MAAS-MI Prep Clinical Reasoning

These exercises rehearse the reasoning of Clinical Reasoning: A Small Physiology of the Noticed Body: how a mechanism met in a region produces a complaint, and how to read the complaint back to its mechanism and region, and on to the diagnosis. Read the chapter, reason each task out in your own words, then reveal the worked reasoning. No scores — the aim is to make the mechanism visible and the reasoning yours.

How to use these exercises

  • Read the matching chapter of Clinical Reasoning first, then work through its exercises.
  • Commit before you reveal — reason the task out, then compare. The comparison is the learning, not the reading.
  • Each answer gives more than the right reading: it shows why the tempting wrong one fails, and links to the chapter and family behind it.
  • Work in a small group when you can, and bring your reasoning to a tutor. Prep builds what you can do alone; real patients and supervision do the rest.

What this is — and isn’t. The cases here are classic teaching examples, chosen to make the reasoning visible. They are a way to rehearse the method, not a clinical protocol — the real diagnosis is always the patient in front of you. These exercises build the framework; applying it well grows with clinical experience.

Five ideas run through every chapter. Hold them, and the rest is practice.

Five Threads

1. The list follows from one equation. Fifty-five complaints follow from one equation: mechanism × region = complaint. Learn how a complaint is produced, and you can read most of the review of systems instead of memorising it.

2. Reasoning reads the complaint back. The patient gives you the grammar; you read it back to the mechanism and the region that produced it, and the diagnosis follows.

3. The feel carries the mechanism. The quality-word names an injury, the timing a mode of failure, the companions a family. The body’s grammar is small — four dimensions — and it points.

4. Danger is built into the presentation. For a cross-cutting complaint the catastrophic mechanism is a member of the set, not a coincidence. Chest pain always carries dissection, pulmonary embolism and tamponade; the rule-out runs every time, before the likely answer settles.

5. The diagnosis is a prediction. The right mechanism predicts the right relief and the right complication. Follow-up is the experiment that confirms the reasoning, or tells you the mechanism was wrong.

Chapters

1The Noticed Body

What a sensation actually reports, and the moment it crosses from unnoticed into a complaint.

  • 1.1Name the regulatory failure a sensation reports

    A patient says: “I get short of breath climbing the stairs, and it has been getting worse over a month.”

    In one sentence, name the regulatory failure the sensation reports — and the one feature of the story that tells you.

    Reveal answer

    A failure to match oxygen delivery to demand on exertion — the body can no longer keep tissue oxygenation defended when metabolic demand rises. The tell is that it appears on exertion and eases at rest.

    Contrast: breathlessness that is worse lying flat points instead at a cardiac/fluid mechanism (orthopnoea); breathlessness at rest with tingling points at a metabolic or anxiety driver. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 1; Family II.)

  • 1.2Mark the moment a sensation crosses into notice

    A patient with long-standing knee osteoarthritis says it was “a bit stiff for years, but three days ago it became hot, swollen, and I cannot weight-bear.”

    When did it cross from unnoticed to noticed, and what tipped it?

    Reveal answer

    The crossing is three days ago — heat, swelling, loss of weight-bearing. A new process (acute inflammation: an effusion, or a septic joint) was added on top of the chronic mechanical background; the change in tempo is the tell that a second process has joined the first.

    Contrast: had the same joint slowly grown stiffer over months, that would be the old process progressing, not a new one. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 1.)

  • 1.3Read one process in health and in disease

    Take coronary perfusion. Describe the physiological version (below threshold) and the pathological version (above), and name what tips the balance.

    Reveal answer

    In health, below threshold: coronary flow rises to meet myocardial demand — the vessels dilate on exertion, delivery keeps pace, and no sensation is produced. In disease, above threshold: a fixed stenosis caps the rise, so on exertion demand outstrips supply and ischaemia is felt as pressure (angina); at rest supply again suffices and it fades. What tips the balance is demand exceeding the now-limited reserve. One process, read in health and in disease. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 1; Family II.)

  • 1.4Take a complaint apart

    Take a patient’s phrase, split it into quality, location and timing, and name what each points at.

    Try it on: “A burning behind my breastbone, worse after meals and when I lie down.”

    Reveal answer

    Quality — burning → a surface in chemical contact (acid).

    Location — retrosternal → the oesophagus.

    Timing — after meals and on lying down → reflux provocation.

    Read together, the three point at gastro-oesophageal reflux. The grammar is what the mechanism and the region give you to read. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 1.)

  • 1.5The Top-7 — quality-word to mechanism, confirmed by one question

    A patient calls chest discomfort “a heavy pressure, like a weight.”

    Which mechanism does it most point at — and which single question best confirms it?

    • A) Inflammation — confirm by asking about tenderness
    • B) Ischaemia — confirm by asking whether exertion brings it on and rest eases it
    • C) Reflux — confirm by asking about a sour taste after meals
    • D) Anxiety — confirm by asking about life stress
    Reveal answer

    B. “Heavy pressure” is the grammar of ischaemia (Family II); the confirming H3 is the exertion-and-relief pattern.

    A would read as sharp and tender.

    C burns and follows meals.

    D is possible but is a diagnosis of exclusion — pressure with an exertional trigger must not be closed on anxiety first.

    A plausible mechanism is confirmed by the one question that tells it apart from the others. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 1 §4, the Top-7.)

  • 1.6The hand-off — which heuristic surfaced the grammar

    Given a short exchange, mark which interview heuristic (H1–H4) surfaced each part of the grammar, and name the mechanism it points at.

    Physician: “What does it feel like, and where?”
    Patient: “A heavy pressure, right across the middle of my chest.”

    Physician: “When did it start, and what were you doing?”
    Patient: “Twenty minutes ago, walking up the hill.”

    Physician: “Does anything change it?”
    Patient: “It eased when I stopped to rest.”

    Physician: “Something else with it?”
    Patient: “A bit sweaty and sick.”

    Reveal answer

    H1 Complaint — quality (heavy pressure) and location (central chest).

    H2 Time-Intensity — acute onset, followed by H3 Modifying Factors — on exertion.

    H3 Modifying Factors — relieved by rest.

