a disease, so that the read-back becomes a single look; Schmidt calls this knowledge encapsulation (Chapter 6 §6; Chapter 10).

Exception classes — The six recurring classes in which the equation needs an extra step: cross-cutting, branching, systemic-companion, negative-departure, mixed, and the mechanical edge. Beyond them lie the off-map complaints of the mental-health handbook and, at the far edge, the sensitised reporter (Chapter 4 §5; the pattern codes of Appendix 3).

Family — A group of mechanisms that share one physiological logic: a common tissue, response or control system. There are five, holding sixteen of the seventeen mechanisms; the mechanical edge holds the seventeenth. Each family has a signature grammar, and often a usual mode of failure (Chapters 2 and 5; Appendix 4).

Feel — The complaint as the patient lives it, before it is read as a grammar or traced back as a signature. The first of the three names a complaint has in this book (Chapter 1 §6).

Functional probe — A test that restores a lost function at one level only, used in place of the symptom modifier (H3) when the complaint is a loss: does a cue bring back the memory, does speech become clear once it is loud enough (Chapters 3 and 8).

Grammar — How the feel of a complaint is reported, along four dimensions: quality (what kind of trouble), location (where it is felt), timing (how fast it moves), companions (what travels with it). Mechanism and region produce it together; it is what you can observe, and it adds no third factor. It is called a grammar because a few values combine in many ways. The interview handbook’s H1 asks for the same feel as the complaint’s nature, intensity, localisation and radiation.

Heuristics, H1–H7 — The interview’s questions, from the companion handbook. H1 Complaint, H2 Time-Intensity, H3 Modifying Factors and H4 Context read the complaint back to its mechanism (Chapters 3 and 6); H5 Psychosocial Impact, H6 Staging and H7 Risk and Vulnerability carry it on to the cause and the plan (Chapter 7). The items behind them are in Appendix 1.

Illness script — The stored picture of a disease that lets an expert recognise it at once; see Encapsulation (Chapters 6 and 10).

Informant — Someone other than the patient who noticed the change, heard as a main source of the history when the patient is not the one who noticed (Chapter 8).

Mechanism — The specific way a process becomes disturbed: ischaemia, obstruction, dysregulated inflammation, rupture. What a complaint’s feel points at. Seventeen in all: sixteen grouped under the five families, and the seventeenth, mechanical, a fault in the anatomy itself. Beside the seventeen, at the edge, lies the mechanism in the reporter: nociplastic pain (Chapter 9). With the region, one of the two factors that produce the feel.

Mechanical edge — The seventeenth mechanism, the only structural one: the anatomy itself is at fault (a joint surface, a lens, a sphincter), and no physiological process is disturbed. It stands outside the five families (Chapters 4 and 5).

Modes of failure — The three ways compensation fails and illness arrives: reserve exhausted (the spare capacity is used up), adaptation outpaced (the disturbance comes too fast for the body to adapt), regulator broken (the control system itself is damaged). A family often has a usual mode, where one dominates (Appendix 4).

Nociplastic pain — Pain that arises from the nervous system’s own altered processing, with no clear evidence of tissue damage or of a nerve lesion to account for it (IASP, 2017). In the book’s terms it is the mechanism in the reporter, and its process is central sensitisation; it stands beside the seventeen mechanisms, outside the five families (Chapter 9).

Noticed body — The body once a disturbance has crossed the threshold of notice; the review of systems is its vocabulary (Chapter 1).

Positive and negative departure — The two ways a complaint leaves the quiet body. Positive: the body produces a new signal (burning, pressure, itch) that crosses into notice. Negative: the body loses a function (hearing, memory, gait), and someone notices that something is missing, often a person close to the patient before the patient. One grammar reads both, with three swaps: the pattern of the deficit for the quality-word, a functional probe for the symptom modifier, the informant for the patient (Chapter 3).

Process — An ongoing physiological activity (perfusion, inflammation, transport, secretion, regulation). In health it runs without being noticed; in disease it is disturbed. It is the same activity at two moments. The five families group the mechanisms that disturb these processes.

Quiet body — The regulated body below the threshold of notice, kept quiet by six achievements: negative feedback, reserve, redundancy, adaptation, anticipation and perceptual filtering (Chapters 1 and 2).