    H4 Context — the autonomic companions (sweaty, nauseated).

    Read together: ischaemia in coronary territory (Family II) — pressure quality, exertional onset, relief with rest, autonomic halo. Likely an acute coronary syndrome; rule out the cannot-miss alternatives (dissection, pulmonary embolism) before closing. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 1.)

2The Quiet Body

How a healthy body stays silent as an active achievement, and the ways that quiet is overrun.

  • 2.1Name the achievements that keep a system quiet

    A 68-year-old with a narrowed aortic valve has no complaints. He still walks his dog, and sits down saying nothing is wrong.

    Which of the six achievements — negative feedback, reserve, redundancy, adaptation, anticipation, perceptual filtering — are keeping him quiet, and how?

    Reveal answer

    Five of the six are at work.

    Negative feedback: his baroreflex holds his blood pressure while the valve limits his output.

    Reserve: his heart draws on its reserve to push blood through the narrowed valve.

    Adaptation: the thickened ventricle, remodelled to the load.

    Anticipation: his sympathetic system prepares his circulation before he moves, so he can start walking without trouble.

    Perceptual filtering: his brain has learned to pass over the slight breathlessness when he begins to exert himself.

    Redundancy is the sixth, and it plays no part in him. The five work out of sight, and each costs something to run, which is why the sign (a murmur at the annual check) appears before the symptom. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 2.)

  • 2.2Read the compensation gap — the sign before the symptom

    A young trauma patient has lost significant blood but “feels fine.”

    Predict the sign the body is already showing that the symptom has not yet reported.

    Reveal answer

    Compensated hypovolaemia: vasoconstriction and tachycardia still defend the blood pressure, so the patient feels fine — but the signs precede the symptom: a raised heart rate, cool peripheries, a narrowed pulse pressure, delayed capillary refill, with a still-normal blood pressure.

    Contrast: a falling blood pressure is a late sign — waiting for it is waiting for decompensation.

    The dangerous reassurance is the normal symptom — read the sign the reserve is spending. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 2.)

  • 2.3Three modes — reserve, adaptation, regulator

    An elderly patient with stable COPD becomes rapidly more breathless over two days, with fever and green sputum.

    By which mode did the illness arrive?

    • A) Reserve exhausted — the slow using-up of a margin
    • B) Adaptation outpaced — a demand faster than the system can adapt to
    • C) Regulator broken — the control system itself fails
    • D) None — this is just baseline COPD
    Reveal answer

    B. A new infection (H4: fever, purulent sputum) imposed an acute demand faster than the already-thin respiratory reserve could adapt; the H2 tempo — two days, against the usual slow decline — is the tell.

    A is the slow background COPD trajectory.

    C would be a failure of a control system (e.g. endocrine).

    D ignores the tempo change.

    The mode is read from the tempo: a slow decline spends the reserve; a sudden change on top of it means a new demand has outrun adaptation. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 2.)

  • 2.4A sensation that fits, and a complaint

    Breathlessness after sprinting for a bus, versus breathlessness walking to the kitchen.

    Which fits the situation, which has crossed into a complaint, and what makes the difference?

    Reveal answer

    Sprinting → fits: the sensation matches the demand — the body reporting appropriate effort.

    Kitchen → complaint: the sensation is out of proportion to a trivial demand, so it reports a failure to meet an easy load.

    The difference is whether the sensation fits its context. A sensation that fits the demand that produced it stays a sensation; the same sensation without that demand becomes a complaint. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 2.)

3The Grammar of the Sensation

The four dimensions of every complaint, quality, location, timing and companions, read together as one signature.

  • 3.1Separate the four dimensions into a coherent signature

    “A burning pain behind the breastbone, comes after meals, worse lying down, with a sour taste.”

    Split it into quality, location, timing and companions, and say whether they cohere into one signature.

    Reveal answer

    Quality — burning.

    Location — retrosternal.

    Timing — post-meal, worse recumbent.

    Companions — sour regurgitation (acid).

    They cohere into one signature — acid mucosal irritation (reflux): the burning fits a chemical injury to a mucosa, the location fits the oesophagus, and the post-meal and postural timing with the acid companion all point the same way.

    Contrast: if the “burning” came with exertional pressure and radiation to the arm, the four would not cohere — and a mixed signature is a warning to reconsider cardiac. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 3.)

  • 3.2Quality — the reporter and the injury

    A patient calls a pain “burning.”

    Name the reporter and the injury it implies — then say which quality-word you would expect if the reporter changed and the injury stayed the same.

    Reveal answer

    “Burning” is reported by nociceptors sensing a chemical or mucosal injury, or an irritated nerve (acid, inflammation, a neuropathy). Change the reporter — a well-innervated somatic surface in place of mucosa or nerve — and the same irritation reads as “sharp” or “raw.” The quality-word is set by the reporter as much as by the injury. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 3.)

  • 3.3Location — referral and migration

    (a) A heart attack is felt in the left arm and jaw — name the shared source.

    (b) Appendicitis pain began peri-umbilical and moved to the right iliac fossa — what does the migration report?

    Reveal answer

    (a) The heart, the chest and the inner left arm share spinal segments T1–4; the cord cannot separate visceral from somatic afferents converging on the same neurons, so the pain is referred to the arm. The jaw lies outside T1–4: cardiac pain spreads there, and to the epigastrium, through neighbouring pathways.

    (b) The migration marks a change of reporter: the early peri-umbilical pain is visceral (midgut, referred to T10) from the distended appendix; the shift to the right iliac fossa is the moment the inflamed appendix touches the parietal peritoneum, which is precisely localised. The migration reports the disease advancing from visceral to parietal. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 3.)

  • 3.4Timing and companions — which tempo, which halo

    A headache is “like being hit on the back of the head,” maximal within seconds.

    Which reading fits best — and which companions would you ask about?

    • A) Tension-type — gradual, band-like
    • B) A vascular catastrophe (subarachnoid haemorrhage) — the instant onset is decisive
    • C) Migraine — builds over an hour, often with aura
    • D) Sinus — worse on bending, with congestion
    Reveal answer

    B. Timing is the decisive dimension: only a vascular rupture reaches maximal intensity within seconds (thunderclap). Companions to seek: neck stiffness, photophobia, reduced consciousness — their presence makes the haemorrhage more likely, and their absence does not rule it out.

    A, C and D all describe slower builds and cannot produce an instant maximum.

    Tempo alone reclassifies this headache from benign to emergency. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 3; the safety principle, Ch 4.)

  • 3.5The swap — reading a negative-departure complaint

    An older patient’s family reports he “cannot follow conversations and turns the TV up.”

    Apply the grammar. What is the pattern of the deficit, what functional probe would confirm the level, and whose report carries the history?

    Reveal answer

    This is a lost function, read on the negative-departure track.

    Pattern: reduced hearing, likely high-frequency and gradual (presbyacusis); failing to pick out words points at a sensorineural loss, and asymmetry would raise concern.

    Probe: a louder voice at close range. Louder sound helps both kinds of loss; what separates them is whether speech becomes clear. Clear again → likely conductive; louder and still unclear → likely sensorineural. Tuning-fork tests and the audiogram settle it.

    History: the informant is a main source of the history; the patient may not notice a slow, symmetrical loss, so the family’s observation is the presenting signal.

    Same grammar, read with three swaps: the pattern of the deficit for the quality-word, a functional probe for the symptom modifier, the informant for the patient. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 3; developed in Ch 8.)

4The Complaint Equation

How every complaint is produced by two factors — a mechanism met in a region — and read through its grammar.

  • 4.1Read a complaint back to its mechanism and region

    Read a complaint back to its two factors — the mechanism and the region — and show that the two together, read through the grammar, produce the name.

    Try it on: “biliary colic.”

    Reveal answer

    Mechanism — obstruction: a stone intermittently blocking the cystic duct, smooth muscle contracting against it.

    Region — the biliary lumen: a hollow, distensible tube.

    Obstruction met in a hollow biliary lumen produces the grammar: the gripping quality with restlessness, a pain that builds to a plateau and holds, under the right ribs and referred to the right shoulder blade (the gallbladder’s segments, T7–9), and the fatty-meal provocation. Pain at the shoulder tip (C3–5) would point at the diaphragm instead. The grammar is what the two factors produce; read together, they name biliary colic. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 4; referral, Ch 3.)

  • 4.2Region-types and the grammar they carry

    Take a vascular territory — a coronary artery.

    Name its region-type and two or three grammar-values you would expect its complaints to take — and two it would not take.

    Reveal answer

    A vascular territory is a deep, poorly-somatically-innervated region reporting via visceral afferents. Expect: pressure / heaviness / tightness (not sharp), poorly localised, with an exertion-and-relief timing when the mechanism is ischaemia. It would not take a precise location the patient can point to, or reproducible-on-palpation tenderness — a vessel wall has no rich somatic afferents to generate those. Region constrains the grammar before mechanism is even considered. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 4.)

  • 4.3Hold one factor, vary the other

    Hold the mechanism at ischaemia and vary the region. List the review-of-systems complaints that result.

    Reveal answer

    Ischaemia, region by region:

    Coronary — angina / chest pain.

    Cerebral — TIA / stroke symptoms.

    Mesenteric — post-prandial abdominal pain (“intestinal angina”).

    Limb — claudication.

    Retinal — amaurosis fugax.

    One mechanism, five regions, five complaints — each with the same demand-led or loss grammar, shifted by its region. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 4.)

  • 4.4Recognise the exception class

    A patient presents with “fatigue” and nothing else.

    Which class is this, and which factor of the equation carries the most diagnostic weight?

    • A) Cross-cutting — many mechanisms at one signature
    • B) Branching — one word splitting into sub-qualities
    • C) Systemic-companion — no localised signature; the companions carry the weight
    • D) Mechanical edge — no active process to disturb
    Reveal answer

    C. Fatigue is systemic-companion: the signature is degenerate at H1 (no quality-word, no location), so the companions (H4) across systems become the presenting axis — you reason from the companions inward.

    A still has a localised signature (e.g. chest pain).

    B needs a quality-word that splits (e.g. dizziness).

    D is a structural, reproducible-on-movement complaint.

    When H1 is empty, the companions carry the diagnosis; naming the class tells you which factor of the equation to read first. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 4; the sweep entered at H4, Ch 6.)

  • 4.5The safety principle — name the catastrophic alternative

    A patient has a headache you think is migraine.

    Name the catastrophic alternative and the single question or test that separates them.

    Reveal answer

    The catastrophic alternative is subarachnoid haemorrhage. The separator is onset speed: “Did it come on instantly — worst headache of your life, maximal within seconds — or build over minutes to hours?” A thunderclap onset mandates imaging (CT, then LP if needed) before migraine is accepted. Run the rule-out even when the benign diagnosis is more likely: for a cross-cutting complaint the catastrophic mechanism is a structural member of the set, and the clean answer is the one that invites premature closure. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 4; App 3.)

5The Five Families

The seventeen mechanisms, sixteen of them grouped into five families by shared logic, and the seven aetiologies beneath them.

  • 5.1Identify the family from its signature

    “Symmetric small-joint pain, tenderness, morning stiffness, a low fever.”

    Which family, and the signature that decided it?

    • A) Family I — Tissue Injury and Response (inflammation)
    • B) Family II — Perfusion and Oxygenation
    • C) Family IV — Luminal and Pressure Dynamics
    • D) Mechanical edge — a structural fault
    Reveal answer

    A. The signature: tenderness, symmetrical small-joint involvement, morning stiffness, a steady or steadily rising course, and a systemic halo (low fever). The Family I move — “is there tenderness, and does anything systemic go with it?” — is yes to both.

    B would be demand-led pressure.

    C cramps in waves.

    D is reproducible on movement with no systemic halo.

    (This picture is inflammatory synovitis; e.g. rheumatoid arthritis.) (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 5.)

  • 5.2Match the signature to the family

    Five patients, five sentences. For each, name the family the complaint belongs to and the failure at its centre.

    The five families are: I Tissue Injury and Response, II Perfusion and Oxygenation, III Vessel and Fluid Balance, IV Luminal and Pressure Dynamics, V Signal and Regulation.