Read-back — The path reasoning takes from the complaint back to mechanism and region (Chapter 6), and on to cause and plan (Chapter 7).

Reasoning patterns — The four shapes the read-back takes, shared with the interview handbook. Schema-based: the systematic sweep, the basic pattern for a complaint with a wide differential; for a complaint with no quality to name, it is entered at H4. Branching: H1 splits the complaint into sub-qualities; take the branch H1 or H3 points to, and follow it to its end. Rule-out: exclude the dangerous alternative first; in parallel when the questions overlap, first when they are separate. Pattern recognition: the whole picture seen at once, which grows out of the other three with experience. Which pattern a complaint calls for depends on how many mechanisms could produce it, on danger, and on experience (Chapter 6).

Red Flags — The cannot-miss mechanisms a complaint could hide — the catastrophic alternatives the rule-out sweep must exclude every time, whatever the leading explanation (Chapter 6; Appendix 2).

Region — The tissue and place where the mechanism acts; the book’s image for it is the address. Six region-types, defined by nerve supply and anatomy: surface or lined, hollow-organ lumen, capsule or stretch, vascular territory, enclosed compartment, and signalling faculty (a nerve pathway, sense organ, cognitive system or endocrine axis); beside them sits the systemic edge. With the mechanism, the other factor that produces the feel. Region is kept apart from location, which is where the patient feels the complaint, one dimension of the grammar (Chapters 1 and 4).

Reporter, sensitised reporter — The reporter is the nerve that carries the signal: somatic afferents in the skin, muscles and joint linings, visceral afferents in the organs; injury and reporter together give a sensation its character (Chapter 3). The sensitised reporter is a nervous system that has itself become oversensitive, so that the sensation persists while the tissue is sound; its mechanism is central sensitisation, the IASP’s nociplastic pain (Chapter 9).

Reserve — The spare capacity a process holds in health: the margin the body draws on to keep a disturbance quiet. When the reserve is used up, the process can no longer stay quiet, and a sensation is noticed (Chapter 2).

Safety-net — What keeps the cannot-miss covered alongside the leading explanation: a test (Sarah’s ECG), and the advice the patient leaves with, naming the earliest complication the mechanism predicts. The book’s rule: 999 for a possible catastrophe, the same day for an urgent but stable change (Chapter 10 §2).

Scales, MAAS-MI — The six scales of the MAAS-MI interview instrument, on which the companion handbook is built. Three content scales follow the consultation: Scale 1 Exploring Reasons for Encounter (why the patient has come), Scale 2 History-taking (the heuristics H1–H7; Appendix 1) and Scale 3 Presenting Solutions (explaining and planning with the patient; Chapter 10). Three process scales run through the whole consultation: Scale 4 Structuring, Scale 5 Interpersonal Skills and Scale 6 Communication Skills. This book uses Scales 2 and 3 directly and names the process scales where the interview’s craft takes over.

Signature — The particular pattern the grammar takes for one complaint: its values in quality, location, timing and companions. It is the mark the mechanism leaves in a region; reading it back leads to the mechanism and the region (Chapter 1).

Systemic edge — The region edge beside the six region-types: the complaint has no local region (fever, malaise, weight change, fatigue); the address is the whole body, and reasoning runs through the companions (Chapter 4).

Threshold — The level a signal must cross to reach notice. Three things set it: the size of the signal, the patient’s own disposition, and context (Chapters 1 and 2).

Top-7 — The seven quality-words that usually point at a single mechanism strongly enough that one follow-up question confirms it (Chapter 1). The easiest way into the method.

Working rule — The rule Chapter 1 draws from the Top-7: the feature the patient reports carries the mechanism, and the follow-up question is the test that confirms it (Chapters 1 and 3).

The chain

Complaint, mechanism, family, aetiology: four links in one chain, each reached by asking about the link before it (Chapter 5).

A complaint points at a mechanism · A mechanism is a disturbance of a process · Mechanisms group into families · An aetiology drives the disturbance

The equation

Two factors produce a complaint’s feel, the mechanism and the region, and the patient reports it as the grammar:

mechanism × region = complaint

Read the × as met in: a mechanism met in a region. The grammar is what you observe; it shows the mechanism (the disturbance) and the region (the address). The read-back runs the equation from right to left: from the grammar back to the mechanism and the region, and from there to the diagnosis.