    1. A burning behind the breastbone after meals, eased by an antacid.
    2. A pressure across the chest on walking uphill, gone within a minute of sitting down.
    3. One calf swollen, warm and tender over a single day.
    4. Cramping abdominal pain coming in waves, with vomiting and no wind or stool.
    5. Burning, tingling numbness in both feet, worse at night.
    Reveal answer

    Family I — Tissue Injury and Response. Acid meeting an unprotected mucosa: chemical irritation of the tissue.

    Family II — Perfusion and Oxygenation. Demand outrunning supply: ischaemia in coronary territory.

    Family III — Vessel and Fluid Balance. A vessel failing to keep blood moving: venous thrombosis.

    Family IV — Luminal and Pressure Dynamics. A blocked lumen with pressure rising behind it: obstruction.

    Family V — Signal and Regulation. Disordered nerve signalling: a peripheral neuropathy.

    The family follows from the failure, whatever the organ: the same reasoning places demand outrunning supply in Family II whether it strikes the heart, the leg, or the gut. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 5.)

  • 5.3The map — complaint to mechanism to family to aetiology

    Take “acute coronary syndrome.”

    Name its family (or families), its dominant mechanism, and the aetiology (or aetiologies) that drive it — then trace the full chain forward from aetiology to complaint.

    Reveal answer

    Family II (Perfusion and Oxygenation); mechanism ischaemia; aetiologies degenerative and nutritional (atherosclerosis, helped along by diet and metabolism), with a thrombus on the narrowed vessel as the acute trigger. Forward: the aetiology narrows a coronary vessel → ischaemia in coronary territory → grammar of exertional or rest pressure with an autonomic halo → the complaint “chest pain” → the diagnosis ACS. Aetiology drives mechanism drives grammar drives complaint. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 5 §8, the map of mechanisms and aetiologies; App 4.)

  • 5.4The mechanical edge

    Mechanical, the seventeenth mechanism, is the only structural one: the fault lies in the anatomy. Here an image can mislead.

    Two patients with low back pain, each with a scan. For each, decide whether the imaging finding is the mechanism of the complaint, a co-mechanism, or an incidental finding — and name the H3 test that would settle it.

    1. Back pain radiating down one leg to the outer foot, worse on coughing, with numbness along the same line. MRI: a disc herniation compressing the S1 nerve root.
    2. Aching pain across the low back after a day in the garden, no radiation, eased by moving about. MRI: a mild disc bulge at L4–L5.
    Reveal answer

    Case 1 — the finding is the mechanism. The grammar matches what an S1 compression produces: pain in the root’s distribution, radiating to the outer foot, with numbness along the same dermatome. The H3 test is the provocation: coughing, which raises pressure on the root, brings the leg pain on. Finding and complaint fit.

    Case 2 — the finding is almost certainly incidental. Disc bulges are common in people with no pain at all. The grammar here is mechanical and axial — no radiation, no dermatome — and the H3 answer, eased by moving about, points at the soft tissues of the back. The bulge is a bystander.

    What settles it: an imaging finding earns the name mechanism only when the complaint’s grammar matches the syndrome that finding would produce, and the H3 test behaves as that syndrome predicts. The scan shows the finding; the fit between grammar and finding makes the diagnosis. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 5 §7.)

  • 5.5Sort Family III by onset speed

    Three patients, one family — Vessel and Fluid Balance. Before any test, let onset speed do the first sorting: decide for each which of the three mechanisms is in play — vascular leak or rupture, Starling-force oedema, or haemostatic disturbance — name the grammar that told you, and the companion that would confirm it.

    1. A sudden, tearing pain between the shoulder blades, maximal the instant it began.
    2. Both ankles swelling over three weeks, worse by evening, painless, the rings still fitting.
    3. Bruising after the lightest knocks, and gums that bleed when brushing.
    Reveal answer

    Vascular leak or rupture. Instant, tearing, maximal at onset — the temporal signature of a wall that failed all at once. Confirming companions: faintness, pallor, a pulse or pressure difference between the arms.

    Starling-force oedema. Gradual, gravity-dependent, painless accumulation — the capillary exchanging more fluid than the lymphatics can return. Confirming companions: breathlessness on the stairs and a raised jugular venous pressure point at the heart; a drug such as amlodipine on the list points at the medicine.

    Haemostatic disturbance. Bleeding and bruising out of proportion to the trauma — the cascade that patches microtrauma has failed. Confirming companions: bleeding elsewhere, an anticoagulant on the drug list, a family history of bleeding.

    Onset speed did the sorting before anything was sent to the lab: instant points at a wall that gave way and takes precedence over everything; gradual painless growth points at Starling; bleeding out of proportion points at haemostasis. Only after that sort do the aetiology, the treatment, and the safety-net open properly. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 5.)

6Reading the Complaint Back

Clinical reasoning as the equation read from right to left: reading the grammar back to the mechanism through four patterns.

  • 6.1Follow the feel to the mechanism, heuristic by heuristic

    A patient reports a gripping right-upper-quadrant pain after a fatty meal.

    Take each heuristic in turn and name what it draws out, and which candidate each question narrows.

    Reveal answer

    H1 Complaint: gripping and restless, under the right ribs → quality and location → narrows to Family IV, obstruction of a hollow lumen.

    H2 Time-Intensity: builds to a steady plateau, after a meal, settling within a few hours, in attacks → tempo → narrows to intermittent obstruction (biliary colic); pain that lasts beyond about six hours would point at cholecystitis.

    H3 Modifying factors: brought on by fatty food → narrows to the biliary tree: the gallbladder emptying against a stone.

    H4 Context: nausea, sweating, pain into the right shoulder blade, no fever → the autonomic halo and the gallbladder’s referral confirm a visceral biliary source, and the absent fever keeps cholecystitis less likely.

    Each question narrows the candidates; together they follow the feel to biliary colic. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 6.)

  • 6.2Choose which of the four patterns is called for

    A 55-year-old presents with acute central chest pain, sweating, at rest.

    Which of the four patterns is called for?

    • A) Pattern recognition — the fast whole read (the destination)
    • B) Branching — one signature splitting into sub-qualities
    • C) Rule-out, in parallel — several mechanisms held at once, each excluded
    • D) Schema-based, entered at H4 — a degenerate signature, read through the companions
    Reveal answer

    C. Chest pain is cross-cutting: the same signature admits several mechanisms at once (ischaemia, aortic dissection, PE, tamponade, oesophageal rupture). The feature is that a catastrophic alternative is a structural member of the set — none is safe to prefer without excluding the others in parallel.

    A would be premature closure — a fast read that skips the danger.

    B needs a splitting quality-word.

    D needs a degenerate signature (fatigue, fever), which this is not.

    Naming the leading hypothesis is necessary but not sufficient — the move is to actively test the alternatives before settling. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 6; App 3.)

  • 6.3Walk the sweep — schema-based, entered at H4

    A patient presents with unexplained weight loss and nothing else.

    Walk the sweep: where do you start, which companions do you ask about and roughly in what order, and where do H2 and H3 come in?

    Reveal answer

    H1 is empty — no quality-word, no address — so you cannot start there; enter at H4, the companions across systems, which are the presenting axis. Sweep the systems for that axis:

    Appetite and bowels (malignancy, malabsorption).

    Fever and night sweats (infection, lymphoma).

    Heat intolerance and tremor (thyroid).

    Thirst and polyuria (diabetes).

    Mood and sleep (depression).

    H2 (the tempo — weeks versus months) narrows the class; H3 and investigations then confirm. H1 remains only as a rule-out check for a hidden localised complaint the patient did not name. This is the systematic sweep, entered through the one door the complaint leaves open. Cannot-miss: malignancy. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 6; App 3; the systemic-companion class, Ch 4.)

  • 6.4The disconfirming move

    Name the one question and the one test whose result could prove your leading hypothesis wrong — and say what each would show.

    Try it on: a patient whose epigastric pain you have read as a peptic ulcer.

    Reveal answer

    The disconfirming question: “Is it brought on by exertion and eased by rest?” — a yes points away from an ulcer toward cardiac ischaemia (an inferior myocardial infarction can present as epigastric pain). The disconfirming test: an ECG with troponin — a positive result overturns the benign reading. A good hypothesis names what would confirm it and the single finding that would refute it; actively seeking that finding is what guards against premature closure. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 6.)

  • 6.5Pattern selection under time pressure

    Busy clinic; a patient with a classic migraine history says today’s headache feels the same.

    Name the pattern, its shortest safe run, and the questions you cannot skip.

    Reveal answer

    Pattern: rule-out (one likely benign, one cannot-miss). Shortest safe run: confirm the headache matches the prior migraine pattern (same quality, tempo, triggers, aura) and actively exclude the red flags. Cannot skip: onset speed (thunderclap → SAH); fever with neck stiffness (meningitis); new neurology or “worst ever”; posture and wake-time pattern (raised ICP). If every red-flag is negative and the pattern matches, migraine settles. The gap to guard is the one where the pattern matched but a red-flag was skipped — that is where missed diagnoses hide. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 6; App 3.)

  • 6.6Close the loop — predict relief and complication

    You diagnose gastro-oesophageal reflux disease (GORD) and start a proton-pump inhibitor.

    Name the relief and the complication it predicts, and what you would revise if the prediction fails.

    Reveal answer

    Predicted relief: the burning eases within days to a couple of weeks on acid suppression — the mechanism (acid mucosal irritation) predicts a response to removing acid. Predicted complication if untreated: oesophagitis, stricture, bleeding. If the predicted relief does not appear, first ask whether the treatment reached the mechanism (taken, at the right dose, for long enough); if it did, the mechanism was likely wrong — return to the H3 branch point (cardiac pain mimicking reflux, or a motility or malignant cause) and look for red-flag features warranting endoscopy. A wrong prediction is the most useful result — it names exactly which branch to revisit. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 6; Ch 10.)

  • 6.7When the read-back fails

    A patient returns repeatedly. The pain shifts location and quality between visits, the companions fit no single family, and two treatments that each predicted relief brought none.

    Name what you are meeting, and how the reasoning should change.

    Reveal answer

    The warning signs — a grammar whose four dimensions will not fit together, companions and timing that fit no single family, a story that shifts between visits, and treatments that keep failing to bring the predicted relief — point at a sensitised reporter: the tissue is sound, and the nervous system that reports has itself become oversensitive. The tissue reading no longer holds: the grammar no longer follows a mechanism in a tissue. This happens often: functional and medically unexplained presentations, now often grouped as persistent physical symptoms, are a large fraction of primary-care contacts, so suspect it early. Stop pressing the tissue reading, keep any dangerous branch covered, and move the reasoning to the reporter: recognise the sensitised reporter, reframe the complaint for the patient, and redirect the plan (Chapter 9). The interview’s process skills (Scales 4, 5 and 6) and shared decision-making (Scale 3) carry much of that work. A mechanism forced onto a tissue that is not producing one is the error to avoid. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 6 §6; Ch 9; App 2.)

7From Mechanism to Cause, and Cause to Cure

The second half of the read-back: from the mechanism to its cause, the person and the plan.

  • 7.1The second half — what H5 to H7 add

    A patient’s mechanism is settled — say, coronary ischaemia behind stable angina.

    There is a mechanism now, but not yet a cause or a plan. Name what each of the three extended heuristics — H5, H6 and H7 — still needs to add, and why the plan cannot be built until they have.

    Reveal answer

    H5 Psychosocial Impact — the person. The life the disease sits in: function, meaning, the life-course, what “better” would look like, what the patient can actually carry.

    H6 Staging — the underlying disease and what has been tried. Other illnesses, the prior treatments, and the current medicines — some of which can themselves be part of the cause.

    H7 Risk and Vulnerability — the aetiology. Why the mechanism arose at all: here, atherosclerotic coronary disease and the risk factors that built it (family history, smoking, cholesterol).

    The mechanism says what is happening. H5–H7 say in whom, on what ground, and why — and the plan is composed from all three together with the mechanism. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 7.)

  • 7.2The life-course question

    H5 sometimes needs the longer question — what a person’s earlier life was like — the kind you would not ask on a first visit.