The slogan

Feel, mechanism, region; and when several complaints come together, look for the mechanism they share.

First, read each complaint back to the mechanism and the region behind its feel. Then, when a patient brings several complaints, look for the one mechanism they share, as Elena’s complaints share one in Chapter 5.

Appendix 7: Further Reading

Each chapter ends with its own references. This appendix gathers the works for reading further: first the books drawn on across the whole book, then the standard reference texts, then studies grouped by theme. The groups follow the order of the book, from the body’s signals to the consultation, so you can read further from wherever you are. Within each group the works stand in alphabetical order; Start here marks the best first read. Where the text mentions one of the main works in passing (“Robbins notes…”, “cf. Costanzo”), this is where it points.

The books referred to throughout

Costanzo LS. Physiology. 7th ed. Philadelphia: Elsevier; 2022. — the physiology throughout: the body’s constant background signals, reserve and the six achievements that keep the body quiet (Chapter 2), the kinds of sensory nerve and pain fibre, the tissue physiology of the region-types and the five families.

Crijnen AAM, Kraan HF. The Medical Interview: A Handbook for Primary Care and Hospital Care. MAAS-MI series (forthcoming). — the interview tools this book works with: the heuristics H1–H7, the four reasoning patterns, the process skills (Scales 4, 5 and 6), and Presenting Solutions (Scale 3).

Kumar V, Abbas AK, Aster JC, Deyrup AT, Das A. Robbins & Kumar Basic Pathology. 11th ed. Philadelphia: Elsevier; 2022. — the pathology throughout: pathology as disturbed physiology, the compensation gap and the three modes of failure (Chapter 2), the chemical mediators behind the words patients use for the feel of a complaint, the seven aetiologies, the clinical course of infarction.

Foundations: further reference texts

Bickley LS, Szilagyi PG, Hoffman RM, Soriano RP. Bates’ Guide to Physical Examination and History Taking. 13th ed. Philadelphia: Wolters Kluwer; 2021. — the standard guide to history taking and examination, with the attributes of a symptom set out one by one. Start here.

McMahon SB, Koltzenburg M, Tracey I, Turk DC, editors. Wall and Melzack’s Textbook of Pain. 6th ed. Philadelphia: Elsevier Saunders; 2013. Chapters on visceral pain and referred pain — the standard reference work on pain; Chapter 3 draws on its segmental convergence account.

Signalling, allostasis, and pain · Chapters 1–3

Barrett LF, Simmons WK. Interoceptive predictions in the brain. Nat Rev Neurosci. 2015;16(7):419–429. — the brain predicts the body’s own signals; what matches the prediction stays below awareness.

Cervero F, Laird JMA. Visceral pain. Lancet. 1999;353(9170):2145–2148. — the classical account of visceral afferent convergence and referred pain.

Leder D. The Absent Body. Chicago: University of Chicago Press; 1990. — the body unnoticed in health, obtruding (“dys-appearing”) in illness.

Leder D. The experiential paradoxes of pain. J Med Philos. 2016;41(5):444–460. — a physician-philosopher on his own persistent pain: how a diagnosis changes what is felt, and why pain is hard to place, rate and live with.

McEwen BS, Wingfield JC. The concept of allostasis in biology and biomedicine. Horm Behav. 2003;43(1):2–15. — allostasis, stability through change, and allostatic load, the wear that repeated or prolonged adaptation leaves behind. Start here.

Sterling P. Allostasis: a model of predictive regulation. Physiol Behav. 2012;106(1):5–15. — regulation is predictive: the brain anticipates the body’s needs and adjusts before they arise.

Van den Bergh O, Witthöft M, Petersen S, Brown RJ. Symptoms and the body: taking the inferential leap. Neurosci Biobehav Rev. 2017;74(Pt A):185–203. — a symptom is the brain’s inference from bodily signals and expectation, and can diverge from the state of the body.

Clinical reasoning and the growth of expertise · Chapters 4–6

Bowen JL. Educational strategies to promote clinical diagnostic reasoning. N Engl J Med. 2006;355(21):2217–2225. — problem representation, semantic qualifiers and illness scripts as teachable steps of diagnostic reasoning.