    For a patient whose recovery keeps stalling, write how you would open that question so it invites the context without reducing the person to it. Then say what the answer could bring out about the person, and one thing it would change about the plan.

    Write a few lines — there is no answer key.

    Reveal a note to compare

    A good opening is open and permissioned — “Can I ask what life was like for you, growing up?” — offered, and left for the patient to fill or to decline.

    The discipline is in what you do next. The childhood household that drank, the smoking that started at fifteen, the loss that changed the daily walk: these are life-course context that shapes the present. They help you understand the person the disease sits in, and the disease keeps its own causes. For heart disease the link is well studied: seven or more kinds of childhood adversity raise the risk more than threefold, and psychological factors carried more of that extra risk than the traditional risk factors did. Use the frame as a lens for understanding, without a score.

    One thing it can change is the behavioural arm of the plan: a walk that was shared with someone now gone needs a plan that fits the life the patient has now.

    How to ask it warmly is the interview handbook’s craft; this book shows what the answer tells you. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 7.)

  • 7.3H6 — a current medicine as the cause

    A patient’s blood pressure stays high despite treatment. H6 asks what medicines they take and what has already been tried.

    Name one current medication that could itself be raising the pressure, explain how a prior treatment that failed can be read as diagnostic data, and say how each changes the plan.

    Reveal answer

    A regular non-steroidal anti-inflammatory — ibuprofen taken two or three days a week for arthritic knees. NSAIDs raise blood pressure by a few mmHg on average, mainly in people who already have hypertension, and the size of the effect varies by drug. That makes the ibuprofen part of the cause: an H6 finding you can act on by switching to a topical NSAID, with paracetamol only as needed (taken regularly, paracetamol raises blood pressure too), and checking the pressure again before adding a second antihypertensive.

    A prior antihypertensive that did not work was an H3 test whose answer was “no.” It narrows the mechanism by ruling out the target that drug addressed, and it points the next choice. H6 turns the medicine list into a cause to remove and a set of experiments already run. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 7.)

  • 7.4Split the treatment — relief and cure

    Take a diagnosis with both a mechanism and an aetiology — stable angina on atherosclerotic disease.

    Name what treats the mechanism (relief) and what treats the aetiology (cure); and where the aetiology has two arms, name both.

    Reveal answer

    Relief — aimed at the mechanism. A nitrate widens the veins and eases the heart’s workload, so the narrowed coronary supply is enough again, and the pressure eases. The symptom stops; the disease beneath it is untouched.

    Cure — aimed at the aetiology. The atherosclerotic disease, addressed on two arms: a pharmacological one (a statin, blood-pressure control, an antiplatelet) and a behavioural one (walking, diet, stopping smoking).

    Relief without cure leaves the disease running quietly under an eased symptom. For a disease whose aetiology has both arms, the plan that addresses both is what the evidence supports — and the behavioural arm is where H5, the person, decides what can actually be carried. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 7.)

  • 7.5The same H3 across three visits

    A patient is seen across three visits for the same problem. Each time, the same heuristic — H3, what makes it better or worse — is being asked, but it is testing something different each time.

    Name what H3 is testing at the first visit, at the second, and at a third where the treatment has failed.

    Reveal answer

    Visit one — finding the mechanism. “What makes it better or worse?” separates the candidate mechanisms and confirms which one is at work.

    Visit two — testing the treatment. The same question, now asked of the treatment: did the predicted relief appear? If it did, the outcome supports what the reasoning proposed, and the more specific the treatment, the more it says.

    Visit three — a treatment that failed. An H3 “no.” The failure is purposeful data: either the treatment did not reach the mechanism, or the mechanism was wrong and you go back to the branch point to reconsider it. A failed treatment is a test result, and the interview structure carries the thread between visits. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 7.)

  • 7.6When the aetiology will not resolve

    Sometimes the second half does not narrow the plan: the aetiology will not resolve.

    Decide whether you are meeting the idiopathic case, the sensitised reporter, or a case where the mechanism or the treatment simply needs more time — and describe what the next visit should do differently.

    Reveal answer

    Idiopathic. The cause is not found after an adequate search. Name the uncertainty, aim treatment at the mechanism and the known risk factors, cover the dangerous branch, and let the next visit check the course.

    The sensitised reporter. The tissue is sound and the nervous system that reports has become oversensitive. More tissue tests will not resolve it; the next visit turns toward the reporter and the person (Ch 9), and sometimes toward the mental-health handbook.

    Needs more time. The process, or the treatment, is still working; the next visit checks the prediction this one made.

    You tell them apart by three things: how complete the search has been, whether the grammar still coheres, and how the picture answers to time. Some hard cases are psychosocial and some unresolved ones are idiopathic; drawing that boundary is the clinical judgement. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 7 §8.)

8When the Patient Is Not the One Who Notices

The complaints noticed by someone else first: lost function, the informant as a main source of the history, and the functional probe.

  • 8.1Who noticed — patient, informant, or both

    A wife brings her husband: he has become withdrawn and repeats himself; he says nothing is wrong.

    Who is the one who notices?

    • A) The patient — he is the one experiencing it
    • B) The informant (the wife) — the change is a lost function the patient cannot see
    • C) Both equally
    • D) Neither — this needs a test first
    Reveal answer

    B. The mismatch between a reported change (withdrawal, repetition — a lost cognitive function) and the patient’s own non-report (“nothing is wrong”) is the tell. Negative-departure complaints, especially cognitive ones, are often invisible to the very ability that has been lost, so the noticing falls to the informant.

    A over-trusts a patient who lacks insight.

    C misses the asymmetry.

    D delays — you interview both first, and the gap between them is itself diagnostic.

    A lost function is often invisible to the person who has lost it, so the informant becomes a main source of the history. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 8.)

  • 8.2The collateral interview

    For the same presentation (possible cognitive decline), list the H1–H4 questions you would ask the informant, and say what the patient’s and the informant’s accounts, read together, would let you conclude.

    Reveal answer

    H1 (nature): what exactly changed — memory, language, personality?

    H2 (time): sudden or gradual; stepwise or steady?

    H3 (modifying): better or worse at times of day; triggers or new medications?

    H4 (companions): gait, continence, mood, sleep, weight?