Croskerry P. The importance of cognitive errors in diagnosis and strategies to minimize them. Acad Med. 2003;78(8):775–780. — the common cognitive errors in diagnosis, among them anchoring and premature closure, and strategies to reduce them.

Kahneman D. Thinking, Fast and Slow. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux; 2011. — for the dual-process account of fast and slow reasoning.

Kulasegaram KM, Martimianakis MA, Mylopoulos M, Whitehead CR, Woods NN. Cognition before curriculum: rethinking the integration of basic science and clinical learning. Acad Med. 2013;88(10):1578–1585. — integration of basic science and clinical knowledge happens in the learner’s mind, and teaching helps it most by making the causal links explicit.

Schmidt HG, Rikers RMJP. How expertise develops in medicine: knowledge encapsulation and illness script formation. Med Educ. 2007;41(12):1133–1139. — as expertise grows, biomedical knowledge becomes encapsulated in clinical concepts and illness scripts, and stays available when a case does not fit. Start here.

Wark S, Drovandi A, McGee RG, Alele FO, Mwangi F, Malau-Aduli B, for the ACHIEVE network. How and when should clinical reasoning be taught in undergraduate medicine: a systematic review and meta-analyses. Perspect Med Educ. 2025;14(1):1021–1042. — explicit teaching of clinical reasoning works; active, feedback-driven teaching works best; few studies looked at the first year.

Woods NN. Science is fundamental: the role of biomedical knowledge in clinical reasoning. Med Educ. 2007;41(12):1173–1177. — students who learned the causal basic science behind a disease remembered its features better and diagnosed more accurately after a delay.

Cause and the life course: adverse childhood experiences · Chapter 7

Anda RF, Felitti VJ, Bremner JD, et al. The enduring effects of abuse and related adverse experiences in childhood. Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci. 2006;256(3):174–186. — the number of adverse childhood experiences showed a graded relation to a wide range of later health outcomes, read alongside the neurobiology of early stress.

Felitti VJ, Anda RF, Nordenberg D, et al. Relationship of childhood abuse and household dysfunction to many of the leading causes of death in adults: the Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACE) Study. Am J Prev Med. 1998;14(4):245–258. — four or more adverse childhood experiences raised the risk of several leading causes of adult death, ischaemic heart disease among them. Start here.

Cardiovascular risk and prevention · Chapter 7

Cholesterol Treatment Trialists’ (CTT) Collaboration. Efficacy and safety of more intensive lowering of LDL cholesterol: a meta-analysis of data from 170,000 participants in 26 randomised trials. Lancet. 2010;376(9753):1670–1681. — each 1 mmol/L lower LDL cholesterol cut major vascular events by about a fifth; more intensive lowering cut them further.

Estruch R, Ros E, Salas-Salvadó J, et al. Primary prevention of cardiovascular disease with a Mediterranean diet supplemented with extra-virgin olive oil or nuts. N Engl J Med. 2018;378(25):e34. — republished 2018 after the 2013 PREDIMED article (N Engl J Med. 2013;368:1279–90) was retracted for a randomisation irregularity; the primary-prevention effect held.

Lear SA, Hu W, Rangarajan S, et al. The effect of physical activity on mortality and cardiovascular disease in 130,000 people from 17 high-, middle-, and low-income countries (the PURE study). Lancet. 2017;390(10113):2643–2654. — more physical activity, walking and housework included, went with lower mortality and fewer cardiovascular events in rich and poor countries alike.

Yusuf S, Hawken S, Ôunpuu S, et al. Effect of potentially modifiable risk factors associated with myocardial infarction in 52 countries (the INTERHEART study). Lancet. 2004;364(9438):937–952. — nine modifiable risk factors accounted for about 90% of the risk of a first myocardial infarction, in every region studied. Start here.

Cognition, dementia, and awareness of illness · Chapter 8

Isaacs B, Kennie AT. The Set Test as an aid to the detection of dementia in old people. Br J Psychiatry. 1973;123(575):467–470. — a quick bedside test: the patient names items in four categories, and a low score points to dementia.