    Hear each source separately — the patient alone (their account and their insight) and the informant alone (their observations). Read together, the two accounts show what has changed, how fast, and how much of it the patient is aware of; the gap between them is itself diagnostic. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 8.)

  • 8.3Functional probes, level by level

    A patient has hearing loss. Name the probe that would restore the function, or bring out the deficit, at each level where the failure could lie, and interpret the result.

    Reveal answer

    A louder voice at close range is the probe that restores function. Louder sound helps both kinds of loss; what separates them is whether speech becomes clear. If louder speech is clear again, the loss is likely conductive: something is in the way of the sound reaching the cochlea (wax, otitis media, otosclerosis). If speech grows louder and stays unclear, it is likely sensorineural: the cochlea or the auditory nerve is damaged.

    Tuning-fork tests and the audiogram settle it:

    Rinne (tuning fork mastoid vs ear): air > bone is normal or sensorineural; bone > air is conductive.

    Weber (fork on the forehead): lateralises to the affected ear in conductive loss, to the better ear in sensorineural.

    Each probe picks out one level — outer and middle ear (conductive) or cochlea and nerve (sensorineural) — so the pattern of results names the level of the failure. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 8.)

  • 8.4Read the gap across the four configurations

    Name the four configurations of patient-versus-informant report, and how the diagnostic direction changes across them.

    Reveal answer

    (1) Patient reports, informant confirms → both agree, straightforward.

    (2) Patient reports, informant does not → a sensation invisible to others (e.g. pain), or amplification — weigh the patient’s interior access.

    (3) Informant reports, patient does not → the classic insight-loss / negative-departure case — trust the informant; suspect that the ability that would notice is itself failing.

    (4) Neither reports but signs are present → screening or compensated disease — the body shows a sign before either senses it.

    The direction of trust shifts with the configuration. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 8.)

  • 8.5The bridge to the mental-health framework

    A patient with possible psychosis has no insight that anything is wrong.

    Recognise the handover moment, and name what the MH handbook’s framework adds to the body-based reasoning.

    Reveal answer

    The handover comes when insight itself is the ability at stake. The body-based read-back assumes a body that reports; here the patient cannot report the disturbance, and the disturbance lies in thought or perception. The mental-health framework adds the tools for that: the mental-state examination, a collateral history given heavy weight, and a phenomenological reading of the experience. At this point the body-based reasoning hands over. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 8; and the mental-health handbook.)

9When the Reporter Is Sensitised

What to do when the sensation persists while the tissue is sound: reading the sensitised reporter.

  • 9.1Recognise the sensitised reporter

    Name which of the four signs are present, and decide whether the reading should leave the tissue.

    Try it on: a patient whose widespread pain has been worked as a tissue complaint across several visits without resolving.

    Reveal answer

    The four signs:

    (1) A grammar that will not cohere across its four dimensions — the quality changes, the location spreads without respecting a territory, the timing has no tempo that fits a family.

    (2) Companions that shift between visits, and cross several systems at once.

    (3) A run of treatments, each reasonable, that have all been given and none has held.

    (4) Investigations that come back normal, or trivially abnormal in ways that do not explain the pain.

    No single sign decides it. When several are present, stop forcing the tissue reading: the reporter has become sensitised. The diagnosis then rests on the positive signature (9.2), once treatable disease has been reasonably excluded. Make the move early; more tests and more drugs tell the patient something is being missed, and help keep the pain going. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 9.)

  • 9.2The sensitised signature

    Pick out the features that make a presentation a positive sensitised signature, and name the companion cluster you would ask about.

    Try it on: a patient who reports chronic widespread pain.

    Reveal answer

    The signature is positive: pain that is widespread or multifocal, often non-dermatomal, with allodynia (ordinary touch hurts) and hyperalgesia (a painful stimulus hurts more than it should) — the marks of an amplifying reporter. It fluctuates, tracking stress and sleep more than any mechanical load. The companion cluster confirms it: unrefreshing sleep, fatigue, cognitive “fog”, low or anxious mood, and heightened sensitivity to light, sound and smell. The cluster belongs to the diagnosis. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 9.)

  • 9.3Explain the mechanism to the patient

    In plain words, explain to a patient what central sensitisation is and why the pain is real — using the idea of the amplifying reporter and the account of prediction from Chapter 2.

    Reveal answer

    “Pain is an alarm your nervous system raises to protect you. In your case the alarm system itself has been turned up — it has learned to fire loudly at signals that would normally pass unnoticed. The pain is completely real. Your joints and nerves are sound; what has changed is the volume. Your nervous system is expecting danger and gives ordinary signals from your body too much weight. In one way that is good news: nothing is being damaged by the pain, and because the system has learned to be loud, it can be helped to turn back down.” (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 9.)

  • 9.4Sort the aetiology — predispose, precipitate, perpetuate

    Sort the factors into predisposing, precipitating, and perpetuating — and name which ones a plan can actually reach.

    Try it on: a sensitised presentation.

    Reveal answer

    Predisposing — a family history of pain, genes that set pain sensitivity, earlier chronic pain, female sex, long-term poor sleep, and a childhood of adversity.

    Precipitating — an injury, an infection, an operation, or a period of severe stress, after which the pain does not settle as it should.

    Perpetuating — poor sleep, inactivity, fear of movement, low or anxious mood, catastrophising, and the cycle of more investigation and more treatment that keeps the reporter alarmed.

    The predisposition is mostly fixed and the precipitant usually past. The perpetuating factors are where a plan can reach — the sleep, graded movement, the fear and the meaning, and an end to the chase. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 9.)

  • 9.5Recognise, reframe, redirect

    Walk the three moves — recognise, reframe, redirect — and write the one sentence in which you would name the mechanism to the patient.

    Try it on: a case with a sensitised reporter.

    Reveal answer

    Recognise — recognise the sensitised reporter, by the four signs; stop ordering tissue tests.

    Reframe — name the mechanism as central sensitisation, and say so to the patient: the pain is real, and the reporting system now amplifies.

    Redirect — turn the plan from the hunt for a tissue toward the reporter and the person: education, movement, sleep, psychological therapy, with a follow-up plan — while any treatable source of pain in the body is still addressed.