McKhann GM, Knopman DS, Chertkow H, et al. The diagnosis of dementia due to Alzheimer’s disease: recommendations from the NIA–Alzheimer’s Association workgroups. Alzheimers Dement. 2011;7(3):263–269. — the clinical criteria for dementia and for dementia due to Alzheimer’s disease. Start here.

Prigatano GP, editor. The Study of Anosognosia. New York: Oxford University Press; 2010. — anosognosia: why a patient with a brain disorder may not know what is failing.

Persistent symptoms and nociplastic pain · Chapter 9

Albrecht DS, Forsberg A, Sandström A, et al. Brain glial activation in fibromyalgia: a multi-site positron emission tomography investigation. Brain Behav Immun. 2019;75:72–83. — brain imaging showed glial activation in fibromyalgia.

Fitzcharles MA, Cohen SP, Clauw DJ, Littlejohn G, Usui C, Häuser W. Nociplastic pain: towards an understanding of prevalent pain conditions. Lancet. 2021;397(10289):2098–2110. — nociplastic pain, arising from altered nociception without clear tissue damage or nerve lesion, as a third mechanism beside nociceptive and neuropathic pain.

Löwe B, Toussaint A, Rosmalen JGM, et al. Persistent physical symptoms: definition, genesis, and management. Lancet. 2024;403(10444):2649–2662. — what persistent physical symptoms are, how bodily and psychological processes combine to keep them going, and stepped care.

Napadow V, LaCount L, Park K, et al. Intrinsic brain connectivity in fibromyalgia is associated with chronic pain intensity. Arthritis Rheum. 2010;62(8):2545–2555. — in fibromyalgia, the brain’s resting connectivity with the insula tracked the intensity of the pain.

Toussaint A, Weigel A, Löwe B; EURONET-SOMA group. The overlooked burden of persistent physical symptoms: a call for action in European healthcare. Lancet Reg Health Eur. 2025;48:101140. — how common and costly persistent physical symptoms are in Europe, and what better care would need.

Woolf CJ. Central sensitization: implications for the diagnosis and treatment of pain. Pain. 2011;152(3 Suppl):S2–S15. — central sensitisation: amplified signalling in the central nervous system that makes ordinary input painful; for the sensitised reporter. Start here.

The consultation: decisions, recall, and what patients want · Chapter 10

Bomhof-Roordink H, Gärtner FR, Stiggelbout AM, Pieterse AH. Key components of shared decision making models: a systematic review. BMJ Open. 2019;9(12):e031763. — the components that models of shared decision making have in common, from describing the options to making the decision together. Start here.

Jones D, Dunn L, Watt I, Macleod U. Safety netting for primary care: evidence from a literature review. Br J Gen Pract. 2019;69(678):e70–e79. — what safety netting consists of, and how thin the evidence behind it still is.

Little P, Everitt H, Williamson I, et al. Preferences of patients for patient centred approach to consultation in primary care: observational study. BMJ. 2001;322(7284):468–472. — most patients in general practice wanted a patient-centred consultation: communication, partnership and health promotion.

Watson PWB, McKinstry B. A systematic review of interventions to improve recall of medical advice in healthcare consultations. J R Soc Med. 2009;102(6):235–243. — what helps patients remember advice, among them written and recorded information.

Appendix 8: CanMEDS Competency Coverage

This book describes a method that a physician uses at every consultation and learns across the whole of medical school. The method belongs in a competency-based curriculum because it is a clinical practice, and this appendix reads it through the CanMEDS roles. The method works in three moves:

It tells you what to ask → You listen to the answer → You read it back to the mechanism

Its first move is a question and its last is an interpretation. So the method sits across two CanMEDS roles at once and joins them. Asking and listening belong to the Communicator. The Medical Expert’s reasoning decides what to ask, and then interprets the answer. This join, the reasoning that chooses the question and reads the answer, is the reason the method exists. Curricula that teach only communication, or only reasoning, tend to leave it to chance.