    The naming sentence: “The tests are reassuring — they tell us nothing is being damaged — and what we are dealing with is a pain system that has become oversensitive, which we can work on together.” (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 9.)

  • 9.6Draft the first plan

    Draft a first plan from the guideline shape — education, movement, psychological therapy, selective medication — and name the investigations and drugs you would deliberately stop.

    Try it on: a sensitised presentation.

    Reveal answer

    First plan — the shape NICE (2021, chronic primary pain) and EULAR (2017, fibromyalgia) agree on:

    Education — pain neuroscience education first: the explanation is the first treatment. Alone it does little for the pain; alongside exercise it eases pain and disability in the short term and lowers the fear of movement.

    Movement — graded aerobic and strengthening exercise as the backbone; the only treatment EULAR rates as a strong recommendation, and NICE offers a supervised group exercise programme.

    Sleep — attention to sleep.

    Psychological therapy — cognitive-behavioural therapy or acceptance and commitment therapy, for the fear of movement, the sleep, the mood and the catastrophising.

    Medication — selective: a low-dose amitriptyline or duloxetine where sleep or mood warrants, with realistic expectations of a modest effect (EULAR rates them, and pregabalin, as weak recommendations); never the centre.

    Deliberately stop: repeating investigations that keep coming back normal, and escalating tissue-aimed treatments that keep failing. NICE advises not to start paracetamol, NSAIDs, opioids or gabapentinoids for chronic primary pain: they carry little benefit and real harm. The two guidelines differ on pregabalin, a gabapentinoid: EULAR allows it, and NICE advises against starting it. Stopping is safe once treatable disease has been reasonably excluded, with the picture kept under review. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 9.)

10The Loop Closes

Follow-up as the experiment that checks the reasoning: the right mechanism predicts the right relief and the right complication.

  • 10.1State the relief you expect at follow-up

    You diagnose bacterial community-acquired pneumonia and start antibiotics.

    State the relief you expect at follow-up, and what you would revise if it does not appear.

    Reveal answer

    Expected relief: the fever settling within 48–72 hours and symptomatic improvement over days as the treated organism clears — the mechanism (bacterial infection) predicts a response to the right antibiotic. If it does not appear, reconsider: wrong organism or resistance, a complication (empyema, abscess), or a wrong mechanism entirely (PE, or malignancy with post-obstructive change). The failed prediction reopens the working diagnosis; treat it as data that names the next step. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 10.)

  • 10.2Name the earliest complication to watch for

    You diagnose a first deep-vein thrombosis.

    Name the earliest specific complication to watch for, and write the safety-net advice you would give at the end of the visit.

    Reveal answer

    Earliest specific complication: pulmonary embolism — a clot embolising — because the mechanism (a venous thrombus) predicts it directly. Safety-net advice: call 999 for sudden breathlessness, pleuritic chest pain, coughing up blood, or collapse; and cover the bleeding risks of anticoagulation. The complication you name is the one the mechanism most directly produces, and the advice arms the patient to catch it early. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 10.)

  • 10.3Present the solution, grounded in the mechanism

    You have reasoned to tension-type headache. Walk through Scale 3 items 3.1, 3.2, 3.3 and 3.6 in your own words, and check whether each rests on the reasoning about the mechanism you have done.

    Reveal answer

    3.1 Explains diagnosis — a tension-type headache, a benign cause, resting on the benign grammar and the negative red flags.

    3.2 Explains causes — the mechanism in plain words: tight muscles and over-sensitive pain pathways, with nothing in the brain damaged; and, this book’s addition, what the body has been doing to compensate.

    3.3 Explains prognosis — what comes next: it settles as the triggers are addressed; come back if the pattern changes; call 999 for a sudden thunderclap headache, or fever with a stiff neck, or new neurology — the rule-out mechanisms.

    3.6 Explains fit to problem — simple analgesia used sparingly, and the triggers (stress, posture, sleep) addressed: the plan fits the mechanism’s drivers.

    Then 3.12 Checks understanding: ask the patient to say back what they have understood. Each item rests on the mechanism you reasoned to. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 10; interview handbook, Scale 3.)

  • 10.4The explanation the patient came for

    Many patients come to be told what is going on, not to be treated.

    Take a benign complaint — a burning behind the breastbone, or a tension headache. In three plain sentences the patient would understand, say what the mechanism is, why it produces this exact feel, and why it is not dangerous.

    Write it out in your own words, then compare your explanation with the worked version.

    Reveal answer

    A good explanation does three things in plain words. For the burning behind the breastbone: “The burning is acid from your stomach rising into your gullet. Your gullet has none of the thick lining your stomach has, so the acid stings it — that is the burning, and it is worse after meals and lying down, when acid rises most easily. It is uncomfortable and worth treating, but it is not your heart, and once we settle the acid the lining heals and the burning stops.”

    Notice what carries it: a mechanism named without jargon (acid on an unprotected lining), the feel tied to the mechanism (why it burns, why after meals), and reassurance made honest and specific (not the heart; heals with treatment) — with the safety-net kept ready for the follow-up (call 999 if you vomit blood; come back if swallowing becomes difficult or you lose weight without trying). The content is the mechanism this book brings out; how you say it warmly at the bedside is the interview handbook’s craft. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 10.)

  • 10.5The end-state — grounded recognition

    Think of a diagnosis you now recognise almost instantly. Can you still take it apart into grammar → mechanism → region? Where in your own practice should that fast recognition be trusted, and where should it give way to the read-back again? Write a few lines for yourself — there is no answer key.

    Reveal answer

    With practice the read-back condenses: the expert does not walk the equation each time; the whole pattern comes to mind at once (an illness script). The aim of this book is that when that recognition forms, it rests on the mechanism. A script built on the mechanism is one you could still take apart and justify if asked, and it can correct itself; one built only on surface patterns comes to mind for look-alikes and breaks on the atypical. Trust the fast read on the ordinary and the classic; go back to the read-back, step by step, when the case is atypical, high-stakes, or when the pattern comes to mind too easily. (Clinical Reasoning, Ch 10; Ch 6 §6, encapsulation.)