The mapping

CanMEDS roleCoverageWhat the method does
Medical ExpertPrimary · coreChooses the question and reads the answer. The reasoning directs what to ask, complaint by complaint (the heuristics H1–H7), then reads the reply back to mechanism and region, and on to cause and plan: the read-back (Ch4–7; App2–4).
CommunicatorPrimary · integratedThe first move is a question, the second is listening: the method tells the physician what to ask about this complaint, and what to listen for in the answer. Asking and listening supply the material the reasoning reads, and they are assessed together with the reasoning, as one act. The full craft of asking well is the companion handbook’s subject. Here the method is shown reading the account of an informant (Ch8), giving a new explanation to a patient with a sensitised reporter (Ch9), and handing the mechanism back to the patient (Ch7, Ch10).
ScholarSubstantiveHow the method is learned to fluency: knowledge encapsulation and illness scripts (Ch6, Ch10), deliberate practice, the case ladder and the conditions for fluency (App5); the method as a shared teaching vocabulary across the years; based on evidence throughout, with references in each chapter and App7.
Health AdvocateSubstantiveHanding the mechanism back to the patient, by explaining what is going on, helps the patient take part in their care, supports adherence, and makes prevention understandable: advocacy within the consultation (Ch7, Ch10). The second half of the read-back also reaches the social causes and life-course risk behind the complaint: H5 Psychosocial Impact, H7 Risk and Vulnerability, and the link with adverse childhood experiences (Ch7).
ProfessionalPartialThe habits that keep the reasoning sound: treating uncertainty as a finding, guarding against premature closure, and modesty about what symptom relief can achieve (Ch7, Ch10).
Collaborator
and Leader
Out of scopeRoles that reach beyond the single consultation. The method works within the consultation and leaves these roles to their own training.

Medical Expert and Communicator are two faces of one act: the question the reasoning asks, and the reasoning’s reading of the answer. The method is built so that the two are learned and assessed together: the reasoning directs the asking, and the listening feeds the reasoning. Coverage levels. Primary: the role is the method’s own core. Substantive: the method contributes a large part. Partial: the method touches the role without aiming at it. Out of scope: the role reaches beyond the single consultation.

On assessment, and placing it in the years

Because the method is used at every consultation, it can enter the curriculum early and run through it. Students practise the cycle of asking and reading, first on clean complaints, then on harder ones as their knowledge grows. What can be assessed is the cycle itself: did the physician ask the discriminating question, listen to the answer, and read it back to a mechanism? Three of the method’s own tools carry that assessment: thinking aloud, teach-back (explaining a mechanism in plain words), and the four-question debrief of Appendix 5. The asking is scored with the MAAS-MI history-taking items (Appendix 1); a scored rubric for the reading back belongs to the curriculum. Reading this book gives understanding. The skill itself shows only in practice: in simulation with a debrief, and finally with real patients.

What the method does not cover

The full craft of communication (asking well, the relationship, the difficult conversation) is the companion interview handbook’s subject. The team and system roles (Collaborator, Leader), and the parts of the other roles that go beyond the consultation, have their own training. What the method brings to a curriculum is the core that joins the two: the reasoning that chooses the question and reads the answer, taught and assessed as one.

Appendix 9: About the Authors

Alfons A. M. Crijnen and Herro F. Kraan have worked together on the MAAS Medical Interview since the early 1980s. It started on Wednesday mornings. They wanted to understand how a clinician actually solves the problem in front of them: the reasoning that runs underneath the interview. They began in mental health, where so much of the work is carried by what is said. Each week a simulated patient was interviewed by a physician or a resident. Afterwards Crijnen questioned the interviewer, listening closely to how each question had been posed and each answer received, to bring the underlying cognitive process to the surface. Kraan, meanwhile, set down its order and structure.

Two things from those mornings have shaped everything since. Drawing a clinician’s reasoning into the open took fluent interviewing. The questioner had to ask well enough for the heavy, half-hidden process to come to the table at all. So the craft of asking and the reasoning it served proved inseparable, each leaning on the other. And what they were watching turned out to be teachable, once it could be named. Reasoning, they found, had been at the heart of the interview all along, and so the method came to teach the two as one.

Out of that work came an assessment instrument, a handbook for the interview, and, in this book, its companion for the reasoning the interview sets in motion: how a complaint, read back, leads to the mechanism that produced it. The two books are one method, written down in two halves, and they keep the shape of that first Wednesday-morning insight through four decades. The method is offered in the project’s spirit. It makes the implicit explicit so that it can be taught, and it leaves room for each clinician to find their own way of being present with the patient: grounded in skill, guided by evidence, and open to the person in front of them.